02 November 2005
Time for a new round of Metro bus route cuts
Metro must still think the path to increased ridership includes cutting bus routes, because Metro has a new round of "service adjustments" ready to go:
METRO will conduct two public hearings to receive comments on considered service adjustments for Sunday, January 23, 2006. METRO has scheduled the public hearings for:
Wednesday, November 9, 2005
Noon and 6 p.m.
1900 Main Street
Board Room, Second floor
In the Central Business District/Downtown
At Main Street and St. Joseph Parkway
Location is wheelchair accessible.METRO is evaluating the following route, schedule and facility modifications. Please review the information for any changes that may affect your daily commute.
NOTE: Routes considered for elimination have experienced low ridership for an extended time. In most cases, METRO offers alternate service in the affected areas. By discontinuing low-performing routes, METRO makes the best use of its resources, including your tax dollars, and continues to offer affordable, reliable and accessible service to our community.
I'll put the (very long) list of adjustments in the extended entry, but I do have a question about one of them:
37 El Sol
Sunday - Throughout the day change frequency from 35 to 50 minutes to match ridership demand. Weekday, Saturday, & Sunday - Modified the route to remove it from portions of Glendale, Hanover, and Woodvale (effective 8/14/05).
How is a bus rider supposed to know when the bus will arrive if the frequency changes depending on demand? How does someone plan to get to an appointment or to work if they can't be sure when the bus will arrive?
And remember that more bus route cuts were in Metro's new budget, in direct contrast to the Metro Solutions plan that voters approved, where Metro promised a 50% increase in bus service.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 11/02/05 09:43 AM |
01 November 2005
World-class panhandling
Laurence Simon had an interesting experience with Houston's homeless and METRO.
METRO really doesn't need to commission $250,000 studies to figure out why people aren't enamored of their transportation system. Reading Laurence's blog would cost a lot less!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 11/01/05 09:58 PM |
Cragg Hines isn't a fan of Judge Alito
Matt Bramanti points out today's Cragg Hines column on Supreme Court nominee Sam Alito:
IF you like machine guns, you'll love Sam Alito.[snip]
Alito, a rock star to conservatives who scuttled Bush's nomination of Harriet Miers, is so in the mold of Justice Antonin Scalia, Bush's archetype of a supposedly strict-constructionist justice, that he's known as "Scalito" — little Scalia or Scalia lite.
But Alito need take a back seat to no one when it comes to hard-right jurisprudence.
[snip]
Just as in the machine-gun case, Alito was the lone way-out-there voice on an important point in an already bad 3rd Circuit opinion that Alito would have made even worse.
In upholding a restrictive Pennsylvania abortion law in 1991, even the increasingly conservative 3rd Circuit refused to go along with one of the legislatively approved provisions: to require a woman to notify her spouse, in almost all instances, before an abortion. To emphasize his position, Alito wrote a dissent to spell out his approval of the spousal-notice section.
The Supreme Court said on review that the provision would impermissibly give a man "the kind of dominion over his wife that parents exercise over their children."
So, all you women who want to be ordered about like the kids, sit down right now and urge your senator to get aboard the Alito bandwagon.
Egads! Lock up the kids and pets!
Back when Ruth Bader Ginsburg was nominated to the Supreme Court, Hines was a Chron DC bureau reporter and (you'll be so surprised to learn) he wrote a glowing story about her nomination:
President Clinton on Monday nominated Ruth Bader Ginsburg , a pivotal centrist on the federal appeals court here for the past decade and before that a leading women's rights litigator, to be an associate justice of the Supreme Court.
Clinton, with Ginsburg at his side for the announcement in the Rose Garden of the White House, praised her as "progressive in outlook, wise in judgment, balanced and fair in her opinions."
[snip]
In his announcement, Clinton praised Ginsburg 's effort to bridge the ideological chasm that often splits open the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, generally considered second only to the Supreme Court in national legal prominence.
"Time and again, her moral imagination has cooled the fires of her colleagues' discord, ensuring that the right of jurists to dissent ennobles the law without entangling the court," Clinton said.
[snip]
The president was moved to tears as Ginsburg described her career and family, concluding with a paean to her mother who died after a four-year bout with cancer when Ginsburg was a teen-ager.
It would be nice to get an answer to one of the questions Bramanti keeps trying to get Jeff Cohen to address: Why doesn't the Chronicle have an on-staff conservative columnist?
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 11/01/05 12:32 PM |
Temporary red light camera delay
Red light cameras that were supposed to be in place Tuesday at busy downtown intersections already face a snag.
The cameras designed to catch red light runners were supposed to begin a trial run Tuesday morning, but the five contract companies involved have not signed their contracts with the city. The city wants to put five cameras at five different intersections to catch drivers who speed through red lights.
Violators will be identified from the license plate and will get a ticket in the mail. The cameras should start working in a few more days once the executives ink the deal.
No doubt, Mayor White is carefully checking the contracts for any sneaky shenanigans.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 11/01/05 10:32 AM |
Chron Breaking News: Iran is dangerous
The Chronicle's editors are entertaining (in a clueless sort of way) as today they discover that Iran is dangerous:
AT first, last week's anti-Israel rant by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad seemed like a throwback. On his country's yearly day of solidarity with Palestinians, the Iranian leader told 3,000 young listeners that Israel "was a disgraceful blot" that "must be wiped off the map." Palestinian attacks, he said, would "wipe this stigma from the face of the Islamic world."
Even to Westerners, these poisoned stylings are now recognizable as overheated Islamic rhetoric. But it has been decades since the revolution that spawned the phrase "Great Satan" and advocated smashing Israel to fuel a theocratic frenzy. In the years since, Iran's leaders slowly have distanced themselves from some of those excesses. That such threats have now belched from a head of state — one whose country is trying to enhance its nuclear program — adds menace to this language from the past.
You have to get up pretty early to get anything past the international experts on the Chronicle's editorial board!
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 11/01/05 07:42 AM |
Chronicle still having trouble with proper identification
On Sunday the Chronicle ran a two reporter story on grieving Houston families who have lost a family member to the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. Yesterday, the Chronicle's reader rep, James Campbell, posted on readers' reactions to the story -- apparently the Chronicle is getting an earful:
A Page One story in Sunday's paper is an axiomatic reminder that you can't please all of the people all of the time no matter how careful the reporting. Chronicle reporters Allan Turner and Rosanna Ruiz wrote what I thought was an exceedingly evenhanded piece, Casualties of War, which looked at how six Houston-area families are grieving after losing a loved one to the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.
The story was not about the 2,000th casualty in Iraq. It was not about blaming the Bush administration. It was not about Cindy Sheehan. It was not about being for or against the war. It was simply about grief and how these families are dealing with it.
My problem is that one of the moms in the Chronicle's story wasn't properly identified:
"Please, do not let our heroes become faceless, expendable statistics in history books," pleaded Amy Branham, the mother of one young Houston-area soldier killed in a stateside accident during the buildup. "For those of us who loved them with every fiber of our being, do not let their sacrifice be for nothing."
Amy Branham is also an active member of Cindy Sheehan's group, Gold Star Families for Peace -- she accompanied Sheehan to Crawford this summer -- and a guest contributor for the Houston Democrats blog. In fact, the above quote in the Chron story that is attributed to Branham is taken from a post Branham wrote for the HouDems:
Please, do not let our heros become faceless, expendable statics in the history books. We must remember them, honor them, respect them. For those of us who loved them with every fiber of our being, do not let their sacrifice be for nothing. The citizens of our country owe them that. The leaders of our country who sent them to die in a foreign country, far away from those they loved, owe them that.
And this isn't the first time Branham has been featured in a Chronicle story. Twice in August she was in stories about Cindy Sheehan's PR event in Crawford, once as a featured Houston-area mom who lost a son due to the Iraq war:
Amy Branham
Amy Branham, whose son died in a car accident days before he was to ship out to Iraq, was at Sheehan's side when the protesting mom was suddenly thrust into the limelight as the voice of anti-war sentiment in America.
Branham, of Houston, blames Bush for the February 2004 death of her son, Army Sgt. Jeremy Smith. She said her son never would have been at Fort Hood, near where he died, had he not been going to a war that she now believes is "illegal and unjust."
"When my son Jeremy died last year, I was contacted by the media, and I was so angry about the war and about my son's death, and I blamed George Bush, and I still do," she said. "But I didn't want to make his death into some kind of political thing at the time. I wanted to honor his memory and what he had done in his service for the country.
"But as time has gone on, and more and more information has come out about this war, and the lies and the way information was altered to bring us to where we are now, I just got more and more angry."
Branham said her son believed in the president and believed in his mission, but "I feel that if he were to see what is going on today, he would be very angry like so many people are."
It's past time for the Chronicle to identify Branham properly and completely, so readers can decide for themselves if her opinions are worth considering.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 11/01/05 06:36 AM |
31 October 2005
Robison: Prop 2 proponents really no different from KKK
Clay Robison's Sunday op-ed is some pretty asinine journalism, even considering the source (who's an expert):
STATE Rep. Warren Chisum apparently was surprised when the Ku Klux Klan announced plans to hold a pre-election rally in Austin in support of his constitutional amendment against same-sex marriage.
He shouldn't have been, because flies are attracted to garbage wherever they may find it.Chisum, a Republican from Pampa, isn't a cowardly cross-burner who takes delight in bashing African-Americans and other racial and ethnic minorities. But his sponsorship of Proposition 2 on the Nov. 8 statewide ballot offers the KKK another opportunity to do what it does best — promote prejudice and hatred, albeit of a different brand than produced the racial lynchings of not so many years ago.
I am not equating the debate over whether homosexual couples should be allowed to marry to the long, often bloody civil rights struggle of blacks and Hispanics in America.
But....
I omitted the rest of the sentence that begins "But" because it contradicts the bolded paragraph. Robison is indeed doing exactly what he says he's not doing. Perhaps his frothing produced a shock from his keyboard, thereby causing his confusion.
There are reasonable arguments for and against Proposition 2. And then there is Robison's column, which really isn't the sort of thing one expects to find in a quality newspaper.
Jeff Cohen and the rest of the Chronicle's executive editorial leadership, of course, expect readers to believe that Robison can crank out work like this on Sundays, but serve as a completely objective bureau chief six days per week. That's laughable.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/31/05 09:36 PM |
Chron's Casey has the pulse of GOP and taxes
The Chronicle's lefty metro/state editorialist and gossip columnist wants readers to think he's got the pulse of Republicans and taxes.
Really!
Here's the start of Rick Casey's most recent column of (mostly) unsourced gossip:
A friend of mine is a Republican precinct chairman and a skilled engineer who retired as a high-level executive with one of the big oil companies.He is a very smart man with a very sharp analysis of his tax situation.
Like the rest of us, he has watched taxes on his home rise at a rate higher than inflation, and certainly higher than his income from pensions, Social Security and investments.
Yet he knows that the appraisals of his home that lead to the higher taxes are accurate. Houses in his neighborhood keep selling for more and more.
He could sell his house and net a nice profit. But it's his neighborhood, his home, with room for his children and grandchildren when they come to town for happy visits.
So he won't cash in. He just gets taxed as though he did.
"They're taxing me on my unrealized capital gains," he says of the property tax.
[snip]
My friend the precinct chairman, not worrying about election to higher office, offers a solution that actually would work.
"Rather than have them tax my unrealized capital gains," he says, "I'd rather have them tax my income. Then the tax would be based on what I could actually pay."
As the baby boomers begin joining him in retirement in about two years, when their incomes shrink as their homes become more valuable, my bet is a whole lot of folks will start thinking like my friend the precinct chairman.
If Casey's unnamed friend is as self-centered as many baby boomers, of course he thinks shifting the tax burden to income from property ownership is the way to go! Why not shift his tax burden to a younger generation of workers if he can get away with it, as his own income drops?
Casey continues:
Already, many elected officials, including Republicans, talk off the record about the need to consider an income tax.
Has he been canvassing Republican officials at those Democratic brown bag lunches he speaks at? Or is he just engaged in the usual gossip?
It's really hard to take Casey seriously when he starts telling stories.
We are not yet in a climate where discussing it openly is safe for those seeking office.
Yes, those pesky voters continue overwhelmingly to reject the income tax proposals that are floated by liberal gossip columnists and bloggers!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/31/05 09:18 PM |
Chron's Cohen breaks promise with readers
Way back on August 28, Chronicle reader representative James Campbell tried a gimmick on his struggling blog: Readers could submit questions for editor Jeff Cohen, and he'd post the replies "during the week of September 5."
Matt Bramanti at the Lone Star Times has been trying to get those questions answered ever since.
September slipped by. Now October is gone. We head into November tomorrow.
So Bramanti followed up with Campbell, who responded:
Well, since agreeing to do it, we’ve had two hurricanes and a World Series. I know he was close to finishing the questions I submitted to him but he got sidetracked by work.
Unlike the high-profile position of public editor at the New York Times, the Chronicle's reader representative position seems designed more as a PR position. One doesn't really envy the position of James Campbell, who frequently draws the task of defending the obnoxious (and sometimes indefensible). Still, this is pretty lame even by Chronicle reader representative standards.
Newspapers cover news. If the editor is too busy to answer questions about his newspaper because news has broken out, then he should never have promised to do so way back in August. Because the Chronicle's reader representative is oriented institutionally to putting positive PR spin on executive editorial decisions, Campbell can't really be expected to call his boss a phony over the matter.
But really, the only conclusions that can be drawn are that Jeff Cohen is a phony, and that following through on a promise to readers just isn't that big a priority to him.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/31/05 08:45 PM |
Downtown park public meeting Wednesday
The Houston Downtown Park Conservancy will present design ideas for the new downtown park at a meeting this Wednesday:
The Houston Downtown Park Conservancy will share initial design concepts for Houston’s new downtown park at a public meetings on November 2nd.
Wednesday, November 2, 2005, 6 - 7:30 p.m.
WHERE: Hilton Americas Houston Hotel, 1600 Lamar, Room 340 (third floor)
Open to the public. Admission is free.
Valet service and parking in the Hilton garage is available, and curb parking is free after 6:00 PM.
PREVIOUSLY: Progress on Houston's world-class downtown park (bH), The Bill White Vermin And Solid Waste Memorial Park (bH)
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/31/05 07:24 PM |
Asinine zero-tolerance policies
Chris Baker is discussing this zero-tolerance stupidity coming out of Cy-Fair ISD. (I guess you know where I come down on this issue.)
Zero-tolerance policies (in my opinion) are helpful crutches for lazy school administrators. It makes their jobs easier and reduces the amount of time they have to spend dealing with disciplinary issues.
What if a normally good student who gets good grades and has a record of good conduct accidentally brings an aspirin to school? Of course with today's zero-tolerance policies, that student faces suspension or expulsion. No ifs, ands or buts.
What if a normally good student is tired of getting punched by the school bully and decides to punch back? Of course, the good student is assumed just as guilty as the bully (who has a history of visiting the principal's office) and both serve the same punishment. (My neighbor just went through an incident like that.)
Zero-tolerance nonsense is just one more reason why parents are increasingly disgusted with one-size-fits-all public schools, and it's good to see parents fighting back and Chris Baker giving it some further attention.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/31/05 03:39 PM |
A teensy bit of government truth-telling
This notice is on the city of Houston's website:
Tax Rate Notification
The City of Houston adopted a tax rate that will raise more taxes for maintenance and operations than last year's tax rate. The tax rate will raise taxes for maintenance and operations on a $100,000 home by approximately $5.77.
Mayor White wants Houstonians to know that the preceding announcement should really say "Harris County Appraisal District," instead of "City of Houston."
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/31/05 10:02 AM |
30 October 2005
Texans will not go winless this season
The Houston Texans will not go winless this season, as they managed to stink less than another of the league's worst teams today, and pulled out a three-point victory at home despite generating only 237 yards of offense.
Area Exxon gas stations have been running a promotion for free coffee on Mondays after a Texans win. It's been a very cost effective promotion for them so far this season, but they will have to pay out tomorrow.
As we've noted previously, the local sports media has been slow to blame Charley Casserly for the Texans' woes this season. The Chronicle's Ken Hoffman, on the other hand, is pretty blunt in his latest Q&A column:
Just bought a bottle of chocolate milk and the expiration date was Oct. 31 at 4 p.m.
Are you kidding me -- 4 p.m.? They can now predict the "hour" my milk will turn sour? Do you know if they took into consideration the time change and it will really be sour at 3 p.m. Monday instead?
Bill "Cowboy" Lamza
I got a letter from Reliant Energy explaining why it's asking for a massive rate increase. Here's a way for Reliant to keep its costs down: How about stop wasting money by putting your name on a stadium so a football team can throw only nine passes a game and have an 0-6 record?
The Texans need to do that Scrabble move, where you dump all your tiles and pick new ones — from the general manager on down to the water boy.
I'm sorry, but you're wrong about David Carr. He's got the talent, but he doesn't have the support to help him out. He can't carry the entire team on his shoulders alone. If we could get any sort of offensive line to help him out, things would be much different. Were you at last Sunday's game? Did you see the defense play? Yeah, I didn't either. Say all you want about David Carr, but he's got my support. We need to look at Charley Casserly and Dom Capers.
Julie Swoboda
Actually, I think we don't need to look at Charley Casserly and Dom Capers. They're the biggest parts of the problem.
Ouch!
I'm guessing Hoffman's not going to be getting many media perks from Charley Casserly the rest of the season.
UPDATE (10-31-05): Hoffman needs to take sports columnist Richard Justice to lunch after Justice's latest.
If Capers is indeed fired, we may never know if it was because the players weren't good enough or because he and his coaches weren't good enough.
Hoffman knows, as do most people in town who don't make their living on the Chronicle sports pages. Both Casserly and Capers deserve the blame. They both need to go after the season is over.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/30/05 09:07 PM |
Houston buys $750,000 worth of Metro passes for city employees
Check out what Tom Bazan noticed on last week's city council agenda:
35. ORDINANCE approving and authorizing contract between the City and METROPOLITAN TRANSIT AUTHORITY OF HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS for Purchase of Employee Transit Passes; providing a maximum contract amount - $750,000.00 - General, Enterprise and Other Funds - PASS
And Tom points out that this is not the first time the city has bought Metro passes for its employees.
So it turns out that while the city doesn't have the time to focus on the growing graffiti problem or the funds to address HPD's manpower shortage, there is time and money to help boost Metro's ridership numbers and bottom line.
Maybe this program will someday be in line for an audit by the Controller's office, just to see if the benefits match up to the cost.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/30/05 05:03 PM |
Red light cameras increase accidents (cont'd)
Accidents have increased in Philadelphia, PA, and in Fort Collins, CO, at intersections where red light cameras have been installed.
Also in Fort Collins, one second was added to the yellow light time at an intersection with a red light camera and look what happened:
Both accidents and red light citations dropped by more than half comparing the most recent month's data to the same time last year. Daily ticket revenue also plunged from $3000 to $1125, giving officials cause to delay voting on a new camera to see if revenue will rebound.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/30/05 04:53 PM |
It's full steam ahead at Metro's Real Estate Development Dept.
Last week I wondered what about a development project mentioned in a Metro board meeting agenda:
Request Board authorization for the President & CEO to negotiate, execute and deliver agreements relating to a transit oriented joint development project at the Cypress Park & Ride facility.
Here's the Metro press release with details:
The METRO Board of Directors today approved initial plans for a new 23-acre Cypress Park & Ride on U.S. 290 at Skinner Road, along with transit oriented development - a first for METRO at a Park & Ride facility.
The $31.8 million project, to be developed by NewQuest Properties, calls for a multi-level parking garage with 1,500 spaces and a "Town Square" area with 28,000 square feet of restaurant space and 92,000 square feet of retail space.
The four story, $17.5 million parking facility will be constructed first, and will be paid for by METRO.
NewQuest will then construct the Town Square at an estimated cost of $14.3 million.
The new Cypress Park & Ride will help ease overcrowding at METRO's Northwest Station Park & Ride on 290 near West Road. Also, METRO expects to realize more than $100,000 per year from its share of the development's income.
The project is the second announced by the Transit Authority this month. The first joint development of a transit property will be the $105 million development of the air space above the Texas Medical Center Transit Center.
Oh dear.
Do you think this Park and Ride will have any real security presence, or will non-operational cameras be used?
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/30/05 09:02 AM |
Chron: young people can sink Prop. 2 (and save the Republic!)
The Chronicle's editorial board laments that more young people don't vote, in an editorial about Prop. 2:
The vote on Proposition 2 on the Nov. 8 ballot, a proposal that would ban gay couples' right to legally protect their families, offers young people a chance to make their influence felt.
Eighteen- to 25-year-olds vote at about half the rate of 45- to 55-year-olds, notes Rice University political scientist Bob Stein. Without home ownership, school districts and careers to worry about, the younger age group doesn't feel driven to participate. What a waste. If 18- to 25-year-olds voted their stated beliefs next month, they could show the country that Texans will not stand for bigotry.
(Oooo, a Bob Stein sighting!)
Why does the Chronicle think that if 18-25-year-olds voted their beliefs, they would vote against Prop. 2? Maybe, just maybe, young voters WILL vote their beliefs -- and vote in favor of it! (Even notoriously-liberal California passed a Defense of Marriage Act with more than 60% of the vote.)
The editorial should also include a big non sequitur warning because of the first and last paragraphs:
THE past year has not been very empowering for young adults. Just starting to earn a living and newly eligible to vote, they have witnessed a cavalcade of events beyond their control: disasters in Asia, terrorist bombs in Europe, interminable warfare in the Middle East. At home, officials are under investigation for endangering national security.
[snip]
There's not much voters can do about natural calamities, stateless terrorists or dishonest, unelected public officials. But Texas' young voters can exert amazing leverage on the home front next month. They need to vote — and show that hateful legislation is an embarrassment in 21st century Texas.
Natural disasters, terrorist bombings and dishonest public officials relate to Prop. 2...how exactly?
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 10/30/05 09:01 AM |
29 October 2005
Casey acts as Mayor's PR man on tax increase
The state legislature recently passed "truth in taxation" legislation that requires certain taxing entities to acknowledge that resultant increases in property tax revenues be labeled tax increases if the taxing entity chooses to set a tax rate that effectively produces new revenue. The rationale behind the legislation was to force taxing entities to acknowledge the growing problem of property-tax appraisal creep, instead of simply saying "what can you do?" and blaming appraisal boards. Anne Linehan touched on this in her earlier post on the fireworks in Council earlier this week, when those who favor larger government and higher spending were forced by the legislation to acknowledge they were setting a rate that would result in a significant increase in property-tax revenues.
Chronicle gossip columnist and metro/state Rick Casey, of course, is one of those who favors larger government and higher spending, but rather than simply shoot straight, Casey's style is always to smear and attack those with whom he disagrees. Here's his latest work:
Meanwhile, the two Harris County legislators responsible for the new "truth in taxation" law, Sens. Tommy Williams and Kyle Janek, should have been laughing up their sleeves.Their little scheme has succeeded in forcing local officials to admit to raising taxes while they themselves continue to get a free ride.
Yet Williams and Janek and the rest of the Legislature raised taxes considerably last year. You don't remember? They did it by not lowering the state sales tax.
The result: State Comptroller Carole Keeton Strayhorn announced two weeks ago that monthly state sales tax revenues were up 14 percent from a year ago.
That formulation sounded familiar. Sure enough, in watching the tape of the debate in Council that is the subject of Casey's column, I heard Mayor White use the bolded soundbite almost verbatim. It's not the first time that Casey has shamelessly stolen the words of other people without proper attribution, but one wishes he would be a little more honest with readers if he's simply going to act as Mayor White's PR man.
Substantively, although the soundbite is clever, it's really comparing apples with oranges. Yes, the sales tax rate has been set, and increased sales do indeed produce increases in tax revenues, all things being equal. However, to my knowledge there are no boards that have ever convinced local merchants to raise prices in order to produce a certain amount of revenue in a taxing district (but we have seen some interesting relationships between property taxing entities and appraisal boards), so the comparison starts to break down. Furthermore, consumers can always cut back their spending if they feel sales taxes are excessive. Homeowners have much more trouble cutting down on their property "consumption" if they feel tax rates are too high!
Rick Casey may not like the fact that the legislature has responded to disgruntled property owners by passing "truth in taxation" legislation, but his characterization of the issue as simply a concern of a few activists just doesn't ring true. And, as usual, his infantile attacks on those with whom he disagrees and his carrying water for political favorites really seem more appropriate for the opinion pages, not the metro/state news pages.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/29/05 09:58 PM |
(Revisionist) analysis poses as DC bureau news
Bennett Roth of the Chronicle's underwhelming D.C. bureau seems hardly unable to contain himself over the Libby indictments:
The criminal charges against the vice president's chief of staff are rooted in the controversy over the Bush administration's initial justification for invading Iraq.
With the U.S. military casualty rate in Iraq reaching the 2,000 mark this week and no weapons of mass destruction yet uncovered, the indictments against Lewis "Scooter" Libby could add fuel to the national debate about the wisdom of going to war.
Special Counsel Patrick Fitzgerald said Friday the indictments were "not about the propriety of the war." Nonetheless, the dispute over whether Saddam Hussein had stockpiled dangerous weapons sparked the legal case.
Patrick Fitzgerald says his case is "not about the propriety of the war," nonetheless a Chronicle reporter knows better!
Arrogance and hubris are hardly exclusive to the pols (of both parties) in Washington, it would seem.
Robert Kagan provided a useful corrective in advance of the indictments, in a Washington Post op-ed several days ago:
The Judith Miller-Valerie Plame-Scooter Libby imbroglio is being reduced to a simple narrative about the origins of the Iraq war. Miller, the story goes, was an anti-Saddam Hussein, weapons-of-mass-destruction-hunting zealot and was either an eager participant or an unwitting dupe in a campaign by Bush administration officials and Iraqi exiles to justify the invasion. The New York Times now characterizes the affair as "just one skirmish in the continuing battle over the Bush administration's justification for the war in Iraq." Miller may be "best known for her role in a series of Times articles in 2002 and 2003 that strongly suggested Saddam Hussein already had or was acquiring an arsenal of weapons of mass destruction." According to the Times's critique, she credulously reported information passed on by "a circle of Iraqi informants, defectors and exiles bent on 'regime change' in Iraq," which was then "eagerly confirmed by United States officials convinced of the need to intervene in Iraq." Many critics outside the Times suggest that Miller's eagerness to publish the Bush administration's line was the primary reason Americans went to war. The Times itself is edging closer to this version of events.
There is a big problem with this simple narrative. It is that the Times, along with The Post and other news organizations, ran many alarming stories about Iraq's weapons programs before the election of George W. Bush. A quick search through the Times archives before 2001 produces such headlines as "Iraq Has Network of Outside Help on Arms, Experts Say"(November 1998), "U.S. Says Iraq Aided Production of Chemical Weapons in Sudan"(August 1998), "Iraq Suspected of Secret Germ War Effort" (February 2000), "Signs of Iraqi Arms Buildup Bedevil U.S. Administration" (February 2000), "Flight Tests Show Iraq Has Resumed a Missile Program" (July 2000). (A somewhat shorter list can be compiled from The Post's archives, including a September 1998 headline: "Iraqi Work Toward A-Bomb Reported.") The Times stories were written by Barbara Crossette, Tim Weiner and Steven Lee Myers; Miller shared a byline on one.
[snip]
Many such stories appeared before and after the Clinton administration bombed Iraq for four days in late 1998 in what it insisted was an effort to degrade Iraqi weapons programs. The Times was not alone, of course. On Jan. 29, 2001, The Post editorialized that "of all the booby traps left behind by the Clinton administration, none is more dangerous -- or more urgent -- than the situation in Iraq. Over the last year, Mr. Clinton and his team quietly avoided dealing with, or calling attention to, the almost complete unraveling of a decade's efforts to isolate the regime of Saddam Hussein and prevent it from rebuilding its weapons of mass destruction. That leaves President Bush to confront a dismaying panorama in the Persian Gulf," including "intelligence photos that show the reconstruction of factories long suspected of producing chemical and biological weapons."
This was the consensus before Bush took office, before Scooter Libby assumed his post and before Judith Miller did most of the reporting for which she is now, uniquely, criticized. It was based on reporting by a large of number of journalists who in turn based their stories on the judgments of international intelligence analysts, Clinton officials and weapons inspectors. As we wage what the Times now calls "the continuing battle over the Bush administration's justification for the war in Iraq," we will have to grapple with the stubborn fact that the underlying rationale for the war was already in place when this administration arrived.
Of course, the Bush Administration built its case on multiple factors (WMDs being the rationale favored by Colin Powell and Tony Blair), although those factors are beyond the scope of this post, which is simply to point out that Bennett Roth's revisionist narrative is overly simplistic (and likely ideologically tinged) analysis posing as news coverage.
Kagan's op-ed is worth reading in its entirety.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/29/05 06:48 PM |
Chron obsesses over tired story
The Chronicle devotes yet more column space to the story of Councilmember Carol Alvarado's strange indifference towards actually obtaining her college degree, and the University of Houston's unusual speed in approving her waiver and granting her a degree after her political opponent pointed out her degree claims were inaccurate:
Within a few hours on Oct. 21, Alvarado obtained the bachelor of arts degree, retroactive to December 1992, after her District I opponent, attorney John Parras, distributed UH documents showing Alvarado had not been awarded the degree she had claimed for years.
UH officials said she had failed to complete a writing proficiency exam required to graduate in December 1992, when Alvarado completed her course work.
The writing proficiency requirement since has been dropped, and students who completed all other requirements can receive degrees, [UH Communications Director Eric] Gerber said.
[snip]
Requests for waivers typically are submitted on forms filed by students, but they can be submitted by advisers on behalf of students or simply noted on various documents, said Gerber.
"There is a general approval for the waiver to be granted," he said.
In the case of Alvarado, the waiver was noted last Friday on what is called a graduation certification check list after an audit of her course work.
"Turnaround time can vary widely, ranging from as little as one day to as long as two or three weeks, depending on the complexity of the request being made and the academic records involved," Gerber said.
Gerber said Alvarado's case was straightforward enough to be quickly resolved.
Many of us who have dealt with the University of Houston know from experience that Councilmember Alvarado's experience in getting this matter resolved so quickly is hardly the norm. One can understand that the university would like to accommodate a high-profile local pol as quickly as possible as it's in the university's interest to do so, but it strains credulity for anyone to suggest that the rapid disposition of Councilmember Alvarado's matter is the norm.
That said, this story really is over. Voters surely have enough information by now to decide whether this is anything but a trivial matter, and the Chronicle surely can find some local news that needs to be reported.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 10/29/05 06:14 PM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]


