11 March 2005
HISD releases TAKS results
HISD has released TAKS results for third and fifth graders, and the news is mixed:
HISD third-grade students performed well on the TAKS reading test this year, with 83 percent passing the English version of the test and 79 percent of Spanish-speaking students passing—even though the State of Texas made the test harder to pass this year.
But the news is not nearly as good at the fifth-grade level, where 62 percent of HISD students passed the English version of the TAKS and 68 percent the Spanish version.
“The passing standard was higher this year, but still about 8 out of 10 third-graders passed the test. That’s good news. But the fifth-grade scores are more disappointing, and clearly we have a lot of work to do at that level,” new HISD Superintendent of Schools Abelardo Saavedra said.
First, congratulations to HISD and students for the third-grade results. Those are some nice scores, on a harder test.
As for the fifth-grade results, we have already seen that Dr. Saavedra is very focused on improving education in HISD. This year's results are undoubtedly a disappointment, but I'll be interested to see if, under his leadership, those scores rise over the next several years. I imagine they will, if he is allowed to do his job and isn't hindered by the naysayers.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/11/05 08:52 PM |
Chronicle finds a connection between Mel Gibson and Hitler
So, why is the Chronicle in a troubling and declining circulation trend? Why does the paper make a Top 10 list of newspapers that rely on "freebies"? Stories like today's on the recut Passion of the Christ are most likely a factor.
It's a head-shaking "news" story, filled with assumptions, distortions, editorializing and anti-Christian bias. If the reporter, Jeannie Kever, has even a rudimentary understanding of Christianity or Christians, it doesn't come through in the story.
I'll single out two passages. First:
Sister Mary C. Boys, a professor at Columbia University's Union Theological Seminary, was one of four Catholic scholars asked by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops to review an early version of the script. Publicity over their fears of an anti-Semitic backlash inadvertently helped promote the movie.
Even now, Boys worries "that we're going to have a whole generation of people who will grow up thinking this is how it went down, and that's how Jews are."
News reports suggest there has been an increase in anti-Semitism, both locally and worldwide, over the past year, although Martin Cominsky, regional director of the Anti-Defamation League, says there is no proof the movie was behind it.
Those are three incredible paragraphs. According to Kever, the Passion stirred "fears of an anti-Semitic backlash" that the ADL admits it can't prove. So WHY report it? Rumors. Possibilities. Potentials. Is the "professional" media supposed to report facts or fan rumors? Is this an example of an "ideal state"?
But it gets so much worse:
Historically, passion plays have sparked violence against Jews, most spectacularly when Hitler invoked the passion play enacted by the Bavarian village of Oberammergau after attending a 1934 performance.
Hitler. The Chronicle reporter has to add a comparison to Hitler.
In case there is a really good explanation for that comparison, I emailed the reporter and the Chronicle's reader representative. So far, I haven't heard back from either of them, but if I do, I'll be sure to add an update.
RELATED: Oh no, here come the pogroms again (Orrin Judd)
UPDATE: Jeannie Kever responds to my email:
The paragraph was not a comparison between Hitler and Mel Gibson; it was an explanation of why Jews have historically worried about the fallout from Passion Plays.
Jeannie
I'm not sure why Kever felt the need to explain "why Jews have historically worried" about Passion Plays, with Hitler as the example. This movie is a rerelease. Since Christian anti-Semitism didn't materialize when the Passion was first released, why bring it up? Are Christians who have seen the Passion the biggest threat Jews face today? Hardly. Evangelical Christians are among the biggest supporters of the Jewish people and Israel.
UPDATE 2: Owen Courreges comments.
KEVIN WHITED ADDS: I was so stunned to see that article that I forwarded it to my friend Orrin Judd, who frequently is my muse. Certainly, Kever's writing is set up to insinuate that Gibson's movie is behind an increase of anti-Semitism in the world and locally, even if she produces a quote that says there is no evidence for any such thing. As for the increase of anti-Semitism globally, that is a fact, but some of the most disturbing incidents seem to be coming in post-Christian, secular (but increasingly Islamic) Europe. Locally, the source of the anti-Semitic incidents reported at the end of last year is undetermined, but nobody has thus far suggested it was a clan of Christians motivated by Mel Gibson's movie. Kever's insinuation is reckless. Whether it was intentional or not is not relevant. It made it into print past an editor (one presumes) with her name on it, and it reads as it reads.
As far as the reference to Hitler, I think I would simply refer Kever to Orrin's observation -- it's not as if Hitler was a devout Christian who was inspired to exterminate Jews after watching the Passion. Indeed, historically we have referred to Hitler accurately as the anti-Christ.
And I'm still puzzled by this statement at the beginning:
Last year's success of The Passion of the Christ foretold the red state-blue state electoral vote divide as the nation's culture wars played out at the box office.
Kever provides no evidence for this assertion, which seems silly on its face. Christians are prevalent throughout the nation, and boosted gate receipts for this movie, yes. But Christians don't exclusively vote for one party, or exclusively live in states that went for Bush. It's this sort of amateur editorializing in news coverage that the Chronicle needs to find some way to eliminate. Not only is it erroneous, but it just doesn't belong on the news pages.
Professional journalists frequently criticize bloggers for making "assumptions." I would bark back at professional journalists that some of their number need to check their own assumptions, and need to write much more carefully.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/11/05 11:31 AM |
The mystery of the mustache, solved
A downtown statue has a new look, and the statue's artist isn't pleased:
David Adickes showed up Thursday at downtown's Lyric Center with Groucho Marx eyeglasses and a fake nose. But though the Houston sculptor's face was clownish, his mood was anything but jovial. High above him, an ebony slash crossed the face of his ivory-toned concrete statue of a cellist, The Virtuoso.
Someone had painted the musician's mustache black.
"My first thought was that somehow a graffiti dude had scaled the body 30 feet and sprayed the mustache," Adickes said. But he soon learned the paint job had been ordered by the office tower's managers.
"They don't have the right to abuse, debase or radically change the concept," Adickes fumed Thursday. "They can't leave it like that. It's hideous. It's Groucho Marx. ... You can't paint a mustache on the Mona Lisa."
[snip]
The cellist's mustache was blackened several weeks ago as workers employed by U.S. Property Management repainted the artwork, which sits on the plaza of the office tower at 440 Louisiana, as part of routine maintenance. Adickes said he learned of the alteration from friends.
Jason Davis, president of U.S. Property Management, said he made the decision to paint the mustache black but offered no further comment. He did not indicate if the mustache will again be painted white.
El Capitan of Baboon Pirates came across this mustache-mystery last week. It doesn't seem right to mess with the sculpture that way, but we'll have to see if the property management company will reverse course.
It is a cool-looking statue, though, with or without the mustache.
KEVIN WHITED ADDS: I hear echoes of Howard Roark in Adickes' complaints, to which I'm completely sympathetic of course.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/11/05 08:26 AM |
Rangers complete evidence audit
Last night, KPRC-2 reported that an initial audit by the Texas Rangers and HPD of some 280 boxes of "forgotten and misplaced evidence" had been completed.
According to the KPRC report, which included a reaction from Harris County DA Chuck Rosenthal, there were no big surprises in the evidence:
HPD asked the Texas Rangers to monitor the lab and help classify 280 boxes of previously lost evidence found in a police property room in August. Some of that evidence dated back to 1979.
The audit was completed on Feb. 28. It showed all of the evidence was available to defendants at the time of their trial.
The audit also showed that 82 percent of the evidence was properly catalogued. Most of the mistakes with the remaining 18 percent involved labeling errors, officials said.
Steve McVicker's coverage that appeared in today's Chronicle did not include any reaction from Rosenthal.
It is worth noting that before the Rangers stepped in to move this process along, Mayor White and Chief Hurtt had drawn criticism from several quarters, including the same Chronicle editorial board that usually serves as a PR firm of sorts for policies favored by White/Hurtt, for dragging their feet on crime lab issues. Hurtt in particular was blasted then by state legislators for stating that he was hoping to get cracking in earnest on the problem in April!
Of course, the chief has had other priorities, such as Tasers, red-light cameras, and his own uniform issues, so perhaps we should just be thankful that the Rangers were able to bail out White and Hurtt on this one.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/11/05 08:19 AM |
10 March 2005
Food and drink roundup (03-10-2005 edition)
There's no restaurant review from Alison Cook this week, but it's an otherwise informative week from Houston's food and drink reviewers.
Robb Walsh finally abandons the French obsession with a review of Himalaya Restaurant, and a feature on chef-inspired cocktail drinks.
Dai Huynh returns with her restaurant news after an absense of a few weeks.
Ken Hoffman checks out the version of Hooters chicken wings now available in the freezer section of some grocers.
And Gracie Ochoa visits the Mezzanine Lounge.
Happy eating and drinking this weekend!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/10/05 11:17 PM |
Uneven coverage of Bush international/legal moves
Yesterday, the Chronicle's D.C. bureau reported on President Bush's executive order that certain Mexican nationals on death row have their cases reviewed to see if they were harmed by failure to notify them of a "right" to contact consular officials (a "right" asserted by an international tribunal), and the newspaper ran another, longer story. Four Chronicle reporters contributed to the two stories.
The other shoe soon dropped, as the Bush Administration announced that it had withdrawn from the optional protocol related to the disputed international tribunal. Chronicle reporters must have been occupied, as the newspaper went with a reprint from the New York Times. Actually, let me correct that. The Chronicle chopped the New York Times version roughly in half. Maybe they needed the space they saved for one of those informative boxes they've added to try to make the newspaper more attractive to idiots (I don't have a print version in front of me, so I can't really say -- readers are free to offer their guesses in the comments).
At least the editorial board had the good sense to leave this topic alone. The last time they tackled it, they conjured a nonexistent treaty out of thin air to try to make a point -- and make a point they did.
UPDATE (03-11-2005): I spoke too soon, as there's a house editorial on this subject today. At least they got the name of the treaty right this time, even if the accusation that the Administration's stated reason for pulling out of the protocol is akin to a "Martha Stewart defense." If the terms of a treaty -- or in this case an optional protocol -- are interpreted contrary to a signatory's understanding, of course withdrawing from said treaty (or protocol in this case) is and should be an option of American foreign policy! That has nothing to do with Martha Stewart. The Chronicle's anti-death-penalty obsession sometimes can lead to strange conclusions. But as I said, at least they got the name of the treaty right this time. Baby steps.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/10/05 10:48 PM |
Chron: UT women are ugly?
Two days ago, we noted a headline and a synopsis that didn't seem to match in the Chron online edition.
Today, there's another problem with a headline in the online sports section. I've grabbed a partial screencap of it:

Please note the very last hyperlinked headline.
Now, I'll openly admit that I'm not exactly a UT sports fan. But I would never call UT women ugly, even by mistake.
Maybe the Chronicle's new motto should be "Houston's leading entertainment source," because that one was good for a chuckle.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/10/05 09:51 PM |
Study says Chronicle's circulation trend isn't great
Editor & Publisher has a story about a Prudential Equity Group study on newspaper circulation that found that circulation is declining:
The Prudential Equity Group issued a biting 72-page report this morning on the state of circulation and found that both quality and quantity continue to decline.
Among other findings, the report said that "other paid" circulation was up 34% in the last reporting period, which it labled "troubling."
[snip]
The Prudential report found that total average daily circulation across the 50 papers was down 0.7%. [...] Though the overall drop seems slight, the firm looked at other aspects of circulation, mainly full-paid home delivery and full-paid single-copy sales, and found the declines to be more dramatic, at 2.5% and 6.8% respectively.
The Chronicle was rated and it didn't fare so well:
The report found the Boston Globe and the Denver Post racked up the most (negative) points with a CQ score of 7. The Houston Chronicle and Denver's Rocky Mountain News followed with 6.
At the other end of the quality scale, scoring an explemary 1 point, were: USA Today, The Washington Post, St. Louis Post-Dispatch, The Press-Enterprise in Riverside, Calif., the Contra Costa Times in Richmond, Calif., the Akron (Ohio) Beacon Journal, and The Knoxville (Tenn.) News-Sentinel.
The Chronicle has previously received recognition for circulation "freebies."
And how was the study constructed?
The report ranks the papers from worst to best based on quality circulation, defined as "consumers seeking and paying for the paper." Low-quality circulation is defined as "copies not paid for by the individual recipient ... the reader is most likely less engaged in the newspaper."
The firm used 10 criteria to create a "circulation quality screener" to measure and score the papers. Some of the criteria include: Decline in total average paid circulation; decline of 5% or greater in full-paid home delivery; full-paid single copies have declined 10% or more; discounted copies represent 5% or more of total circulation and have increased 5% or more; other-paid circulation represents more than 10% of total circulation; and 10 or more days were omitted from daily circulation averages.
A paper received a point for every one of the ten criteria it qualified for. The more points, the more troubling the circulation trend, in Prudential's view.
Some of us would say that in the Chronicle's case, a troubling circulation trend is not terribly surprising.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/10/05 05:16 PM |
Did they use Elmer's glue?
KPRC-2 has a story about counterfeit money being used in the Houston area, and apparently it has an identifiable characteristic:
Rodgers said the funny money is unique because it is printed on two different pieces of paper and glued together.
Two pieces of paper glued together?!
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/10/05 04:18 PM |
Metro's disappearing "Startling Facts"
Metro's "Startling Facts" press release, which entertained me over the weekend, has mysteriously disappeared from Metro's site. But Metro is no match for the power of Google, so here's the cached press release.
I don't understand why it isn't there anymore, unless someone decided it wasn't a good idea to give out the 2004 ridership number, which showed a decline from 2003, in a press release designed to tout Metro. We'll have to wait and see if the promised "Startling Facts" brochure materializes.
(I searched Metro's site pretty thoroughly. If the press release has been moved to another section, please feel free to point it out to me.)
UPDATE (03-28-2005): The Google cached press release is no longer available. The "Startling Facts" have just disappeared!
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/10/05 10:58 AM |
Time Mag glowingly covers MetroRail
One of our commenters points out that Time Magazine has a little something on MetroRail:
A rare and exotic species has found its way to Houston of late. Known in other cities as pedestrians, the carless creatures are suddenly appearing along a vibrant 7 1/2-mile stretch of the city, thanks in large part to Houston's new light-rail system. Any new visitor to the city would do well to see them in action--and join them for a ride on the new rails and a stroll around town.
Any new visitor would also do well to avoid being hit by one of the new light rail trains along a 7 1/2-mile stretch of the city.
Where to begin? Pick your spot. Reliant Park, a popular convention site, is on the Metrorail route, close to Reliant Stadium (home of the Houston Texans and the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo). So are the hotels and high-rises of Houston's downtown business district. Near the northern end of the rails lie the Toyota Center, where Yao Ming's Rockets hold court, and Minute Maid Park (known locally as the Juice Box), where Roger Clemens pitches.
The Metrorail also goes deep into the heart of Houston's museum district. The Museum of Fine Arts and the Contemporary Arts Museum are on Bissonnet Street, adjacent to the rail. Also nearby: the Menil Collection--one of the country's most distinguished troves of 20th century art, in a serene, minimalist setting--and the Rothko Chapel, designed by artist Mark Rothko and home to 14 specially commissioned works in undulating shades of black, gray and violet.
And don't forget the food. Bank Jean Georges at the Hotel Icon, a lavishly restored former bank, sits less than two blocks from Preston Station on the Metrorail. Part of the culinary empire of chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten, the restaurant is a temple to gorgeous, delicious food. Golden, ruby red and candy-striped beets brighten a simple salad; Texas blue crabs star in a sublime crab cake. For a more casual, festive evening, try Bossa, near the Main Street Square stop, which offers zesty pan-Latin fare and has a hopping bar scene. Afterward, stride down the block and across the street to Sambuca Jazz Cafe on Texas Street, where you can hear live jazz and sample a California-heavy wine list.
While the Metrorail may pose little threat to Houston's status as a concrete paradise, it is a great alternative to downtown's scarce and expensive parking. A one-day Metrorail pass is just $2 (if anyone bothers to check your ticket), and several stations have their own parking lots. Of course, taking a walk in Houston means leaving the air conditioning behind. You've been warned.
Woops! The Metro press release appears to have gone a bit off the rails there by pointing out that MetroRail isn't too concerned with checking fares. That's because Metro is more interested in body counts than fare counts.
And that last little jab at Houston heat is really annoying. Yes, Houston summers are on the warm and muggy side, but they're not any worse than Washington, D.C., Florida, or Phoenix summers. Yeah, I know, Phoenix is a dry heat. Trust me, when it's 115 degrees outside, low humidity means nothing. And Houston often has wonderful weather the other three seasons, unlike many parts of the country.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/10/05 10:37 AM |
We're Number Ten!
The Houston Business Journal calls attention to a Popular Science study that ranked Houston tenth as a metropolis for technology, ahead of all other cities in Texas.
The methodology and ranking of cities typically thought of as tech cities seem a little unusual, but I guess we'll take the positive publicity regardless.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/10/05 07:45 AM |
09 March 2005
Chronicle celebrates "local" hero
On the day of Dan Rather's final broadcast, the Chronicle was practically gushing over their local hero.
Mike McDaniel, who has been chirping less than critically about Rather for a while, was boosting a documentary on Rather in today's newspaper.
Mickey Herskowitz, who co-authored a couple of books with Rather, can barely keep his composure in this puff piece.
The funniest part of it all, though, is that as Houston's only newspaper was busy celebrating the "local" hero today, Rather himself was apparently so tuned in to Houston that he didn't think Houston's smoking ban had any relevance to a story on a new report linking breast cancer to secondhand smoke.
Even though the Chronicle chose to treat Rather as retiring hero, the internet fortunately offers many more perspectives than Houston's only newspaper. If that continues to be the case, Houston's only newspaper will probably continue to see its influence decline.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/09/05 09:40 PM |
Total smoking ban voted down (Updated)
According to this Chronicle story, Council has voted down the tougher smoking ban and is now contemplating the mayor's proposed version:
Houston City Council today rejected a proposal to ban all smoking in restaurants, and took up Mayor Bill White's compromise proposal to ban lighting up in restaurants but not restaurant bars.
The 10-3 vote, with two members absent, was on a proposal by Council Members Shelley Sekula-Gibbs and Gordon Quan, who offered it as a compromise on their earlier measure to ban smoking in all restaurants and free-standing bars.
The story also has a bit more on the impact a total ban might have had on the city's convention business:
Jordy Tollett, president and CEO of the Greater Houston Convention & Visitors Bureau, said the city would lose the annual convention of the Retail Tobacco Dealers of America in July 2007 if the council passed a total ban. The convention would pump as much as $10 million into the local economy and fill as many as 12,000 hotel rooms, he said.
"We're not a No. 1 tourist destination," he told the council's Neighborhoods, Housing and Redevelopment Committee earlier this week. "We're fighting for every convention we can ... A total ban is going to cause us hardships. It's economics for me."
Tollett said the city also could lose other prominent conventions under such a ban because convention organizers sometimes want the option of providing separate smoking areas for those who attend.
[snip]
Tollett said a complete smoking ban likely would dissuade a small percentage of conventions from coming to Houston. But he said this could still hurt the city's hopes to double its convention business in the wake of renovations to the George R. Brown Convention Center and the opening of the city-owned Hilton Americas-Houston convention center hotel.
Sekula-Gibbs told Tollett that a complete smoking ban would bring four conventions to the city for every one that would be lost. Tollett disagreed, saying he would support a total ban if that were true.
UPDATE: Council has now approved Mayor White's plan that bans smoking in dining areas of restaurants, but allows it in bars.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/09/05 11:49 AM |
Promote smokefree restaurants instead of creating new regulations
Today, supposedly, City Council will vote on a smoking ban, unless there is another tabling of the measure.
The Chronicle editorial board has come out in favor of -- you'll be so surprised -- a tougher ban than what Mayor White has proposed.
The Greater Houston Restaurant Association argues that no government-recognized study shows secondhand smoke in restaurants is unhealthy. But there are plenty of studies showing secondhand smoke is hazardous almost anywhere it is encountered. Restaurants do not inhabit a separate, pathology-free universe, nor do they operate outside the laws of physics.
[snip]
The object of regulating air quality is not to accept and set in stone Americans' high cancer rates. Studies showing that restaurant patrons and workers get cancer at the same high rate as other people are no excuse to tolerate unhealthy air, whether outside or in enclosed spaces where Houstonians spend much of their time.
Studies, studies, studies. Certainly we have learned by now that if someone has an agenda, someone can also find a study to promote that agenda. Yes, there are studies that say secondhand smoke is harmful. There are also studies that say it isn't. And there are people who have disproved the studies.
But I especially like the editors' reasoning in the bolded sentence: even if studies don't show a higher rate of cancer for restaurant workers and customers, there is still no excuse to have unhealthy air, so sayeth the Editors from On High.
How come the editors never once suggested that Houstonians who don't want to be exposed to secondhand smoke visit the website of the Harris County Health Department, where there is an extensive listing of all smokefree dining places in the Houston area?
Isn't that a less heavy-handed approach -- promoting smokefree establishments -- as opposed to forcing every restaurant and bar to bow to the wishes of some (30) anti-smoking advocates? I bet if you put it to a vote of the citizenry, a smoking ban would be tough to pass.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/09/05 08:24 AM |
08 March 2005
Chron editorial board values some life
Earlier, Anne Linehan called attention to the Chronicle editorial urging the killing of people who become so inconvenient they can't feed themselves.
However, we do have to concede that there was indeed balance on the editorial page and even among the house editorials today.
That pro-death editorial was matched with a pro-life editorial of sorts:
Last week's tragic killing of an Italian intelligence officer and the wounding of the captive journalist he had freed was but the latest in a series of fatal encounters between U.S. troops and vehicles carrying innocent passengers, including Iraqi civilians and security personnel. The suggestion by freed Italian journalist Giuliana Sgrena that her shooting might have been deliberate is absurd. Lack of communication and the fog of war are almost certainly the culprits. But the U.S. forces at an impromptu checkpoint fired in error.
The latest bloodshed provides a dispiriting reminder that two years after the U.S. invasion of Iraq, the main artery between downtown Baghdad and the airport remains unsecured and one of the most dangerous places in the world. However, following the success of the Iraqi elections, and with the resultant air of imminent self-government, the terrorists seem to be losing the all-important battle for hearts and minds. To make sure the insurgents continue to lose the sympathy of the Iraqi people, U.S. forces must use extreme caution in engaging unidentified moving targets.
According to this report in Newsday, the troops in queston claim they did not fire in error, but fired in complete accord with established rules of engagement, and shot to disable the vehicle by targeting the engine block. The Chron editorial effectively asserts they are lying.
The broader point of the Chron editorialists seems to be that innocent journalists must be spared at almost any cost, even if the vehicle of a given journalist speeds recklessly to a checkpoint in a country that still suffers from car and other bombs intended to kill U.S. soldiers.
It's revealing what life the Chron editorial board values (potential terrorists, death row killer guys) and what life it does not (U.S. soldiers, impaired people who cannot feed themselves, babies in the womb).
RELATED: Italy didn't plan safe escape for hostage (Rowan Scarborough, Washington Times), Run a well-marked checkpoint with armed troops, get shot (Laurence Simon).
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/08/05 11:37 PM |
Latest news/talk radio ratings trickle out
We've already mentioned the latest local television ratings that saw KHOU-11 news surge ahead of the competition.
We've not yet seen complete ratings for local news/talk radio, but we have gathered a snippet or two.
A trusted source tells blogHOUSTON that for the 25-54 demographic in the January ratings period, 3pm-7pm weekdays, the major talk stations pulled the following ratings: KTRH-740 (3.8), KPRC-950 (2.8), KSEV-700 (0.9).
We haven't been able to obtain raw data, but if we're able to do so, we'll do something similar to our last detailed post on local radio ratings.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/08/05 06:01 PM |
Shall we believe the synopsis or the headline?
Sometimes, it seems as if the Chronicle's left hand doesn't work very well with the right hand.
Today's story on Rick Perry's transportation plan provides an example.
The headline on today's online metro/state page: Bumpy road ahead for Perry's transportation plan
The synopsis just below the headline on that page:
The Trans-Texas Corridor, Gov. Rick Perry's grandiose vision of future transportation, is expected to take the fast lane toward reality this month.
Bumpy road or fast lane? Who knows? Maybe the fast lane ends in a bumpy road. Or perhaps the bumpy road leads to the fast lane. Just for the sake of posterity, we've preserved the fun here, since things like this are sometimes stealthily corrected.
Regardless, whoever put up such a punny synopsis in the first place should have keyboard privileges taken away for at least a week.
More substantively, Charles Kuffner isn't pleased with the article.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/08/05 05:43 PM |
Chronicle: Let murderers live, but allow innocents to die
It's a highly inconsistent editorial board that would celebrate the end of death sentences for convicted murderers, but complain that innocents who have no voice are not being put to death faster.
And yet, that is the Chronicle editorial board for you.
Last week the editors threw a journalistic party (four editorials at last count!) because the Supreme Court decided teenage convicted murderers cannot be sentenced to death.
Today the Chronicle editors decry keeping people on life support. You know, innocent people whose big crime is that they can't speak up for themselves. The case of Terri Schiavo is used in the editorial and the editors apparently feel that her life isn't worth saving because they did not specifically say she should be allowed to live.
The editors do, however, pass on one big falsehood:
Schiavo remains on life support as the legal maneuvering continues.
No, she is not on life support. She breathes on her own. She does need a feeding tube for meal times, but that's because her husband, who is trying so hard to kill her, won't allow her the rehabilitative care she needs so she could be taught to feed herself. Rehabilitative experts have testified before the judge in charge of the case, that Schiavo most likely could be taught to feed herself, but again, her husband won't allow it.
(By the way, would the Chronicle editors advocate the starving to death of death row inmates as punishment? Because that's what will happen to Schiavo if her husband gets his way -- a slow, painful death, over the course of a couple of weeks. We have laws against people doing that to animals, but it's okay for Schiavo, apparently.)
Have the editors done any research on Terri Schiavo? Have the editors seen the video of her interacting with her parents? She is not on life support and she does not appear to be in a vegetative state, as many like to claim.
Yet the editors cannot bring themselves to urge that the judge turn over Schiavo's guardianship to her parents. Why? Why not advocate for her to live? Why not err on the side of life? The editors have no problem advocating for the lives of convicted murderers, even going so far as to do complete puff piece makeovers of death row inmates.
We also know the editors are big proponents of abortion so this sentence is unsurprising:
All too often, the painful decision of life and death in such cases is landing on a court docket, where judges are faced with another right to life issue that shows signs of becoming politicized along the fault lines of abortion.
The protection of innocent life is as much a political/legal question as a moral one. Why should only supporters of abortion -- the killing of innocent babies -- have their way in our political and legal system?
Here are the last two paragraphs of the editorial:
Also, billing the state for the medical costs of maintaining life support for patients involved in litigation might provide an incentive for judges to swiftly rule instead of dragging their feet.
Physicians and medical institutions should have their judgments on life support cases double-checked by impartial sources as part of the process of convincing a terminally ill person's support group that everything possible has been done to save them. If relatives prove incapable of making a rational decision, then courts must be willing to enforce the law, no matter how personally disagreeable the judge might find that duty.
All Terri Schiavo's family wants is the right to help her live. They are not asking for the state to pay for her to live. They are asking the state to ALLOW her to live, so that THEY might take care of her. It's an act of love and an act of life, not an act of state welfare. The Chronicle editors may simply be so used to pushing state welfare that they can't tell the difference.
And I would like to know how the editors define "rational decision." If the Chronicle editors are deciding what is and isn't rational, we should all be very, very fearful.
KEVIN WHITED ADDS: To follow that last point -- you bet! Isn't it wild that the crowd that supports abortion and opposes common-sense laws like parental notification on the grounds that NOTHING should come between a doctor and a patient now insists that the political system needs to create some method for "impartial sources" to intrude in the relationship between loved ones, a physician, and a patient unable to make decisions, to the point of mandating when it's okay to give state sanction to a death sentence that a family is otherwise unwilling to make?
What a ghastly worldview that treats an innocent but impaired human being as being so inconvenient as to merit worse treatment than one's leftovers!
Since the editorialists like to lecture us mere bloggers on ideal states, let me bark back a little about this atrocious sentence:
Physicians and medical institutions should have their judgments on life support cases double-checked by impartial sources as part of the process of convincing a terminally ill person's support group that everything possible has been done to save them.
The "them" doesn't actually have a clear antecedent, but the intended antecedent seems to be terminally ill person. That's singular, so the "them" should actually be "he" or "she" or "he or she." Those who would lecture about editorial idealism should demonstrate better mastery of grammar.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/08/05 03:58 PM |
Landry's had a roaring fourth quarter
Tilman Fertitta should be happy with fourth quarter results for Landry's Restaurants:
Casual dining and seafood restaurant chain Landry's Restaurants Inc. said Tuesday that fourth-quarter profits rose to $12.3 million, or 47 cents per share, compared with $1.5 million, or 5 cents per share, in the year-ago period.
Wall Street expected the Houston company to earn a mean estimate of 22 cents per share, according to six analysts surveyed by Thomson First Call. Landry's (NYSE: LNY) added that its quarterly earnings got a boost from record revenues and higher restaurant-level margins. The results also included an income tax gain of $18.5 million.
Quarterly sales rang up at $259.8 million, up from $254.1 million in the same quarter of 2003.
For full-year 2004, the company turned a profit of $66.5 million, or $2.39 per share, on sales of $1.2 billion, up from a 2003 profit of $44.9 million, or $1.59 per share, on sales of $1.1 billion.
Does this mean more white tigers for the Aquarium? Or how about the "primate lounge, complete with captive bred orangutans or endangered mountain gorillas," that the Chronicle suggested a while back?
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/08/05 03:33 PM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]