22 October 2004
Does journalism warp reasoning?
How does this happen? How do trained and professional journalists write editorials that, day after day, seem to defy common sense?
This week a soldier with a nickname right out of a mid-20th century, all-American sit-com, Staff Sgt. Ivan "Chip" Frederick, pleaded guilty to eight of 12 counts of abusing Iraqi prisoners.
Frederick admitted that he knew his behavior — including the attachment of wires to a prisoner to make him think he could be electrocuted — was wrong at the time he engaged in it. His admission earned him a sentence of eight years in prison, and the judge stripped him of rank and pay.
If a noncommissioned officer in the Army repeatedly and openly does what he knows is wrong, his actions suggest he has little fear of punishment. Frederick said an Army investigator encouraged him and other guards to mistreat prisoners and prescribed various abuses, which they enthusiastically exceeded.
If a sergeant knows prisoner abuse is wrong, the senior commanders in Iraq should have recognized wrong when they were apprised of it by Red Cross workers in Iraq.
Also disturbing, Frederick had worked at a Virginia state prison. Other reservists at Abu Ghraib had experience working in U.S. prisons. War warps human behavior, but the link argues that audits of prisoner treatment in the United States are in order.
Excuse me while I stare at the editorial with my jaw agape. Of course the public was disgusted with what happened at Abu Ghraib, but the public also knew, unlike so many professional journalists, that it was an isolated incident and not reflective of our military as a whole. And what is this "war warps human behavior" statement? Where is that from and what does it mean? Should everyone who has ever served in a war be considered warped and be barred from society?
Let's try this: if some journalists, like Stephen Glass, Jayson Blair, Jack Kelley, Janet Cook and Dan Rather, sully the profession of journalism through lying, plagiarizing, and promoting stories containing fake backup, should we then condemn the journalism profession as a whole? No. That's not what we are supposed to do. Here is what the Chronicle's editors told us after the Dan Rather faked memo problem exploded:
Conservative critics of the mainstream news media will attempt to tar the daily press, as well as ABC and NBC, with CBS's sins. The network's unprofessional behavior draws attention to the three broadcast networks' loss of audience and prestige, but CBS blundered on its own.
CBS's sins shouldn't tar the daily press. All right.
What if some newspapers and publishing companies are being investigated about circulation numbers, should we suspect all newspapers of inflating their numbers? Apparently not, because the editors haven't written an editorial on the Enron-like scandal within their own industry:
Ordinarily, the press gives a hot-diggity-dog ride to corporate corruption stories. If it's a banking, real estate, or stock market swindle, it wins multipart coverage on Page One [unless it's the Enron scandal in Houston -- the Chronicle missed that one]. But, despite the fact that newspapers are a $55 billion business, the press has largely tamped down the circulation scandal, burying its scant coverage in the business pages.
But the editors DO think that this soldier's actions, which are obviously not representative of 99% of our fine military men and women, should lead to a nationwide audit of conditions in U.S. prisons.
Think about that.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/22/04 06:15 PM |
21 October 2004
Dinosaur media in action
The Chronicle regularly reports what I call "olds" (news that's out of date by the time it makes it into the daily).
I'm not sure what to call this little blurb from Rich Connelly in the Houston Press:
Was it Microsoft run amok, or was the Houston Chronicle getting all subliminal with its hatred of George Bush's foreign policy?
We don't know. All we know is that the lead editorial October 12, on the recent Afghanistan elections, contained this sentence: "Exit polling and international observers predicted that Interim President Hamid Crazy would win election with more than 51 percent of the vote."
Well, sure he's a winner -- he's got a great '80s-nostalgia theme song, from the Fine Young Cannibals: "He's Ha-mid Crazy -- whoop, whoop…"
That was only noted by this blog -- and then picked up by the Wall Street Journal's OpinionJournal -- way back on October 12!
In internet time, that's like years.
Come on, dinosaur media! Get yourself up to speed and find some NEWS to write about!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/21/04 11:51 PM |
Houston Press covers Vo/Heflin race
Josh Harkinson reports on the Hubert Vo/Talmadge Heflin race for state representative.
He includes these observations from UH political science professor Richard Murray:
"Most people think Harris County is going to flip from Republican to Democrat," explains University of Houston political science professor Richard Murray, "but the question is when it's going to happen. Politicians like Heflin are kind of like the canaries in the mine."
And for the Democrats, Vo could be the chisel that strikes gold. The 48-year-old former factory worker and convenience store clerk has become one of the party's greatest hopes for a new beginning, in a race that reflects the rapidly shifting political bedrock in urban Texas.
Murray sees an upset in the works. "I think he's going to win."
Like the rest of the local dinosaur media, Harkinson neglects to identify Murray as a finally out-of-the-closet Democratic partisan. Murray's a straight shooter and a good academic, but readers deserve to know that he's no longer just a political science professor talking about politics.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/21/04 11:37 PM |
Food and drink (10-21-2004 edition)
Houston's food and drink writers have been busy this week!
Robb Walsh goes in search of dumplings.
Alison Cook praises the Third Ward's Soul on the Bayeaux.
Brian McManus checks out reported trouble at the Lancaster Bistro.
Dai Huynh catches up diners on various restaurant news about town.
And finally, Gracie Ochoa treks all the way out to FM 1960 to check out Celluci's Pub.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/21/04 09:42 PM |
Live music roundup (10-21-2004 edition)
I usually link to David Cobb's weekly roundup of live rock music in Houston, but he hasn't posted one this week.
The local rock scene is not really one that I follow, so I'm not going to try and duplicate Cobb's effort and screw it all up. Instead, here's the usual roundup of the Americana/alt-country/Texas music that I follow more closely.
Thursday, October 21
Mando Saenz, Mucky Duck
Friday, October 22
Jesse Dayton **, Mucky Duck
Phil Pritchett, Firehouse Saloon (Texas High Life opens)
The Gourds, Fitzgerald's
Ian Moore, Sidecar Pub
Asylum Street Spankers, Continental Club
Saturday, October 23
Ray Wylie Hubbard, Mucky Duck (Shake Russell for the late show)
John Evans **, Firehouse Saloon (cd release party)
Bleu Edmonson, Sidecar Pub (Matt Davis opens)
Peter Case, Anderson Fair
Blanco's probably has something good going on too, but they don't make it very easy to check.
As always, check with the venue before heading out, as schedules can change at the last minute.
** John Nova Lomax penned a nice column on Jesse Dayton and John Evans in last week's Houston Press.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/21/04 09:18 PM |
Stinky's Pig Farm
Some stories are too good to pass up, like this one:
Magnolia resident Bill Bailey said his two piglets are more than just pets — they are his first step toward turning his 5-acre homestead into a pig farm to protest a developer's plans to surround his land with a 580-acre subdivision.
Bailey said he is protesting Magnolia Ridge because the developer — Austin-based John Kleas Co. — bought the properties to the north, east and west of his five-acre lot at 38928 FM 1774, but never approached him with a deal.
He said he made the real estate broker handling the sales an offer of $350,000, but was turned down.
Jane Miller, project manager for the 580-acre commercial and residential project, between FM 1488 and FM 1744, said the company turned down Bailey's offer because the price was too high.
"We would entertain another offer, but not at that price," Miller said.
"We encourage him to contact us."
I'll bet they do! Bailey's calling it Stinky's Pig Farm. That's one way to get a developer's attention.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/21/04 03:54 PM |
Chronicle editorial pages: facts not required?
Recently the Chronicle published an opinion column purporting to show that during President Bush's time in office, abortions have increased, perhaps even soared. This, the author speculated, is attributable to Bush's economic policies that make it harder for women to keep their babies.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/21/04 01:28 PM |
Safety is no accident
METRO posted a curious press release on their website yesterday:
METRO Breaks Own Safety Record Third Year In A Row
Oct. 19, 2004For the third year in a row, METRO has set a new record for safety, posting its lowest number of accidents ever per 100,000 revenue miles.
During FY 2004, the Transit Authority logged .83 accidents per 100,000 miles, down from record years of .89 in FY 2003 and .99 in FY 2002.
The new figures represent a 33% decrease in METRO's accident rate since 2000.
"Safety is no accident at METRO," said President & CEO Frank J. Wilson. "All of our employees go to work each day with safety as their number one priority. We are dedicated to being the safest system in the country.
The buses must be running much more safely this year, given the frequent MetroRail crashes. Or maybe there's some convoluted reason light rail crashes don't count that Lucas Wall can explain to us.
(Update) Now we get it. We've not heard any reports of Metro buses killing anybody this year. So by that standard alone, it's been a safer year.
Posted by Callie Markantonis @ 10/21/04 12:20 AM |
Council shelves expensive Tasers, for now
KPRC-2 reports that City Council today voted to put off a decision to purchase nearly $5 million in Taser equipment, a priority that we criticized last week.
Council member Addie Wiseman sounded a familiar theme:
"Personally, I believe we need more police officers out on the street. Here, we're being asked to spend millions of dollars. We're having to borrow money to make this purchase," said Addie Wiseman, a Houston City Councilwoman.
Onetime conservative Michael Berry, on the other hand, is disappointed that Council is reconsidering the expenditure:
"I wish we could have passed it today, but I think some people felt like they needed some more information. I've had my questions answered. I feel very comfortable with it. I'm a huge proponent of this Taser technology and I think we need to move forward with it," said Michael Berry, of the Houston City Council.
Rumor has it that that Councilman Berry also likes cotton candy and lollipops. A whole bunch!
Television reports showed that Police Chief Hurtt is still not wearing the HPD uniform.
MORE: Coverage from KTRK-13 and KHOU-11.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/21/04 12:00 AM |
20 October 2004
McLane begins to lower Beltran expectations
Sports Business News calls attention to the following line from a Dale Robertson column that I missed last week:
According to team officials, the Astros need to rally past St. Louis and win their first pennant to turn a for-real profit this season.
The Astros enjoyed record attendance of more than 3 million fans this season. It is difficult to imagine that the team is in any real danger of not turning a profit.
But you just knew that at some point owner Drayton McLane would start lowering fan expectations regarding Carlos Beltran, who's going to cost some team plenty after his tremendous postseason performance.
Here's hoping for a big game from Beltran tomorrow, so we can continue to see him in an Astros uniform for at least one more series.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/20/04 11:38 PM |
Fjetland says the strangest things
House Majority Leader Tom DeLay (R-Sugar Land) surprised bloggers, media, and fellow candidates when he appeared at a candidate forum yesterday after much blogger speculaton suggested he would not.
Kristen Mack's coverage had this entertaining line:
"I didn't think he was going to be here," [independent candidate Michael ] Fjetland said. "If I had known, I would have prepared better, but I winged it. If he didn't show up, he realized he was going to look bad."
That sort of preparation must surely inspire confidence in voters.
Fjetland has been saying all sorts of entertaining things lately. In a recent blog interview with Charles Kuffner, he noted that he hoped a post-DeLay Washington would be more civil:
With DeLay gone we might be able to get back to some kind of civilized behavior in Congress.
With no apparent sense of irony, he then proceeded to call DeLay names:
My only regret will be if the bastard gets back in.
[snip]
Any replacement won't be as bad as that power drunk moron.
Fjetland practices a strange form of "civilized behavior."
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/20/04 11:28 PM |
Chronicle again mischaracterizes Rosenthal position
It was hardly a shocker that the Chronicle endorsed Harris County DA Chuck Rosenthal's opponent
Rosenthal is one of the Chronicle's "bad guys," almost certainly because he's a tough prosecutor who believes strongly in the death penalty.
What was a shocker, although perhaps it shouldn't be at this point, is that the editorial page continues to characterize Rosenthal's position on the crime lab unfairly:
Rosenthal refuses to stand aside to allow the sort of independent investigation needed to restore faith in the system.
That's a more carefully worded version of the letter that this blog forced the Chronicle to correct just a few days before this endorsement came out. That letter actually contended that Rosenthal opposes an independent review of the crime lab, when in reality the Chronicle's own reporting notes that he supports an independent review.
Further, I followed up with Rosenthal, who explained that he actually had called for a Blue Ribbon Review panel to review the crime lab (which Judge Robert Eckels supported but then-Mayor Lee Brown opposed), and that he later wrote to then-police chief Joe Brashears urging a review of the entire crime lab. He admits that he has refused to recuse himself "unless there was evidence that any of my staff was involved in wrongdoing" and contends he's just doing the job he was elected to do. He has also opposed a "Cleveland plan" style review, contending that it is not appropriate to Houston's circumstance. Those last two points are certainly fair game for honest debate, but to characterize Rosenthal's position as outright opposition to an independent review is not honest.
The Chronicle can certainly endorse whatever candidate it prefers for various offices. However, one would hope for a little more integrity from the editors than continuing to mischaracterize the views of a politican they clearly dislike.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/20/04 10:43 PM |
The Chronicle weighs in on redistricting
Two days ago, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a two-sentence order that remanded a series of related Texas redistricting cases back to a lower court for "further consideration."
In short order, local blogger and attorney William Dyer explained in a lengthy post what the decision meant, and why it's not much of a "victory" for hopeful Texas Democrats (despite major media characterizations to the contrary). His post came only a few hours after the decision, and is well written and reasoned.
Today, the Chronicle came out with a staff editorial that is neither well written nor well reasoned.
It begins as follows:
One of the arguments against redrawing congressional districts more often than once every 10 years is the endless litigation and unwanted uncertainty that inevitably result. The U.S. Supreme Court action Monday sending the Texas redistricting case back for review confirmed nothing in the law. However, it proved that the litigation over redistricting would last beyond the November election.
I can't even figure out what the second sentence means. Or what the writer even intended it to mean.
This seems to be the main contention (to the extent I can find one):
The redistricting plan, which required one regular session and three special sessions to pass, gives the Supreme Court justices plenty of cause for concern. The redrawn district map is outlandish on its face and suspect in nature.
Outlandish on its face? Only to those who dislike it, one supposes. The courts haven't found it "outlandish on its face" or on its merits, and seem unlikely to do so.
The Chronicle goes on to offer something that finally does at least resemble an argument:
The fault of the new district map is not that it threatens to shift six seats in Congress from the Democratic to the Republican column. As Texas is so heavily Republican, a Republican advantage could have been gained without doing so much damage to communities and common interests. The plan's demerits result from the legislative majority's complete disregard for the state's need to have a strong, experienced, knowledgeable, effective delegation in Washington — a delegation in which each member is familiar with his constituents and their needs.
To summarize, the reason the editors contend the new map is "outlandish" is because it does "so much damage to communities...." We have to give the Chronicle credit for coming up with a unique new twist on a tired topic. We tend to think of communities in terms of neighborhoods, and schools, and families, and neighbors, and shared experiences. At Minute Maid Park during Game 5 a few nights ago, for example, I felt like a genuine part of the Houston sports community! I feel like a part of a different community when I walk my dog and see neighbors. But I've never been out and about in Houston or anywhere else, and thought to myself "Darn that Tom DeLay for destroying my sense of community by obliterating Chris Bell's Congressional district!" What a novel new argument against redistricting.
Even more amusing, the Chronicle urges "strong, experienced, knowledgeable, effective" representation in Washington -- yet itself endorsed an environmental lawyer from the minority party over the House Majority Leader who just flexed his muscles in delivering a sales tax deduction for many Texans who itemize their federal income taxes. But Tom DeLay is a "bad guy," so that probably trumps the other considerations. It's hard to know from day to day with Chronicle editorials.
As we say frequently, if the Chronicle wants to write childish left-of-center editorials that frequently don't measure up to the best work by bloggers (on the left and the right), that's certainly the newspaper's prerogative. But one would think it might cause Jeff Cohen some concern that a post by a blogger only hours after a Supreme Court decision beats any commentary that has appeared on the Chronicle's news or editorial pages on the topic so far.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/20/04 10:07 PM |
Music update: Bob Schneider at the Mucky Duck
We normally provide a roundup of live Americana/Texas/alt-country type music on Thursdays, but sometimes venues will sneak in an interesting Wednesday show.
Tonight, Bob Schneider will be playing the Mucky Duck at 8:30 ($15, nonsmoking).
It might be advisable to call ahead to check on seating.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/20/04 08:40 AM |
Flu vaccine shortage blame
In an entirely predictable development, Cragg Hines blames the Bush administration for the flu vaccine shortage that the media is busy whipping into near-hysteria:
In May 2001, four months into the Bush administration, Janet Heinrich, director of GAO's health care division, testified before the Senate Special Committee on Aging. The title of her statement could not have been clearer: "Steps Are Needed to Better Prepare for Possible Future Shortages."
Heinrich's testimony was an eerily exacting guide to what is now afoot.
"Manufacturing difficulties could occur in the future and again illustrate the fragility of current methods to produce a new vaccine every year," she said. "Compounding the problem is that when the supply is short, there is no system to ensure that high-risk people have priority for receiving flu shots."
On Tuesday, Heinrich was far from pleased that her forecast has come to pass. "This has been a long-standing issue," she said matter-of-factly.
And then Hines says:
The Bush administration has blamed the current vaccine shortage on virtually everyone but itself.
A favorite whipping boy is, of course, trial lawyers and liability suits against pharmaceutical houses. So, it's interesting to note that the National Vaccine Advisory Committee said in a report last year that shortages in vaccines against childhood diseases "do not appear to be liability-related."
Okay, Cragg, what is the reason for the shortage? What did the Bush administration actually do to cause a shortage, in an election year? Did you do any digging into what the root cause might be?
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/20/04 08:25 AM |
19 October 2004
Who will pay for Houston's own Central Park?
Mayor White has announced plans to acquire land near the George R. Brown Convention Center, part of his broader plan to create a large, downtown park:
Mayor Bill White announced today that he has completed negotiations with Crescent Real Estate Equities, Ltd. Partnership to acquire 5.29 acres of land for a major new central park in downtown Houston. The new central park would entail over $35 million in private contributions, and amount to more than 13 acres. This acquisition will consolidate the City of Houston’s ownership of the “Superblock” in front of the George R. Brown Convention Center and a block immediately to the west, all of which will be made into an urban park to be opened as soon as late 2007.
“Great cities preserve land for public plazas, parks and gathering places for the future,” said Mayor White. “We now have an opportunity - probably our last opportunity as a city - to create a place like that for us in Houston’s central core. A new major park will be an enduring legacy for our efforts to improve Houston’s quality of life.”
Eighty percent or more of incremental funds required to complete acquisition and development of the park will be raised from private sources. Design and development will be accomplished through a private/public partnership.
Mayor White currently is working with a number of interested individuals and organizations to secure the private funding required for site acquisition, design and construction. The schedule calls for site acquisition to be complete by the end of 2004, pending City Council approval of the project and agreement with those private funders.
It's good to know that Mayor White is already acting to implement his park project even though City Council has apparently not yet approved it. And it must be reassuring for taxpayers to hear that tired promise that someone else will fund "most" of an exciting new project.
Mike Snyder adds this tidbit:
The city's contributions would come from hotel and entertainment tax revenues rather than property taxes, White said.
Hotel and entertainment tax revenues may be an unsteady source of funding for the Mayor's new project, if recent history is any guide.
That's not to say that the mayor's proposal doesn't have its appeal. His presentations are always appealing. But this proposal needs to be reconciled with other priorities in the city, by all the city's relevant elected officials. That means City Council needs to be engaged fully, and the cost to taxpayers needs to be spelled out more clearly.
MORE: Coverage from KTRK-13, KHOU-11, KPRC-2, and the Houston Business Journal.
(10-20-2004 Update) Mike Snyder has additional coverage here.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/19/04 10:10 PM |
Demagogue on Sunday, "objective" journalist the rest of the week?
Clay Robison penned a typically shrill column for the Chronicle's editorial page this past weekend, and one that is highly reflective of his worldview.
Here is an excerpt:
While controversy continued to swirl last week over Texas' poor record in protecting abused children, Gov. Rick Perry was in Dallas bragging about a major cause of the problem.
In a speech to the National Center for Policy Analysis, a conservative think tank, Perry touted "limited" government and his role in perpetuating it in Texas.
"I believe there is not only a limited role for government, but also a legitimate role for government," he said, patting himself and the Legislature on the back for bridging a $10 billion revenue gap last year by squeezing needed services rather than raising state taxes.
Excuse me, governor, but abused children have had about all the limited government that they can stand. So have frail, elderly Texans with no one to look after them.
This is the sort of demagoguery one hears from the minority party in Texas all of the time, especially on blogs. As we've noted time and again, if the Chronicle is determined that staff editorials shall be childish and simplistic, that's entirely the prerogative of the editors (although one wonders why even have an editorial page at all if the newspaper's resources and vaunted trained journalists cannot produce higher quality than the better left-of-center blogs in the state).
In any case, the problem with Robison is not so much the substance of these columns, but that as he's serving as hyperpartisan weekend editorialist, he also serves as the head of the Chronicle's Austin news bureau.
It boggles the mind that the newspaper expects readers to believe that Robison can engage in such partisan flamethrowing on weekends, yet cover the majority party and politicians in the state capital fairly during the week.
A quality newspaper would make him a full-time editorialist and find a more credible newsman to run the Austin operation.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/19/04 09:24 PM |
Turning to Dallas for local sports coverage
KHOU-11's newspaper partner (the Chronicle) must be pleased to know that the television station's website is running a really great newspaper column on Astros manager Phil Garner.
There's only one problem.
It's a newspaper article by Dallas Morning News columnist Kevin Blackistone.
I's a pretty good read, better than anything in today's Chronicle actually.
Now, KHOU and the Dallas Morning News are both owned by Belo, and various Belo media entities share this kind of content frequently. Still, one has to think the folks down at 801 Texas Avenue can't be too happy that their "partner" television station turns to the Dallas newspaper for opinion columns on the local sports scene. They should, of course, be even less happy about the quality of their own sportswriters.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/19/04 08:54 PM |
Food problems at UH
Chartwells, the company that holds the food service contract at UH, is under fire from students:
"The students as a whole are not gung-ho happy," RHA President Russell Payne said. "However, they have acknowledged that there have been improvements."
Students' concerns ranged from pricing in convenience stores to their inventory.
Some of the loudest complaints, however, had to do with sanitation and customer service.
Advertising junior Phong Chau said employees handling the food, such as those working at Taco Bell in the Satellite, never wear gloves.
"For the price I pay," Phong said, "I expect so much more."
The district manager for Chartwells, showing that all those years of management training have really paid off, responded:
However, Chartwells Resident District Manager Nick Iula said gloves aren't required by the sanitation department and are not encouraged by Taco Bell.
"If an associate has a glove on and picks his hair, it's the same as if he picked his hair without a glove on," Iula said. "Chartwells has never had one confirmed case of food-borne illness."
Oh, that's disgusting! Food handlers should not be picking their hair or anything else, while they are working.
Callie, get Marvin on the phone, pronto.
The good news is UH students needn't worry. Iula is on the case and says that once the company's contract is renewed, there will be big changes:
Iula said the company has a number of plans for continuing to improve its service -- but they're being kept secret so they are not copied by competitors.
"There will be changes made that you won't believe," Iula said.
(emphasis added)
Iula should probably be more concerned with current hygiene issues, such as employees picking their hair while working, rather than his super secret future food improvements.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/19/04 01:44 PM |
Beldar explains yesterday's U.S. Supreme Court sentences
Rob Booth calls attention to this Chronicle/AP coverage of yesterday's two-sentence U.S. Supreme Court order regarding Texas redistricting, and local blogger William Dyer's analysis of that order.
Dyer's analysis goes well beyond the AP coverage, and is yet another example of the important ways that intelligent bloggers have begun to supplement (even supplant) dinosaur media. Few journalists are intellectually equipped to analyze complex cases of election or business law, but plenty of bloggers are quite comfortable doing so. Indeed, Dyer's brief discussion of Texas redistricting in his comments section is enlightening in its own right.
Keep an eye on blogs like his, in which the posters bring special expertise to a range of topics. They're the new alternative media, and many of them are quite good. In this case, the analysis beats that Chronicle/AP dispatch hands down.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/19/04 09:39 AM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]