25 September 2004

Houston Symphony's Zemlinsky interpretation praised

The Chronicle's Charles Ward offers praise for the Houston Symphony's performance of The Mermaid by Alexander Zemlinsky:

For a second week in a row, Houston Symphony music director Hans Graf and the orchestra poured their energy into a lavish performance of a major but overlooked work.

The Mermaid by Alexander Zemlinsky opened Thursday's performance of the weekend subscription series program in Jones Hall. The usual Saturday concert was moved forward to accommodate Yom Kippur, but only a few hundred people heard Zemlinsky's voluptuous interpretation of the Hans Christian Anderson tale about a mermaid who tries to take a human lover but is rejected.

Zemlinksy was a noted conductor and teacher — Arnold Schoenberg was a star pupil — but became one of those unfortunate composers whose music and reputation were obscured by the rush of history, in his case the destruction of tonal music that arrived just after the turn of the 20th century. Only in the past couple of decades has his music resurfaced under the urging of a few conductors, including James Conlon and Riccardo Chailly.

But Zemlinsky's influence was so strong that when Schoenberg got the news his teacher had started writing The Mermaid, he began writing his own post-romantic tone poem, Pelleas and Melisande (as the symphony's program notes observe).

Zemlinsky never abandoned tonality, as Schoenberg did so spectacularly. He retained a deep allegiance to the harmonic tradition that had ruled European music for almost three centuries.

It's interesting that Schoenberg is so much more celebrated (especially, if memory serves, by former music director Christophe Eschenbach, who really put the Houston Symphony on the map) than his teacher, who seems more in line with traditional classical music. Is the choice of Zemlinksy merely reflective of the prior interest in Schoenberg, or a departure? I haven't followed the post-Eschenbach symphony, so I really couldn't say.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/25/04 11:25 PM |


Proving the assertion with itself?

The political scientist in me just got around to a closer look at the Chronicle's predictably screeching house editorial on the indictments secured by Travis County DA Ronnie Earle in relation to the TRMPAC:

Lawyers for the accused argue that the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution trumps Texas law. But if the Constitution supersedes Texas campaign finance law, it would also negate similar provisions in federal campaign finance law. The U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly upheld such laws as constitutional.

Some defendants and their lawyers stipulate that federal law allows corporate money to be used in Texas elections. This is false. Texas has the right to regulate its elections in any constitutional manner it pleases.

The intent here seems to be to confuse readers into thinking something has been proven!

The argument goes something like this: 1) the indicted officials contend that the First Amendment protects their actions; 2) but if the First Amendment protects their actions, it would also negate other federal campaign finance law; 3) but the Supreme Court has upheld federal campaign finance laws; 4) the First Amendment doesn't protect the actions of the indicted officials because Texas can regulate its elections in any constitutional manner.

Talk about circular reasoning! Since the question itself is about whether or not the First Amendment allows Texas campaign finance law to be interpreted as Earle has interpreted it, it's odd to fashion an argument that concludes with an assertion of the point to be proven (item 4) as proof! Because surely items 2 and 3 are so ambiguous as to be disregarded as anything but speculative -- not legal/analytical -- observations. The crux of the debate is over what is constitutional. That is what will be decided in court(s) eventually.

Further, the political scientist in me cringes every time I see a phrase like "Texas has the right...." Texas is not a person. It's a state. The state government of Texas may have powers, but powers are not rights. The Chronicle should be more careful with its use of language.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/25/04 10:56 PM |


The "tax man" speaks out

Paul Bettencourt is sounding the alarm on skyrocketing property taxes:

Tax Collector/Assessor Paul Bettencourt said, "The overall increase on the Houston home was worse than I expected."

Bettencourt says the average home in Harris County costs $3,100 a year in taxes on average. That’s up $1,600 since 1997.

Bettencourt says as home values have been going up, a lot of commercial values have been going down. Meaning overall, homeowners in Harris County are shouldering an ever greater tax burden.

The city of Houston did lower the tax rate this year, but with values up, taxes are actually higher.

"The public needs to remember that they need to be protesting their value whenever they get a case," Bettencourt stressed. "This reinforces that we need tax relief legislation out of Austin."

As Bettencourt points out, even though the city enacted a token rate decrease this year, appraisal creep has kept the total bill increasing steadily. Bettencourt favors lowering the cap on annual appraisal increases from the current 10 percent.

The Harris County Tax Office provides information on protesting assessed property values here.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/25/04 10:18 PM |


Metro's 210 Katy Freeway route latest casualty of service cuts

KHOU-11's Mike Zientek reports on one of the casualties of Metro's decision to cut back on bus services:

Driving is drudgery most of the time on the Katy Freeway. That's why riders of Metro's 210 route let someone else take the wheel when going to work downtown.

For 19 years, it served the West Belt Park & Ride but next month, this ride will disappear.

[snip]

Metro officials say the reason they're eliminating the route is because of the hundreds of empty parking places that are left day after day. Metro's Vice President of Planning says it's costing $240,000 a year to serve an average of only 115 passengers a day. This doesn't mean that he thinks the Park & Ride idea as a whole, has hit a speed bump.

"We are looking at additional Park & Rides, it's just that the market for Park & Ride service is a little further out," says John Sedlak, of Metro.

[snip]

Metro insists there are other avenues. They say they would like the 210 route riders to take another nearby route or join a vanpool.

Metro says it will be eliminating another 21 routes by the end of next month in a move it says will save at least $9 million.

One of the many benefits that Metro promised in relation to the referendum on light rail was a 50% increase in bus services, including expansion of Park-and-Ride services. Instead, Metro seems to be scaling back bus services considerably. Even worse, this particular Park-and-Ride bus serves one of the most congested freeways in Houston, the Katy. The cost per rider may be higher than Metro would like, but any cost-benefit analysis ought to consider the cost in light of the additional congestion resulting from having those riders in separate vehicles along the corridor served. In some instances, the cost may well be justified.

Furthermore, in the discussion of costs, the media might also report on costs of the light rail system. Opponents of light rail predicted that the cost of the system would force Metro into cutting bus services. That may -- or may not -- be the direct cause of the current cuts in bus services, but consumers of news can't make an informed conclusion without more information. It would be useful, for example, if reporters would press Metro officials on the per-rider cost of the light rail train, and the freeway congestion relieved by the same.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/25/04 05:43 PM |


Battleship Texas is ailing

According to this AP report, the Battleship Texas needs some serious repairs:

Age, relentless corrosion from saltwater and tight budgets are doing what no bombs, torpedoes or bullets could accomplish.

Sixteen years after the state spent $14 million to help preserve it, the nearly century-old Battleship Texas -- the only remaining battleship to survive World Wars I and II -- needs an overhaul to keep it from rusting away.
"The ship is in need of significant repair," said Steve Whiston, director of the infrastructure division of the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department, which maintains the 573-foot-long, 34,000-ton vessel in a berth on the Houston Ship Channel. "There is corrosion at the water line. We're continuing to experience problems that cause us concern. And the ship, given its age, is pretty fragile."

So fragile that chronically leaky air tanks -- known as blisters and added to the exterior during the 1920s for stability -- sprung a serious leak one recent night. Workers were greeted the next morning with the ship sporting a 4-degree starboard list.

"It got all of us excited but we're satisfied it's stable," Whiston said.

The water was pumped out and the leak was patched, at least temporarily.

"If you are going to acknowledge you're going to keep some historic ships, there is a very strong argument this is at least as good, if not the best, one to keep," said Barry Ward, curator of the Texas.

Ward said the ship is a unique piece of technology in terms of the time period it represents. "This goes from the very beginning of the age of flight through the nuclear age," he said.

The battleship is a great place to visit. The history of the ship is fascinating and you can go all over that big boat, exploring below-deck quarters, checking out the mess hall, sitting in the anti-aircraft gun seats and climbing up the main mast, among other things.

Let's hope she can be repaired and enjoyed for years to come.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 09/25/04 01:29 PM |


A little appreciation for our downtown tunnels, please

Anne Belli Gesalman gives a pretty decent history and overview of downtown Houston's tunnel system in the September 15th Edition of The Greater Houston Weekly:

Each week day, thousands of office workers, tourists and other visitors to downtown take stairs, escalators and elevators down into this self-contained sub-grade world, sheltered from the elements and immune from such outdoor annoyances as construction zones, mosquitoes and bus fumes.

Not to mention annoyances such as crazed drivers, panhandlers, Metro officers on the prowl for jaywalkers, and Metro trains and buses that seem to have a penchant for hitting pedestrians.

Today, 77 building - officer towers, performance hall, government complexes and hotels - are connected, from the historic district on the northern edge of downtown, the skyline district to the south. The tunnel serves about 150,000 downtown workers.

We Houstonians are known for our love of cars and our lack of desire to walk instead of drive. The tunnel system stands in the face of that. It makes it easier for downtown workers to walk. Now that the free downtown trolly system is about to go by the wayside, the use of the tunnels might actually increase.

Ms. Gesalman goes on to give some historical and notable facts about the tunnel, but gets one thing wrong:

The tunnel may only be accessed directly from the street at one point - from Wells Fargo Plaza at McKinney and Louisiana. All other access points are through building lobbies.

Not true actually. There are at least ten other non-lobby entrances that I'm aware of. While most involve the Theater District Parking system, there is one entrance on the corner of Travis and Mckinney that offers direct access.

The tunnel system could see its biggest boost of all in the years ahead if Metro officials opt to build a subway line downtown instead of additional street-level light rail lines. The transit agency unveiled preliminary plans for a downtown subway this summer, and it says it will study the option in coming months. Construction would not begin until at least 2007.

That's reassuring (the part about the boost, not the part about the prospect of another Metro boondoggle). Several months ago there was talk of eliminating the tunnel system in Dallas to get people back on the streets for street-level retailers. Even our own downtown reps, in a piece by the Chronicle's Dallas bureau reporter, were trash talking the downtown office-worker-venerated tunnel.

"Clearly, they work like a giant vacuum. They suck people off the street," said Jodie Sinclair, spokeswoman for the Houston Downtown Management District. "I had a woman visiting from Manhattan ask me, `Where are all the people? It's Wednesday at 1 in the afternoon.' I told her, `Dear, they're all underground.' "Over the past decade, Sinclair said, Houston has come to terms with its tunnels, even though "behind the scenes, people wish they weren't there."

Behind the scenes? Houston has come to terms with its tunnels? Is someone going to come up with the bright idea that something this free and this used shouldn't be?

Posted by Callie Markantonis @ 09/25/04 10:35 AM |


Political groups should be labeled equally

If the Chronicle is going to attach labels to conservative political groups, then the same must be done with liberal political groups. It's called consistency. In Saturday's Chronicle there is an article about a 527 group, Texans for Truth, that is being accused of violating campaign fund-raising laws:

The complaint says Texans for Truth is accepting contributions and running advertisements to influence the presidential race and therefore comes under campaign finance limits, which cap individual contributions at $2,000 from an individual and $5,000 from a political committee.

Texans for Truth has reported a $100,000 contribution from Daniel O'Keefe, a California television producer.

Glenn Smith, a Democratic political consultant who organized Texans for Truth, said Friday that he hadn't seen the complaint and could not comment on its charges.

Smith said most of the group's contributions are small and not representative of the big money already being spent in the election.

Texans for Truth's ads came after another group, Swift Boat Veterans for Truth, ran TV ads criticizing Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry's Navy service in the Vietnam War.

The watchdog groups have complained to the FEC about the Swift Boat group and other pro-Republican groups. Those complaints are pending.

The closest the Chronicle reporter comes to acknowledging that Texans for Truth is a pro-Democrat group is when he writes that the group was founded by "Glenn Smith, a Democratic political consultant." But the reporter has no problem saying that the Swift Vets group is a pro-Republican group.

If you follow the links at Texans for Truth, you can see that Glenn Smith is the founder of DriveDemocracy.org, "a Texas-based organization initially funded through a generous start-up grant from MoveOn.org." OK, now we're getting somewhere! One look at these groups' websites will show that these are not non-partisan groups, any more than the Swift Vets are non-partisan. As such, they should be labeled accordingly.

Also, the story mentions television producer Daniel O'Keefe without giving any background. Ten seconds on Google would have provided plenty of helpful information on O'Keefe, if one was interested in finding some more information. O'Keefe is a John Kerry fundraiser who says he is mad at President Bush for not fighting in Vietnam and for his handling of the Iraq war. It would be safe to label him a liberal.

The Chronicle needs to think outside the liberal box and label these groups appropriately. It's a little thing, but it's a thing that grates on the nerves of many readers.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 09/25/04 08:22 AM |


24 September 2004

Murray engages in nonpartisan party building!

Kristen Mack supplies the following news about University of Houston political science professor Richard Murray:

Richard Murray, University of Houston political science professor and noted authority on Houston and Texas politics, will hold the Bob Lanier Endowed Chair in Urban Public Policy at UH.

The $500,000 endowment, funded through donations from individuals and foundations, is named for the former Houston mayor.

Murray recently began assembling a team of academics and others to help create a more robust two-party system in the state by revitalizing the Democratic Party. He characterizes the effort as nonpartisan and says it won't affect his objectivity as an academician.

Professor Murray is an asset to his department, and certainly deserves this endowed chair.

However, the notion that Professor Murray's work at "revitalizing the Democratic Party" in Texas is "nonpartisan" is surely one of the more nonsensical things I've read lately in the Chronicle. If Professor Murray actually said it with a straight face, then it leads us to question his academic "objectivity." Maybe he was just pulling Mack's leg and she didn't catch on. Either way, it's silly.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/24/04 11:59 PM |


Corrections, Chronicle style

The Chronicle corrections section is just an endless source of amusement (and one that occasionally garners national attention).

Last Sunday, the newspaper ran a story by John Frank of the Washington news bureau on political donations by Texas sports owners.

On Monday, the Chronicle ran the following correction:

The first name of Houston Astros owner Drayton McClane was listed incorrectly on Page A12 Sunday with information accompanying an article about campaign contributions by sports executives.

That rather priceless statement led to the following correction the next day:

An item in this column Tuesday misspelled Houston Astros owner Drayton McLane's name.

There are three owners of major sports teams in this town. One would think those employed as editors of the city's only major daily would have a clue who they are and how to spell their names. But one would obviously be mistaken.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/24/04 11:32 PM |


Chronicle: Lynne Cheney = Stepford wife?

The Chronicle has a daily Election 2004 section and in today's paper, under the heading "Quotable," is this:

"She plays the smiling Stepford political wife, which is so opposite from what she is. It's quasi an embarrassment, and I say that because she's not the little wife."

-- Paul Costello, Rosalynn Carter's former press secretary about Lynn Cheney

I'd give the link to it, but it's not online. This seems highly disrespectful, unless the Chronicle is trying to highlight how nutty Rosalynn Carter's former press secretary is, which probably wasn't the intent.

A look at the Chronicle's Election 2004 section for the past week shows that there are days when the Chronicle editors can't find anything "Quotable." So Wednesday and Thursday were "Quotable"-free, but Tuesday, the Chronicle dug up this:

"We either pull out all the stops over the next few weeks, or we will live to regret it."

--James Carville, Democratic strategist to prospective donors in a DNC fund-raising letter sent last week.

Actually, the Chronicle was a bit off describing Carville. It should have said, "Democratic strategist and host of CNN's Crossfire." And what an illuminating quote!

On Monday, the Chronicle decided this was worthy of being a "Quotable":

"We've got to take out the sanctuaries. We're going to have to sustain, tragically, some more casualities. Airstrikes don't do it. And the longer we delay...the more casualties we will incur."

--Sen. John McCain, on CBS' Face the Nation. The Arizona Republican called on the president to initiate an urgent ground offense to retake insurgent sanctuaries in Iraq [sic]

Love the ellipsis. Wonder what was taken out so the three dots could go in? And was this really the most "Quotable" quote the Chronicle could find from the Sunday news shows? Why, yes it was. It was a Republican criticizing President Bush.

We have to go back to last Thursday to find another quote. But it's not given the title of "Quotable" - it's just in a little box on the Election 2004 page:

"Actually new documents surfaced today proving that President Bush did not fulfill his National Guard service. CBS said they know they're new because they were just printed over the weekend."

--Jay Leno, The "Tonight Show" host on a CBS' [sic] story using disputed documents.

The Chronicle needs to get its Washington bureau looking for better "Quotables."

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 09/24/04 11:25 AM |


23 September 2004

Scooped by the Ohio and New Braunfels Press

Former President Bush made a trip to Ohio earlier this week to stump for the current President Bush. The topic of CBS News (with which he tangled as President) came up in his speech:

"This disgraceful thing with CBS, trying to malign our son's service as a jet pilot, was insidious," Bush told about 300 Republican supporters at a private ballroom in Columbus.

It's really too bad that the Ohio (instead of Houston and/or Texas) press actually is reporting former President Bush's reaction to MemoGate, a scandal with many Texas connections. As pointed out previously, the Houston Chronicle should have owned this story, including this local angle. Instead, they've largely been shown up by the national press, the Ohio press, and even the New Braunfels Herald-Zeitung.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/23/04 11:59 PM |


What to do with the Astrodome?

Bill Murphy and Bill Hensel report that Astrodome Redevelopment Co. has shifted from initial plans to develop a theme park out of the abandoned sports arena. Now, the company hopes to redevelop it as a convention hotel.

No doubt, many Houstonians have fond memories of the Dome, and don't like the idea of tearing it down. However, the costs of maintaining the empty behemoth are significant. It either needs to be dynamited and paved over, or turned into something useful.

On that last, Tom Kirkendall warns:

[M]y sense is that this proposal for the Astrodome is not likely to occur without a substantial subsidy from Harris County. Consequently, let's see if the Chronicle or any other Houston news media discloses the true taxpayer cost of retrofitting and maintaining the Dome in comparison to alternative uses of the property. Given the Chronicle's abysmal performance in providing accurate information regarding the cost of the Streetcar Named Disaster, my expectations are not high.

Somebody needs to look out for the taxpayers and their interests on this deal. Murphy and Hensel suggest that the redevelopment project has a potential price tag of $400 million. The result would be a convention hotel that competes with the new Hilton Americas downtown -- potentially hurting its revenues.

This project needs much more scrutiny before we decide it's better than just blowing up the rat trap.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/23/04 11:32 PM |


Maybe the Chronicle needs a new subscription drive

You can just imagine this poor Chronicle reporter pounding his keyboard in frustration as he worked on this story:

Reaction from Fort Bend County residents to the indictments involving campaign contributions linked to U.S. Rep. Tom DeLay of Sugar Land was rather tepid Wednesday. Most people said they were only vaguely aware of this week's actions taken by a Travis County grand jury.

Local political leaders say the indictments will have little or no effect on the upcoming election in which DeLay, a Republican and the House majority leader, is seeking an 11th term.

"I think that most people realize that partisan politics get introduced into many things, including the DA's office of Travis County," said Eric Thode, chairman of the Fort Bend County Republican Party.

A quick and informal poll of people outside a county courthouse annex building Wednesday showed that only a few knew about the indictments in any detail.

"I don't really keep up much on it," said Mary Lutz of Needville. "I should, but I don't."

Lutz said she plans to vote a straight Republican ticket and that includes voting for DeLay.

The grand jury on Tuesday indicted three DeLay associates and eight corporations on charges of making illegal campaign contributions to Texans for a Republican Majority, a political action committee associated with DeLay.

DeLay was not named in the indictments. DeLay is being challenged Nov. 2 by Democrat Richard R. Morrison, Libertarian Thomas Morrison and independent Michael Fjetland.

How can this be? Hasn't the Chronicle told these people that DeLay is a very bad man? Why aren't they paying attention?

Perhaps there aren't enough of DeLay's constituents reading the Chronicle.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 09/23/04 10:46 AM |


22 September 2004

CAIR's fuzzy math

On Sunday the Houston office of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) sent out a press release saying it was holding a news conference calling for political and religious leaders in Texas to condemn Islamophobia. We at blogHOUSTON couldn't wait to see if the Chronicle would send a reporter and, if so, to read the story.

We weren't disappointed. The Chronicle answered the call and on Tuesday Melanie Markley wrote a press-release talking-points story:

Last week's attempted firebombing of an Islamic center in El Paso represents the latest in a renewed rash of hate crimes against Muslims in Texas, the director of Houston's Council on American-Islamic Relations said Monday.

Iesa Galloway, executive director of CAIR in Houston, called on political and religious leaders Monday to condemn the attack in El Paso, calling it an act of "Islamophobia," a term he said was coined by his organization.

"This," said Galloway, "is the latest in a trend of attacks that have been happening across Texas."

Galloway said other recent acts include a dry-ice bomb that exploded in a mailbox at a Houston-area Islamic center, a series of arsons in San Antonio that targeted Muslim-owned businesses and graffiti and other hateful incidents in McAllen.

Galloway said he believes that hate crimes against Muslims have spiked during the past six months.

If Galloway provided statistics to back up what he believes, the Chronicle reporter didn't pass them on in the story. Next to the story online is a statistics box that belies Galloway's assertion that Muslim hate crimes are on the rise. The statistics, from the Texas Department of Public Safety, list hate crimes reported against Muslims in Texas:

TEXAS STATISTICS
Incidence of hate crimes reported against Muslims in Texas, by year:

• 2004: No statistics available
• 2003: 4
• 2002: 11
• 2001: 29
• 2000: 3

Source: Texas Department of Public Safety

We can see in 2001 there was a high of 29 hate crimes and last year there were four. Seems as though hate crimes against Muslims have been declining, dramatically. Galloway highlighted the attack on an El Paso mosque, and a dry-ice bomb in a mailbox at a Houston mosque. In the case of the El Paso attack, the police have already arrested a suspect. While certainly a disturbing incident, it's a stretch to say Texas is experiencing an epidemic of Muslim hate crime attacks. And a dry-ice bomb in a mailbox could just as easily have been kids pulling a prank.

[Read More]

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 09/22/04 05:37 PM |


Who Is Nate Gray?

Richard Connelly tucked away the following blurb near the end of his "Hairballs" column in last week's Houston Press:

When most Houstonians hear the name "East Cleveland," they may find themselves surprised that the tiny Montgomery County town of Cleveland has a suburb.

But, it turns out, there is also a city of sorts named Cleveland, in a state called "Ohio." And that Cleveland has a suburb to the east, an impoverished, mostly minority enclave of 27,000.

Why the geography lesson? Because the politics of East Cleveland may come to play an intriguing role in the politics of Houston.

Mayor Emmanuel Onunwor was convicted last month of bribery, racketeering and tax fraud, the charges stemming from an FBI investigation of businessman Nate Gray. Gray was videotaped handing envelopes stuffed with cash to the mayor, apparently to further the interests of CH2M Hill, a company running the city's water department.

The Cleveland Plain Dealer reports that wiretaps of Gray have led to "so many different fruitful veins of investigation," triggering probes in Chicago, Detroit, New Orleans -- and Houston.

There are indeed some local connections. CH2M Hill is involved in the Port of Houston Authority's mammoth Bayport project, and it has its nose fully in the City Hall trough. In 1999 the city paid $1.6 million for the company to develop a "strategic plan" for its water system, an amount later amended to $2.5 million, which is a pretty nice amendment. A year later it got a $3.5 million design contract.

Gray also owns Etna Parking, which has a piece of the contract for shuttling car-rental customers at Bush Intercontinental Airport. A "Nate Gray" gave $500 to Mayor Bill White's campaign in December.

Whether anything comes of this is difficult to say -- Gray didn't return calls, and the FBI and U.S. Attorney's office in Cleveland refused comment.

There may be something there, or there may be nothing. This is the sort of thing that former Press reporter Tim Fleck was good at fleshing out.

A search of the Houston Chronicle archives did not turn up any reference to this story.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/22/04 05:06 PM |


Eavesdropping on the Chronicle

It would be fun to see what goes on in the daily editorial board meetings at the Chronicle. You know, having to go over current events and decide what matters are of such importance that the Chronicle must give its devastating, can't-miss analysis.

Big 1: Well, there is this Rather thing.

Big 2: The President gave a speech at the United Nations.

Big 3: John Kerry gave his fourteenth position speech on Iraq.

Big 4: DeLay wasn't indicted, but all his closest friends were.

Big 3: It's not as good without DeLay's indictment.

Big 5: Metro isn't checking boarding passes.

Unison: No, no, no. Can't do that.

Big 1: Johnny Ramone died. The Ramones were awesome. Oh, but he was a conservative.

Big 4: No problem - we can just bury that part about his being a conservative. No one actually reads all the way to the end.

Unison: Great, good! We'll go with that.

Big 2: MeMo showed me a Kansas City Star editorial on the swinging pendulum of fashion.

Big 4: Terrific! We'll do Another Voice for that one.

Big 1: OK. Rather, Ramone and the swinging pendulum of fashion it is. Good meeting folks. Thanks. See you tomorrow.

[Read More]

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 09/22/04 10:10 AM |


We don't want to see her in jammies

The Chronicle's MeMo is an endless source of amusement. On Tuesday, Memo delved into the world of blogs vs. Big Media:

Someday this blogger would love to do a serious piece about the rise of the "citizen journalist," which is a term Drudge made popular to distinguish himself from the lackeys of Big Media such as, presumably, us. The issue really does deserve much more space, but when did journalists with real jobs become separated out -- in the public mind and maybe in some cases beyond that -- from their chief role, which is to be the eyes and ears of the public? This is, believe it or no, the principal reason most people we know got into the Land of Bad Pay and Bad Hours that is journalism -- because they were idealists (and not idealogues).

Ah! we could go on and on, about journalistic ethics, about fatcat Beltway and Manhattan pundits being conflated with everyday news people, about liberal vs. conservative. But another time.

Can't wait.

That's an interesting idea she brings up, though - that journalists are idealists.

My handy little (online) 2001 Merriam Webster defines an idealist as "one that places ideals before practical considerations." And ideal is defined as "a standard of beauty, perfection or excellence. An object or aim of endeavor."

The Myers Briggs Type Indicator (who hasn't taken that personality test?) has this to say about idealists:

The Idealist's Motivation
Wanting to uncover meaning and significance in the world, and trying to understand what they believe is the real nature of life and relationships, Idealist thought and speech tends to be interpretive, which means they frequently comment how one thing is really something else.

And:

Idealists are naturally inductive in their thought and speech, which is to say that they move quickly from the part to the whole, from a few particulars to sweeping generalizations, from the smallest sign of something to its entirety.

[snip]

At the very least, Idealists are the best suited of all the types to read between the lines, or to have a sixth sense about people, and they do indeed follow their hunches, heed their feelings, and insist they "just know" what people are really up to, or what they really mean. Even with complicated issues NF's [idealists] need hear only the first words of an explanation to feel they understand the subject fully, jumping from telling details to larger meanings.

Oh dear.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 09/22/04 06:55 AM |


21 September 2004

Can anyone explain the editorial policy?

A few posts ago, Anne Linehan credited Chronicle Outlook editor David Langworthy for a "frank column" acknowledging public concerns about shortcomings of the mainstream media.

Recognizing the problem surely is a start, but my most recent experience of being ignored by the Chronicle's reader representative James T. Campbell and Langworthy himself suggests that the newspaper still has a ways to go in being responsive to readers who have questions about editorial policy and decisions.

To back up a bit -- I actually wondered about the Chronicle's official policy on bylines for op-eds when I ran across a complaint on Charles Kuffner's blog that the newspaper had run an op-ed with a "ridiculously uninformative byline...." Apparently, Kuffner thinks that the newspaper needs to edit supplied bylines. I got to thinking about it, and realized that even though I don't really have his problem with the Chronicle's practices (seemingly, the policy is to run supplied bylines unless they are somehow inaccurate), it might be nice to know the official policy.

I sent James T. Campbell a polite email inquiry about the policy, beginning with a discussion of the criticism (and an admission that I didn't agree with the criticism). He responded fairly quickly that mine was a recurring question, and that he would visit with David Langworthy and get me an answer "tomorrow."

I didn't hear from Campbell the next day, so I emailed again and asked if he had been able to get a statement of policy from Langworthy.

No response.

A day later, I forwarded the correspondence to Langworthy, along with a repeat of the question.

Still no response, a week after the initial email.

I understand that editors probably have more important things to do than answer questions from bloggers, but it seems strange to promise an answer to a legitimate question about editorial policy and then not to deliver, and to ignore subsequent emails on the topic.

Given Langworthy's "frank" column, it's stranger still.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/21/04 11:35 PM |


The Chronicle still isn't happy with Prop. 12

Recently, Texas Media Watch noted that the Chronicle was less than happy with Proposition 12, medical liability reform:

When medical liability reform was on the ballot last year, the editorial board of the Houston Chronicle adamantly opposed it. In addition to chronically slanted news coverage of the issue, the paper produced twelve editorials during the campaign stressing their opposition. Two days before the vote they wrote:

If Proposition 12 passes in Saturday's statewide election and becomes an amendment to the Texas Constitution, Texans almost certainly will have given up an important constitutional right and consumer protection tool.

In exchange, they will have received a dubious promise about lowering the cost of medical malpractice insurance rates.

Houston Chronicle, 9/11/2003

[Read More]

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 09/21/04 05:39 PM |


20 September 2004

Chronicle gets mixed review for memogate coverage

The Houston Chronicle gets a mixed review from Texas Media Watch's Sherry Sylvester for its recent coverage of the Dan Rather fake memo flap.

Sylvester blasts the Chronicle for ignoring Marian Carr Knox:

The elderly National Guard typist, Marian Carr Knox, made national news when she told reporters that the documents were phony. Knox, who lives in Houston, told the Washington Post and Matt Drudge that she had called the Houston Chronicle to tell her story, but they didn’t call her back.

As Anne Linehan suggested earlier, perhaps the Chronicle's voicemail wasn't working. And maybe that's why they missed the Enron story as well. Someone at 801 Texas Avenue really should call in the phone company. In any case, the Dallas Morning News managed to scoop the Chronicle on a story the local newspaper should have owned.

Sylvester goes on, however, to credit the Chronicle for its background on Bill Burkett:

The Houston Chronicle also published an important piece on Burkett, who has been a bitter and frequent critic of Bush over the years. The Chronicle noted that many of Burkett’s charges failed to check-out. Demonstrating how far off a national news report can drift, on September 17 the Washington Post published a piece on Burkett entitled “Suspected CBS Source is Well-Regarded Texan." The much better researched story about Burkett ran in the Houston Chronicle the same day. It was headlined “Texan has history of attacks on Bush."

More of this kind of reporting from journalists who knew the players and their backgrounds would have saved the national media a lot of time and surely resulted in some glory for the Texas press.

It really is disappointing (if not surprising) that the Texas press didn't do a better job on this story. Texas newspapers could still redeem themselves, however. Documents were obviously faked, and laws broken. Getting to the bottom of who did what would be some nice journalism. It might even produce that elusive first Pulitzer for the Chronicle.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 09/20/04 10:35 PM |


[Previous 9 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]

 SITE MENU

+Home
+About
+Archives
+BH Commentary (RSS)
+Bloggers
+Blogroll
+Contact Us
+Forum
+Local News Headlines
+Syndication
+Twitter