28 October 2005
A sports column just waiting to be written
Friend Tom Kirkendall picks up on a theme we've sounded here previously -- the fact that Texans GM Charley Casserly has been nearly immune to criticism until very recently.
Kirkendall goes on to refer to Chronicle columnist John McClain's previous fawning over Charley Casserly, and writes:
I would like to read an article by Mr. McClain that is based on thorough research that details the personnel choices of Mr. Casserly, compares those choices to alternatives that were available at the time of such choices, and analyzes why the choices that were made have come together to make the Texans the laughingstock of the NFL.
That's a great idea that we'll second, with one caveat: It doesn't have to be McClain. Any sports columnist who wants to tackle the topic is fine by me.
And why not? It's a good story just waiting to be written, and one that fairly cries out for treatment by a professional sports journalist with the research tools and time to do it properly.
Banjo Jones has gotten things off to a good start. But a truly comprehensive column would look into potential free agent signings over each year, potential salary cap impact, alternate draft picks, and the like.
How about it, local sports writers?
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/28/05 05:19 PM |
Chron runs chopped AP coverage of base closures
Today, the print version of the Houston Chronicle and Chron.com both ran an edited version of an Associated Press story on a House vote on base closures that will affect Ellington Field locally.
The fact that the Chronicle D.C. bureau did not cover this story of local relevance is about what we've come to expect. The editing of the AP story is also curious.
Beneath the [Read More] link, I've posted the original AP story as posted by the Fort Worth Star Telegram. The bolded portion represents what the Chronicle and Chron.com chose to cut from their versions.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/28/05 04:59 PM |
Neighborhoods complain about graffiti; Mayor continues to "review"
The Chronicle has posted two "This Week" stories that cover Houston's worsening graffiti problem.
Kim Jackson reports on discussion of the problem at a Spring Branch meeting:
Spring Branch civic association members, police and government officials agreed last week to join forces to discourage the spread of gang membership and graffiti.
About 75 residents and a panel of state and local officials threw out several ideas and potential solutions to the problems at a town hall meeting focused on curbing the spread of gangs and graffiti in and around northwest Houston.
First on the list, several said, is the total elimination of graffiti, which often attracts other blight, and gang activity into an area.
"I am the father of a son who got sucked into the gang culture and it almost ruined his life," said Greg Rudichuk, a Spring Branch Oaks resident.
"All parents out there should know we must clean up our neighborhoods and keep them clean in order to keep the gangs out."
Tom Manning reports on the problem in the Heights:
Dean Swanson's bus route is getting shorter and shorter.
Since his retirement, Swanson, a Heights resident, has been operating Houston Heights Historic Tours, a bus tour of the neighborhood that gives visitors a chance to see some of the historic buildings in the Heights and hear the stories behind them.
But lately, Swanson said he has been forced to alter his tour routes because of the increase in graffiti that's been appearing on buildings in the Heights. It's a problem that continues to increase, he said, and one that he wants to see stopped.
"I'm getting ashamed of what I show people," said Swanson, who lives in the 800 block of Harvard and is also the Restoration-Historical Committee Chair of the Houston Heights Association. "I have to avoid certain places because there are things people don't need to be seeing."
In August, Swanson said he sent a letter to Mayor Bill White's office with some 20 addresses of buildings that fell victim to graffiti vandals in the previous two weeks. Not only did he say that he hardly received any response to his inquiry, but since then, the problem has gotten worse.
"The only response I got was from the former captain of Central Patrol, who said he forwarded it to the new captain and the gang unit," Swanson said. "I just wanted to see what they can do, but I haven't heard anything."
Graffiti eradication simply isn't a priority for Mayor White and his Council.
Both "This Week" stories cite HPD Assistant Police Chief Brian Lumpkin on the matter. Here's Manning's version:
When graffiti is reported to police, they forward the report to both the police department's Neighborhood Protection Corps and the city's Anti-Gang Office.
Graffiti that is reported by residents via the city's 3-1-1 Help Service Line is also reported to those entities.
"We're responsible for giving notice to buildings that have graffiti," said Assistant Police Chief Brian Lumpkin, who runs HPD's Neighborhood Protection Corps. "We play a role in identifying graffiti on private property, particularly property that doesn't have anyone there."
Once notice has been given on a property, the owner has 30 days to remove the graffiti. If that doesn't happen, the city will step in and remove the graffiti and, according to Neighborhood Protection's Web site, a lien will be placed on the property in order to recover the cost of doing so.
Judging by the explosion of ugly graffiti all over town, this system is obviously not working. And given the amount of graffiti that now covers the public infrastructure of the city, one would think it might become a priority for Mayor White, his Council, and his police chief.
If only they could figure out how to turn it into a revenue-stream possibility!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/28/05 04:21 PM |
Houston-area trees worth $205 billion!
KUHF-88.7 reports that the Texas Forest Service has completed a four-year study of Houston's trees and determined the value of our beautiful green canopy:
It took over four years, but the Texas Forest Service was able to count the trees in Houston and actually put a monetary number on what they're worth. According to the report, there are 663 million trees in the 8-county Houston region valued at over $205 billion. Pete Smith is the partnership coordinator with the Texas Forest Service. "That speaks volumes as to what they're really worth. That's just in the landscape. $456 million of annual environmental benefits, that's a big number. We really didn't have a good idea that trees were worth that much to us," he says.
Smith says the trees store $721 million worth of carbon and remove over 60,000 tons of air pollution every year.
The report points out that while Houston has an impressive urban forest canopy, 17-percent of those trees have been lost since 1992, a total of around 78 million trees. The losses are due in part to changes in how land is used and also because of invasive species of trees that are wiping out other species. Texas Forest Service Director Jim Hull says philosophies are changing. "In the past, maybe there could have been some things done that would have maintained some of these trees, but we're really looking now at establishing a baseline for the future," he says.
Save the trees! In my own little corner of Harris County we are losing more and more trees. Developers raze every last tree on a parcel of land to build something. Why? Why not save some, even if it's only around the perimeter? We are watching as a huge stand of trees is slowly being bulldozed on FM 2920 at Falvel Road. Also, various sections of land along Gosling Road are losing trees. Especially confounding is a new subdivision called Gosling Pines where there is not a single pine tree left standing! In fact, the development's landscaping includes...a few crape myrtles.
Trees add so much...it just kills me that many developers are short-sighted and find it easier to bulldoze them all.
RELATED: Trees for Houston
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/28/05 08:36 AM |
Houston's property tax "cut" (wink, wink)
City Council voted to cut Houston's property tax rate on Wednesday and Matt Stiles reported on the disagreement over whether or not it's really a tax cut:
The council cut the city's tax rate by a quarter of a penny. But a new state law, passed with the goal of increasing elected officials' accountability to homeowners, forced the council to declare formally that it had raised taxes, since rising property values will bring in more city revenue.
The new rate — 64.75 cents per $100 valuation — means the owner of a $100,000 assessed house will pay the city $518 in annual property taxes with a typical 20 percent homestead exemption. The previous rate was 65 cents per $100 valuation, under which that homeowner would have paid $520.
The vote came after a contentious, 90-minute debate about whether the action amounted to a tax cut — or whether it was an increase.
"Ultimately, there will be some people whose taxes go up and some people whose taxes go down, because of the actions of the appraisal district, not the city," Mayor Bill White said.
The appraisal district determines the market value of property for taxation.
As Edd Hendee and Paul Bettencourt pointed out yesterday on Edd's morning show, the mayor is being disingenuous. He knows full well what the city's funding wants are and he knows how much the average homeowner's bill will rise each year to help fund the city's wants -- eight to ten percent -- so for him to say that the appraisal district is the bad guy and not the city, well, he knows better. But, of course, he hopes the average Houston homeowner will fall for it and not blame him.
Council members Shelley Sekula-Gibbs and Addie Wiseman voted against the rate cut, saying that it was, indeed, an increase. They also said it didn't provide enough tax relief.
Sekula-Gibbs proposed a new rate of 64.17 cents per $100 valuation. That figure, she said, represented the "effective" tax rate, the amount that would keep revenue level with the previous year minus new appraised properties or exceptions.
The council, by a 10-5 margin, voted against considering her plan, which would have reduced the city's revenue for the current fiscal year by about $9 million, she said.
Wiseman, who had tense exchanges with White and others on the council, was adamant that the panel had increased taxes. She forced Councilman Adrian Garcia, who read the motion with the language required by the state law, to repeat the phrase twice.
"The decision here is to raise taxes, but by a smaller amount," said Wiseman, who later issued a news release describing her "outrage."
The debate grew so tense that Councilwoman Ada Edwards at one point interrupted, saying, "Ms. Wiseman, this is not your meeting. You have to have some respect for the decorum of this body."
The decorum, the process, the tradition. True politicians always value those things above any real substantive debate and action. No rocking the boat!
Good for Councilmembers Wiseman and Sekula-Gibbs. Texas homeowners ARE being run over, trampled on and spit upon, due to this state's broken taxation system. How much longer can governmental bureaucracies strangle the golden goose? We are going to find out.
Sedosi has some thoughts on this looming trainwreck:
The Municipalities? As seen here they are quite comfortable taking in 5-10% revenue increases annually while having a convenient scapegoat on hand to blame for rising tax values.
[snip]
The fact is next year the City of Houston will get a pay raise from taxpayers at a rate that is higher than the Cost of Living Index and population growth. Most of this increase will come on the backs of property owners who are already struggling under increased fuel and food prices.
Some will say that this isn't a problem, that the "issue" is Conservatives wanting to give more to the rich.
Except its not the rich that are going to be forced out of their homes, it's the poor and middle class that are feeling the crunch the hardest.
I would only add to those on-target points that even with a 65-exemption, many of Texas' retired homeowners cannot indefinitely afford property tax bills that increase much faster than their retirement funds do. Soon, very soon, Texas' system will have to be fixed and hard choices will have to be made. Unfortunately, many politicians prefer the ostrich-approach.
RELATED: Doug Miller's (KHOU-11) coverage, which gives the mayor and the city a pass. Miller needs some educatin' on Texas' property tax system with statements like this:
But of course, Houston's booming housing market brings higher home prices and higher home prices generally bring homeowners higher property tax bills.
No. On average Houston-area homes sell for eleven percent under fair market value. Which means that Houston homes are "worth" more than they are selling for. How did they get that higher worth? Appraisal increases that have nothing to do with a home's true worth! Appraisal increases, instead, are based on government funding wants.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/28/05 07:49 AM |
Local bloggers' voting suggestions
Sedosi and Matt Bramanti have each helpfully provided their own recommendations for voting on the proposed constitutional amendments.
The only proposition I am going to opine about here is Proposition 9, and I strongly support a NO vote, like Sedosi and Matt do. Here's Sedosi's take:
Prop 9: The constitutional amendment authorizing the legislature to provide for a six-year term for a board member of a regional mobility authority.
Position: Opposed The thought behind this amendment is that appointees need longer terms to do long range planning more effectively. What is lost here is that most long range planning is handled in 20 year increments, so this would have no effect on its efficacy one way or another. What this WOULD do is make regional transportation authorities even LESS accountable to the public. Some, of course, would view that as a GOOD thing. Of course, these same people tell you that your vote is important to them....
And Matt's:
Proposition 9: Against. Longer terms for mobility board members would only make them even less accountable to the public than they currently are.
Yes. We are looking for MORE accountability and transparency in our governmental bureacracies, not less.
It's also worth pointing out that the Chronicle's editorial board recommended voting YES. How unsurprising.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/28/05 06:56 AM |
Chron endorsements for council districts H and I
The Chronicle editorial board offered more Council endorsements yesterday. It's hardly a shocker that they like the incumbents in District H and District I. They might have posted all of their endorsements prior to the start of early voting, however.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/28/05 06:15 AM |
27 October 2005
Thanks Astros -- it was a wild ride!
Thanks to the Astros for making it to the World Series and giving us all something to cheer about and obsess over.
(now what are we going to do?)
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/27/05 08:58 AM |
26 October 2005
METRO ridership study posted
Further to this post from earlier, the final powerpoint version of the $250,000 ridership study commissioned by METRO is available here. The file is large (roughly 2 MB) and best suited for broadband internet connections.
Thanks to Tom Bazan for being persistent and obtaining the report.
It should have been posted by METRO on their website. For that matter, some of our enterprising local media might well have obtained it and posted it online.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/26/05 08:38 PM |
Metro's September data
Royko beat me to the post -- about Metro's September ridership and fare data -- so I'll link to his comment and point out that Metro's numbers are not encouraging:
-- Train boardings are up, but Metro's counting method is misleading.
-- Ticket vending machine (TVM) revenue is down from September 2004.
-- Bus ridership declined from September 2004.
-- Fare box revenue is down from September 2004.
Is it any wonder Metro has decided to go into real estate development?
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/26/05 11:21 AM |
Metro's $250,000 ridership study
You'll recall that Metro commissioned a study to figure out why bus ridership has steadily declined over the past several years. We've offered our own (free of charge) reasons, but strangely, Metro officials still felt the need to spend $250,000 to figure it out. Tom Bazan got his hands on the study and here is the summary and the recommended fixes:
In order to make significant gains in ridership METRO must…
-- Improve the efficiency of the system – Commuters will not ride the bus if they believe their trip will be longer than if they drove alone.
-- Change the negative stereotype associated with riding the bus – Commuters shouldn’t need to justify to their peers why they are taking the bus.
In a market where 66% of residents are opposed to riding the bus, METRO must find ways to incrementally increase ridership.
-- Target segments of the population open to trying the bus
-- Target segments of the current riders open to riding more frequently
Ways to increase ridership:
-- Improve security at Park ‘n Rides and at stops
-- Improve security on the bus
-- Make it easy to find information on how to use the system, routes, schedules
-- Expand the number of direct and express routes, especially from Park ‘n Rides
-- Add more bus shelters
-- Initiate training for bus drivers focusing on people skills
And there you have it. That's what a quarter of a million dollars bought Harris County residents/taxpayers. Oh sure there are lots of pages in the Power Point study -- 70 to be exact -- but that's the summary.
You'll notice that the study does not recommend cutting bus routes as a means of increasing ridership. Amazing!
I'll add that stories like the one Rad Sallee brought us in August also show why Metro has a bus ridership problem:
Then there's Terrence Wilson, who was paralyzed from the waist down in a motorcycle accident 24 years ago. Wilson, 49, depends on Metro buses and his motorized wheelchair to get around.
Because many streets in his Acres Homes neighborhood lack sidewalks, Metro built a concrete slab on the shoulder for his wheelchair, he said. But over the years, his regular bus was replaced with a circulating shuttle, and then Metro shortened that route. It no longer passes his home, and Wilson said he now rides his chair in the street for a risky 1 1/2 miles to reach the bus stop.
That doesn't seem ideal.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/26/05 09:47 AM |
Floodgates are beginning to open on Casserly
Word must have gotten around the Chronicle that it's now okay to mention general manager Charley Casserly's name in connection with the awful play by the Texans so far this season.
Here's John McClain in today's newspaper:
It's mystifying how a team can fall so far so fast on both sides of the ball. Fans are certain they know who to blame.
Some are sure it's general manager Charley Casserly's fault because he's the one who drafts the players and signs free agents.
Others are sure it's coach Dom Capers' fault because he hires the assistants and approves the offensive and defensive systems.
In truth, the blame for this monumental collapse should be shared equally by Casserly and Capers. That's not a cop-out; that's a fact.
Thanks for clearing that up for us "fans."
Here's some clarity of my own for the bigshot professional sports columnist: Until recently, too many sports journalists in this town seemed convinced Charley Casserly was not at all to blame, if we are to judge by the dearth of criticism from the city's professional sports journalists of the GM's role in putting this terrible team together.
Of course Casserly and Capers are to blame. It's good to see some of our professional print journalists in town starting to come around to that view. It's still not clear why Casserly has merited such hands-off treatment for so long, though.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/26/05 08:32 AM |
25 October 2005
Chron profiles at-large position 1 council race
Matt Stiles continues the Chronicle's recent coverage of local political races with a profile of the contest for City Council's at-large Position 1:
Architect and urban planner Peter Brown is the front-runner in the race for Houston City Council at-large Position 1, but his two opponents say they believe their grass-roots campaigns could make the contest interesting.
Brown, retired Air Force officer Roy Morales and private investigator Michael "Griff" Griffin are vying to fill the seat being vacated by term-limited Councilman Mark Ellis.
Morales and Griffin say they can compete with Brown, who began campaigning six months after his 2003 runoff loss to Councilwoman Shelley Sekula-Gibbs, even though he's out-raised them in campaign donations by hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Brown, 69, said his experience — he's overseen numerous city building and parks projects in Houston and other cities — uniquely qualifies him to accomplish his top goals: neighborhood revitalization and urban redevelopment.
A major force behind the Main Street Coalition, which pushed for the light rail line between downtown and Reliant Park, Brown said he would work to lure more residents back into the city from suburban areas.
The combination of weak opponents, Brown's name ID, and Brown's fundraising are probably going to result in Brown's election, but not everyone in Houston would count the dangerous, inefficient light-rail line as a strike in his favor.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/25/05 10:42 PM |
Metro board meetings on Thursday
Metro board meetings are scheduled for Thursday and the notices contain some interesting items up for discussion. The first item of interest is the second entry in the Finance/Audit committee agenda:
Authorization for the President & CEO to negotiate, execute and deliver a contract for a credit facility for commercial paper
Commerical paper translation: An unsecured obligation issued by a corporation or bank to finance its short-term credit needs, such as accounts receivable and inventory. (We've brought up the issue of Metro and commercial paper before.)
Next up, this is from the Human Resources Committee agenda:
Authorization for the President & CEO to execute and deliver a contract for temporary personnel services
Metro recently announced layoffs.
Then we have this howler from the Operations Committee agenda:
*Status Report on METRORail Fare Enforcement
Well, since Metro's fare recovery rate is considered low by industry standards (15%), that report shouldn't take too long. (Actually, Laurence Simon has a report on fare enforcement.)
And here are the highlights from the Executive Session meeting:
1. Request Board authorization for the President & CEO to negotiate, execute and deliver agreements between METRO and Transwestern Development Company, L.P. dba Transwestern Commercial Services, LLC ("TDC") for a transit oriented joint development project located on the TMC Transit Center.
2. Request Board authorization for the President & CEO to negotiate, execute and deliver agreements relating to a transit oriented joint development project at the Cypress Park & Ride facility.
Hmmmm. We know what the TMC project is. What's going on at the Cypress Park & Ride?
With any luck, some intrepid local media reporter will have a full report on all these exciting agenda items.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/25/05 03:59 PM |
Casserly begins to draw fire locally
Not everyone at the Chronicle is on board with lady sportswriter Emily Davis' assessment that things are looking up with the Texans' offense. Indeed, columnist Richard Justice gets downright mean with Texans GM Charley Casserly on his blog (at least by recent Chronicle standards):
Bob McNair has offered no hint about what he'll do. But if he cleans out the coaching staff without firing general manager Charley Casserly as well, that would be ridiculous.
No matter what you think of the coaches - and it's hard to say anything good - the Texans simply don't have enough good players.
The national media also are beating up on Casserly today:
It's time to clean house in Houston. Dumping offensive coordinator Chris Palmer was only the beginning. At this point, head coach Dom Capers is the next guy out the door and general manager Charley Casserly isn't safe, either. I've said it before and I'll say it again: Quarterback David Carr isn't the only problem on this team. I don't see much help around him -- on either side of the ball -- and that's an issue that goes straight to the front office.
It's a shame that the early years of the Texans' franchise have effectively been wasted because of so many poor decisions.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/25/05 12:12 PM |
Oh my: what was Metro thinking?
You will not believe what Laurence Simon noticed on a Metro bus this morning.
Seriously. Go check it out.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/25/05 09:11 AM |
Alvarado's one-day graduation-status change interests opponent, media
Of all the pressing problems that Houston City Council candidates might be discussing and debating, one wouldn't have thought that Councilmember Alvarado's strange indifference to actually obtaining her college degree would still be news this week.
One would be wrong.
KHOU-11's Doug Miller covered the story last night:
"I immediately started getting all of my paperwork from the alumni. I mean, they don't do that unless you've completed all the hours," Alvarado said.
[snip]
Last week, Alvarado's political opponent found out that she did not actually have the college degree she had always claimed she had earned. So he said someone from his campaign contacted a newspaper reporter, who in turn contacted Alvarado for comment. That was on Thursday. Within 24 hours, the University of Houston had issued Alvarado a college degree.
The University said privacy laws prevent it from saying anything specific about Alvarado without Alvarado's permission and she hasn't given it.
But in a written statement, UH said students were once required to take a written exam before getting their degrees. According to the statement, "the Writing Proficiency Requirement or Exam, was dropped. Since that time, students who had enrolled under earlier degree plans have been allowed to petition to waive this obsolete requirement. Such requests are routinely approved."
"This has happened before and they've been able to resolve it before," said Alvarado.
It has surely happened before, but it's just odd that Alvarado was so indifferent towards actually making sure she had fulfilled the requirements of graduation. As the bolded portion goes, I filed graduation papers one semester before finishing my dissertation and actually obtaining the degree, and that was enough to get me on the Alumni Association mailing list, so that doesn't really explain the indifference.
The Chronicle also ran coverage of this story today, devoting two reporters to it:
Carol Alvarado's opponent continued to call for her resignation Monday, suggesting the two-term councilwoman used political influence to get a University of Houston degree in one day that she had claimed to have had for years.
Alvarado, who dismissed the issue Monday as "negative politics," said she was consulting with personal and UH attorneys about releasing her academic records in response to media questions while still maintaining some privacy.
Meanwhile, a UH System regent said the issue may be something for the board to discuss at a future meeting.
"It does seem strange that it could happen so fast, but I really don't have any information beyond what I read in the paper," said Regent Morgan Dunn O'Connor.
[snip]
Officials in the UH registrar's office Friday morning confirmed Alvarado did not have a degree. By late Friday afternoon, however, other UH officials said she did.
[snip]
Parras said he thinks Alvarado drew on her political contacts and influence to fast-track a waiver of the process that other, less prominent, students could not navigate so quickly.
Being somewhat experienced with how slowly and inefficiently administrative matters tend to move at the University of Houston's main campus, I also find it a little surprising that Councilmember Alvarado's status managed to change from non-graduate to graduate in part of one day. Furthermore, her indifference towards actually obtaining her degree is odd to me. Still, this doesn't seem to merit the amount of media coverage it's getting, especially when there are interesting races for other Council positions.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/25/05 08:06 AM |
24 October 2005
Mack profiles at-large position 2 candidates
The Chronicle's Kristen Mack profiles the candidates vying to replace Councilmember Gordon Quan in the race for City Council's at-large position 2 today.
It's a quick and dirty look at the five candidates, unfortunately, because of the usual space limitations of the print edition.
Wouldn't it be useful if Chron.com beefed up its coverage of local elections with a timely local politics blog?
That's something on the wish list for 2007, I guess.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/24/05 09:41 PM |
How did that make it onto the sports pages?
The Chronicle's David Barron did something that we didn't think was allowed on the newspaper's sports pages today: He criticized Houston Texans general manager Charley Casserly.
Sort of.
Barron didn't actually criticize Casserly himself -- we're not sure if that's allowed on the Chronicle sports pages -- but he did repeat criticism of Casserly seen on the television:
Fox Sports analyst Jimmy Johnson certainly raised some eyebrows with this sound bite: "A long time ago, before I got into the NFL, Marty Schottenheimer once told me not to worry about the team owner — worry about the guy sitting next to him, whispering in his ear.
"So many times coaches are criticized when the blame should fall on personnel. (Texans general manager) Charley Casserly needs to be evaluated for some of the personnel decisions that were made when Dom Capers was there"
Raised eyebrows indeed! Because what would an NFL Super Bowl and college National Championship-winning coach know about these things?
Besides, we also learned from the Chronicle sports reporter Emily Davis today that the Texans' problems on offense are nearly solved after yesterday's 38-20 loss:
The Texans might not like the bed they've made. But they might be able to sleep a little easier now that things seem to be looking up on offense.
The Texans generated six net yards passing yesterday, and 139 yards total.
Apparently there's no reason for any Chronicle sportswriter to criticize Charley Casserly, since "things seem to be looking up on offense."
So if they get seven yards passing next week, will the Chronicle have Casserly in the running for GM of the Year?
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/24/05 09:24 PM |
A light rail editorial sans rose-colored glasses
Of course, it's no secret that the Chronicle's editorial board members are big fans of Metro and specifically light rail. You'll recall these editorial highlights:
At the end of the day, the altered plan will bring several billion dollars of transit improvements quicker than the original plan. Not insignificant, the new plan offers Houston a chance to move ahead in a more united fashion to ease congestion and pollution.
And:
If Metro's proposal would produce public benefits faster and less expensively, why would anyone object? Here is a chance to reduce the government waste that frugal taxpayers decry.
The voters have spoken. Houston needs mobility improvements that include an expanded rail transit component as well as one of the nation's better bus systems. The next time Metro and the majority of voters in its service area say "Jump," their representatives in Congress should ask, "How high?"
Now take a look at an editorial board opinion that isn't colored by wishful thinking:
On Thursday, the Regional Transportation Commission of Southern Nevada unveiled its latest justification for a 33-mile light rail boondoggle that would span the Las Vegas Valley. The county's transit authority hailed a report from the Parsons Transportation Group that says light rail is a cost-effective way to ease traffic congestion.
Although the Parsons group was paid gobs of public money for its work, these consultants clearly didn't consider county taxpayers their clients. If they had, they might have told the RTC's empire builders the truth about light rail: It costs a fortune, it doesn't relieve congestion, it never pays for itself and it actually hurts mass transit ridership.
AdvertisementDon't believe it? Download Randal O'Toole's recent study, "Rail Disasters 2005" at www.reason.org/ps336.pdf.
Mr. O'Toole's research, which is based on more than 20 years of ridership and transit data, exposes light rail cheerleading as delusional.
Cities with successful bus lines get a sniff of the federal subsidies available for mass transit and want a bite. Consultants and bureaucrats provide inflated ridership estimates. Local and state governments then bury themselves in construction debt, convinced that people will abandon their vehicles for expensive, inconvenient trolley rides. When the riders don't materialize, already high fares are raised to cover operational costs and bus service is slashed. Ridership drops, and taxpayers cover the debts.
The RTC and its light rail steering committee have to come to their senses and realize that there are no light rail success stories. The proposed line from Henderson to North Las Vegas is a multi-billion-dollar white elephant that will leave valley taxpayers trampled.
Doesn't the contrast just make you want to cry?
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/24/05 05:05 PM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]