20 December 2004
DMN continues with TAKS cheating scandal
The Dallas Morning News has another story related to the TAKS cheating scandal, this time going through the ways cheating can occur and the ways officials can detect or prevent cheating, which obviously isn't being done. (The Chronicle is still running its AP-inspired story.)
Here's an example of the official leadership thinking at the Texas Education Agency:
"Typically, school districts police themselves," said Lisa Chandler, the TEA's director of assessment. "We trust educators to educate our kids."
[snip]
Ms. Chandler said she refuses to react cynically when TAKS scores improve by leaps and bounds.
"It may be an optimistic viewpoint, but it's also a necessary viewpoint," she said. "We can't afford to lose five years in a child's educational career. They have to have improvement. Can we expect quick turnarounds? We have to. We can't let those kids not be successful."
The Texas accountability system rewards schools and districts for high test scores. Principals and teachers often see their careers advance if their students score well. That can leave few incentives for educators to be vigorous about pursuing cheaters.
So, for the TEA, even if test scores improve so dramatically as to defy logic, it's okay, because improving test scores is everything. Students actually learning is not.
Boy that makes me mad. I am not against testing at all. I think testing is necessary, but it should be done honestly so we can see if students really are learning. Wildly improving scores should be a huge red flag, and if administrators and officials are unwilling to notice those scores and check them out, then what good are they? They certainly aren't earning their big, fat paychecks.
But Ms. Chandler isn't done with her inspiring words:
Ms. Chandler said the agency is willing to consider toughening its stance. It is considering setting erasure thresholds for schools that, if exceeded, would trigger investigations.
TEA officials also said that the agency is considering adding a check similar to The News' analysis: searching for schools with wide swings in average scale scores.
Considering? Considering? Don't strain yourself with all the considering, Ms. Chandler. After all, it's only about the education of Texas' children. This is why parents are getting fed up with public schools. The people in charge are mainly interested in protecting their own jobs, not in actually educating our children.
And here's a well-earned dig at the TEA and (in my opinion) the Chronicle:
The newspaper's [DMN] analysis was performed entirely with publicly available test scores obtained from the TEA, using basic statistical techniques. The agency could perform a similar analysis on its own, but its leaders choose not to.
If the scores are improving, then the TEA is happy. Why, that must mean Texas public education is in good shape! So, no. The agency would not be interested in investigating red flags.
And shame on the Chronicle for not digging this up. But as we know, the Chronicle does its best reporting when a press release comes out to alert the editors that some news is happening. Since the TEA didn't helpfully send out a press release about the cheating, the Chronicle couldn't write a story on it.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/20/04 08:15 AM |
19 December 2004
Press discovers "olds"
In the most recent issue of the tired Houston Press, Richard Connelly discovers that Galveston has received acclaim for being so average demographically.
At least one blog pointed out that Galveston news a month and a half ago.
Once upon a time, Connelly used to tweak the Chronicle by suggesting they check with the Press more frequently for their story ideas (frequently rewrites of earlier Press stories). Bloggers could say the same to Press writers these days.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 12/19/04 02:37 PM |
Doesn't Robison have something in Austin to write about?
The Chron's Austin news bureau chief is acting as Mayor White's PR man at the newspaper again this week, rambling once more in favor of cameras at traffic lights.
The "argument" doesn't go much beyond last week's effort, which effectively said "red light runners are bad, and the city should go after them."
But Robison does concede one point to opponents, even as he takes shots at them because they might be conservatives:

What's wrong with the city raising money, to be used for public needs, from people who willingly endanger other people on the road?
Here's what's wrong -- a little thing called accountability. The private contractor has an incentive to raise revenues, and the city wants those revenues -- for what? Nobody has bothered to answer that question, because they all insist this is a safety issue (as I've pointed out before, when politicians say it's not about the money, of course it's about the money). There's all sorts of potential for mischief when our city officials engage in public-private partnerships, as those of us who have lived here for a while understand quite well. Since Mr. Robison spends so much of his time in Austin, he may not realize that. Maybe he should be writing pro-camera editorials for the Austin American Statesman and telling Austinites how to raise more money for their city? Except that newspaper tends to have better taste on its editorial page.
Further, since the paranoid Austin bureau chief imagines a right-wing conspiracy against him, here's an unlikely ally of that conspiracy:
"This is a case of the city looking for money, and they're looking for the money in the wrong way," said ACLU attorney Randall Kallinan. "No study has shown that the safety is increased with red light cameras."
Of course it's about the money.
Robison concludes with another condescending lesson in American constitutionalism:
A popular misconception to the contrary, we don't even have an unrestricted, constitutional right to drive, much less to ignore basic rules of traffic safety.
You mean the Chronicle editors who embrace the constitutional privacy penumbras that protect the "right" to kill fetuses do not embrace the logical extension of said penumbras to traffic cameras? I'm so very disappointed in their selective embrace of constitutional fiat!
All joking aside, here's something for Robison to chew on: citizens do have a right to oppose bad public policy, policy that is designed to further liberal ends of expanding municipal government by raising revenues that are not earmarked for any particular purpose, and is presented under the guise of public safety. And even citizens who might be Republicans (or -- shock -- ACLU members!) enjoy that right, no penumbras necessary.
You would think the Austin news bureau chief might have something in Austin to write about, especially as the upcoming legislative session approaches. Maybe he was busy Kwanzaa shopping, and it was just easier to write a column belittling the people who sent him emails than come up with anything more substantive.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 12/19/04 10:25 AM |
DMN beats Chron on important education news
The Dallas Morning News has two stories of interest, relating to public schools. The first questions the dramatic improvements some traditionally low-rated schools have made in TAKS testing:
A Dallas Morning News data analysis has uncovered strong evidence of organized, educator-led cheating on the TAKS test in dozens of Texas schools – and suspicious scores in hundreds more.
[snip]
The News' findings have led to cheating inquiries in three Texas school districts, including the state's two largest, Dallas and Houston. One of the schools under investigation is a National Blue Ribbon School that a year ago was touted by federal officials as an example of top academic achievement.
[snip]
Take Sanderson Elementary, a school in a poor Houston area.
In 2003, after years of mediocre performance, it reached what has traditionally been the pinnacle for American schools: The U.S. Department of Education named Sanderson a Blue Ribbon School because of rapid improvement in its test scores.
But the News' analysis raises questions about the validity of Sanderson's TAKS performance, particularly in fifth-grade math.
Sanderson's fourth-graders scored extremely poorly on the math TAKS test. Their average scale score was so low that it ranked Sanderson in the bottom 2 percent of the state: No. 3,173 out of 3,227 schools.
That's roughly what might be expected from a school where 98 percent of the student body is poor enough to qualify for free or reduced lunches. Hundreds of research studies have found that student poverty is the single most important factor in student academic achievement.
But Sanderson's fifth-graders had astonishing success on the math test. They had the highest scale scores of any school in Texas, beating every magnet school, every wealthy suburban school and every high-performing school in the state.
Sanderson didn't just finish No. 1. No other school in the state was even close. In scale-score points, the distance between Sanderson and the No. 2 school was as large as the gap between No. 2 and No. 116. More than 90 percent of Sanderson's fifth-graders got perfect or near-perfect scores.
Uh oh.
It sure would be nice to see this kind of reporting out of the Chronicle.
UPDATE 1: The Chronicle now has an AP story up, on the probe into TAKS cheating.
UPDATE 2: The Chronicle did that "poof" thing again, where it replaces a wire story with a Chronicle-authored story. The Chronicle doesn't believe both stories can coexist, apparently, so poof! No more AP story. That "poof" thing drives blogHOUSTON crazy. Anyway, the link in UPDATE 1 now goes to the Chronicle-authored story, and we'll use the term "Chronicle-authored" loosely, since much of the information is from the AP story, with a few quotes and a bit of new information thrown in. Here's the AP story the Chronicle used earlier, from USA Today. The Chronicle is truly a piece of work.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/19/04 09:45 AM |
Baby steps for the D.C. bureau
Gebe Martinez has a decent column on House Majority Leader Tom DeLay (R) in today's Chronicle that is a step up from what usually comes from the Chron on DeLay, in that it's not simply a "bad guy" profile.
For those who don't understand (or just hate to admit) DeLay's popularity among his Republican colleagues, here are a couple of useful excerpts:
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 12/19/04 09:33 AM |
New teachers are ready for winter break
The Chronicle has a nice story on two first-year, Houston teachers and how they are adjusting to the demands of teaching:
Now they understand why teachers covet their two-week winter break.
Halfway through their first year as Houston teachers, Daryl Grantham and Leonardo Elvikas have been worn down by 12-hour days, chatty students, night college and, in Grantham's case, a newborn daughter.
"I need to recuperate, lick my battle wounds, plan and get ready for Round 2," said Grantham, an eighth-grade science teacher at Pin Oak Middle School in Bellaire.
[snip]
To gauge how Grantham's life has changed since the school year began in August, look at his waistline.
"When I first started, I was about 260. I'm down to 225," he said while grading papers minutes before the first bell on a recent morning. "The teacher down the hall calls it the ACP (Alternative Certification Program) diet. I call it the teaching diet."
Grantham said he can count on one hand the number of times he's eaten lunch since coming to Pin Oak. Instead, he spends his lunch period grading and preparing lesson plans.
Grantham's classroom also has undergone a transformation since the start of the year. Lab tables that once were crammed together to seat groups of eight students are now separated for no more than four.
"Eight to a table tended to lead to too much conversation," Grantham said.
Grantham, a former University of Houston football player, puts on his game face when the bell rings, sending teenagers streaming toward their lockers.
"Here comes the herd," he said.
The whole story is a great read.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/19/04 08:32 AM |
Synchronizing downtown traffic signals
In today's Chronicle story on Metro's belabored traffic light-linking system there is this paragraph about Mayor White's plan to synchronize Houston traffic lights:
After his election a year ago, Mayor Bill White made it clear he wasn't going to wait for Metro to complete the RCTSS [Regional Computerized Traffic Signal System] before putting some of its components to work. The mayor's first initiative after taking office in January was laying out a yearlong effort for public works to manually program more than 1,500 traffic signals, including many of the computerized controllers that are part of the RCTSS. Houston is spending $3 million for this — work that would have been done mostly at TranStar had the RCTSS been up and running.
But there is one section of Houston that will not have synchronized traffic lights, in the same way the rest of the city does, as a we learned from Lucas Wall's Move It! column last week when he responded to this question:
Q: The traffic signals downtown are still a joke. They all turn green (or red) at once! On Austin Street, for example, all the lights from south to north in downtown turn green at once. The objective (I suppose) is to go as fast as you can to make as many lights as you can. When are they going to fix this?
— David Kester, Houston
A: The traffic signals downtown are synchronized, meaning the lights on north-south and east-west streets change at the same time. This is by design, said Wes Johnson, spokesman for the Department of Public Works and Engineering.
In other parts of the city, public works has been sequencing the traffic signals. Sequenced signals turn green as traffic rolls along the major street, meaning a motorist traveling the set speed (usually the limit or 5 mph under) won't usually have to stop.
The city has agreed with the Metropolitan Transit Authority that the Main Street light rail line is the most important aspect of downtown signal timing. Trains receive priority at intersections and the system is designed so that they should not have to stop between stations. This makes sequencing downtown lights impractical, Johnson said.
In other words, Mr. Kester, it is fixed.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/19/04 08:13 AM |
18 December 2004
Abortion supporters promote study that faults parental notification laws
The Chronicle decided to give abortion supporters a big platform with this story in today's paper:
Two laws in Texas that limit teenagers' ability to confidentially obtain reproductive health care cost $44 million a year largely because of additional pregnancies, local researchers have found.
[snip]
One requires teens younger than 18 to obtain parental consent before receiving prescription contraceptives, and the other requires health care providers to report to law enforcement agencies the identity of patients younger than 17 who they think are sexually active.
Is there any group that might have an interest in a study like this? Why, yes:
"But trying to legislate that teens and parents must communicate, and putting barriers to health care if teens do not, isn't going to solve the problem," said co-author Elena Marks, who is Mayor Bill White's health policy director.
Marks, who also is a volunteer at Planned Parenthood, said the paper was written and submitted before she joined White's administration. Another author, Laurie McGill, is vice president of medical services for Planned Parenthood of Houston and Southeast Texas.
Well, that explains some things.
Now, about those costs:
The researchers estimated that 37 percent of girls who used reproductive health care services would stop doing so because of the parental notification requirements.
As a result, Franzini and her colleagues calculated that more than 8,000 additional pregnancies would occur annually among Texas adolescents. Because of prenatal costs, births and abortions, the total cost was nearly $44 million.
Locally, Planned Parenthood noticed a chilling effect almost immediately after enforcement of the laws, McGill said. The number of visits by minors in the second half of 2003, compared with 2002, dropped by 30 percent.
This study uses estimates. Based on Planned Parenthood numbers. And that "chilling effect" was, no doubt, chilling mostly to Planned Parenthood's revenue base. Teens absolutely should be talking to their parents, and not Planned Parenthood, which profits from abortions.
Toward the end of the article, the reporter notes this:
The local effect may not be as drastic as the numbers predicted because state law cannot trump federal rules, which say that clinics receiving federal family planning and Medicaid funds must allow confidential access.
A majority of Planned Parenthood clinics in Harris County receive these federal funds, so they are exempt from the new state law regarding contraceptives. But in other Texas cities, such as San Antonio, few, if any clinics receive federal family planning money.
Interestingly, the San Antonio Planned Parenthood website, which lists eight locations in and around San Antonio, says this in its "For Teens" section:
The Texas Parental Notification Law applies to pregnant teens who are 17 years of age or younger and have decided to have an abortion. The law requires your doctor to notify your parent, legal guardian or conservator at least 48 hours before you have an abortion.
The Texas Parental Notification Law does not apply to other services you may receive at Planned Parenthood, such as birth control, pregnancy testing or treatment of sexually transmitted diseases.
That section goes on to helpfully tell teens how to get around the parental notification requirement for an abortion.
If you want to see the basis for the Chronicle story, all you have to do is look at the published study, because that's what the reporter did, with a sprinkling of phone call quotes thrown in for good measure.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/18/04 10:49 AM |
'Tis the season for major road construction - cont.
KTRK-13 has a list of the major freeway construction hotspots that will be causing problems this weekend:
Both the northbound and the southbound exits from the Gulf Freeway to the eastbound South Loop will be closed from 9pm Friday to 5am Saturday morning.
On the North Loop westbound, the exit to the northbound lanes of I-45 will be closed from 8am Friday until until 5am Monday.
If you're headed downtown on the Southwest Freeway, the northbound exit to Main will be closed until 5pm Saturday afternoon. Drivers are urged to detour on the Shepherd or West Gray exits.
And a reminder about a closure sure to cause the most headaches -- the 610 West Loop southbound exit to the eastbound lanes of the Katy Freeway is closed until next Thursday.
Happy driving.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/18/04 07:44 AM |
Christmas Scrooges
A neighborhood in The Woodlands was hit hard by Christmas decoration-vandals:
It all happened on the street that usually wins the coveted award for best holiday decorations in The Woodlands.
Despite the crime spree, residents of Timber Mill Street refuse to let the vandals steal their Christmas spirit.
Wolfgang Evans went all out with his light display, but it lost some of its sparkle early Wednesday morning when someone came by to say "bah humbug."
"It was slashed open," Evans said referring to a giant snowman in his yard. "I took hot glue, ran a bead of hot glue and just folded it over and glued it back together."
Evans's snowman wasn't the only decoration deflated.
The same thing happened to another inflatable snowman across the street.
And even the "abonimable snowman" wasn't spared the wrath of the vandals.
"It was heartbreaking," said owner Kirsten Bubier who noticed something terribly wrong when she got home from the gym. "It didn't occur to me at first. I wasn't looking for damage. I'm driving home to get my kids home from school. And the arch in my driveway had fallen over and I couldn't get in my driveway."
The story notes that the residents have repaired their outdoor Christmas displays and for the third year in a row, the neighborhood won the title of "best decorated" in The Woodlands." Take that, you Scrooges!
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/18/04 07:30 AM |
The Christmas mailing rush
The Chronicle has a story on the mad rush of packages and cards that will be mailed on Monday, the Postal Service's busiest day of the year, and the first two paragraphs are immediately eye-catching:
Landon Goss' girlfriend has figured out a foolproof way to avoid long lines at the post office during the holiday season. She joins friends at a day spa and sends Goss to mail her Christmas items.
Goss, a college student from Waco, said he didn't mind the half-hour wait at the Postal Service's Astrodome branch on Friday afternoon. "I try not to be frustrated," he said.
That's some boyfriend!
In case you don't have a boyfriend (or husband, or girlfriend, or wife) who will do that for you, here's my secret for mailing the boatload of boxes I send out every year: go to Parcel Plus. The stores ship USPS in addition to UPS and FedEx and they'll compare all three prices for you. And rarely is there a line. And they are friendly and helpful. (And I don't work there or know anyone who does.)
Because most boyfriends won't do what Langdon Goss does.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/18/04 06:30 AM |
17 December 2004
Houston radio short takes
In addition to the launch of a new political talk radio station in Houston this week, Houston radio saw a number of other developments:
KILT (FM and AM) laid off longtime newsman Jim Carola, as part of its elimination of its in-house news department.
Infinity radio (parent of KILT) will, according to David Barron, bring legal action next week, in an attempt to keep Charlie Pallilo from settling in as the main local talker at the new Sports Animal KBME-790.
And DJ Paul Berlin said goodbye to listeners of KBME today (in its current format), after a 54-year career on Houston airwaves.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 12/17/04 11:39 PM |
Mayor's press barrage criticized by federal prosecutors
The Chronicle's Kristen Mack reports that Mayor White is under fire from federal prosecutors in Ohio for releasing excessive information about an ongoing bribery investigation that has already nailed one Houston-area official:
The city of Houston has received a harsh letter from federal prosecutors in Ohio scolding Mayor Bill White for releasing subpoenas in a bribery case to the media after the prosecutors asked the city not to.
The prosecutors acknowledged that the release was legal, and a White spokesman said the mayor released the information in the interest of open government.
[snip]
The prosecutors' letter says the city was informed ahead of time, in writing, that the subpoenas were sensitive and that "public disclosure of these materials at this time would not be advisable."
The prosecutors said disclosing the information would "inform individuals under investigation ... unknown details regarding the focus of the investigation, the progress of the investigation and the sources of information obtained to date."
The mayor's office defended the release of information as reflective of White's belief in transparent government.
Former Mayor Bob Lanier weighed in, with a quote that is perhaps more revealing than intended:
"They have one set of needs in the U.S. Attorney's Office in Ohio and the mayor has another set of needs in leading the city of Houston," Lanier said.
The most Machiavellian mayor in Houston's recent history surely must be taken seriously on such topics, and we have no doubt this release of information was intended to satisfy the current Machiavellian mayor's political needs.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 12/17/04 10:34 PM |
Metro's fare policy
Metro is changing a policy for those don't pay a bus or train fare:
Fare evaders caught by Metropolitan Transit Authority police now are issued a citation charging them with theft of services, a Class C misdemeanor heard in Houston Municipal Courts. The new procedure will allow those cited to settle the ticket by paying a $75 civil fine to Metro. After 30 days, outstanding tickets will be sent to the courts for criminal adjudication.
The only thing missing from this story is the number of people who have been ticketed for fare-evading. This would be especially interesting to know, considering Metro has had a problem actually collecting fares for MetroRail. In September Lucas Wall wrote a story specifically detailing Metro's fare collection and verification system, or lack thereof. He wrote that the light rail train is "designed to operate on an honor system with random checks for fare payment."
Now why is it that Metro train riders are assumed to be honest and trustworthy, but Houston car drivers are presumed to be guilty red light-runners who must have cameras watching them go through intersections?
The rest of Wall's story today is about the smart card system that still isn't working:
[...] the Metro board met [...] to discuss options for gaining compliance on a contract with Cubic Transportation Systems, a San Diego company hired to supply a "smart card" fare system Metro says was supposed to have been ready for the opening of the rail. Cubic disputes that it is to blame for the lengthy delay.
The Washington (DC) Metro requires every person to buy a ticket and enter the ticket into a turnstile and the turnstile doesn't open 'til it checks the fare ticket. Houston opens its light rail with a combination honor system/unfunctioning smart card system. That's some new kind of business strategy! No wonder Metro requires millions upon millions of taxpayer dollars.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/17/04 08:52 AM |
16 December 2004
Food and drink roundup (12-16-2004 edition)
Houston's food and drink reviewers have been busy this time.
Alison Cook stays in town (really!), paying a visit to Red Onion Seafood y Mas. Oddly enough, Molly Glentzer commented on the restaurant in October, but the Chron's link is dead. That's certainly useful to diners.
Robb Walsh likes the steaks and sides at the Strip House.
Elsewhere in the Press, he comments on Robert Gadsby and his new restaurant, Noé. He's a month later than Dai Huynh on this topic.
Dai Huynh posts the weekly restaurant buzz.
Gracie Ochoa visits the bar at McCormick and Schmick's, and doesn't seem to have much to say about the experience.
That's all I found. Happy eating and drinking!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 12/16/04 10:39 PM |
Houston live music
Most weeks about this time, I point readers to David Cobb's live music roundup, and supplement his rock-oriented list with some alt-country/Americana type offerings.
Up to now, I didn't realize that KPFT was putting out a music calendar. They used to do it during the Sound of Texas days, but I just assumed the Trotskyite Revolution over there killed it. And maybe it did for a time, but it's back now, and really comprehensive.
We may still point to notable live music from time to time (this weekend, Alejandro Escovedo at the Continental Club on Friday and Django Walker at the Firehouse on Saturday are probably good bets), but at some point we'll probably just add the KPFT calendar to the links on the sidebar and leave it at that.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 12/16/04 10:04 PM |
Flu vaccine hysteria
Here's the news today:
Two months after the government recommended that scarce flu shots be reserved for people most at risk, health officials are now worried that tens of thousands of doses could go to waste, and they are considering easing the restrictions.
It turns out that the furor over the vaccine shortage and the government's response have had an unintended effect: More than half of all elderly or chronically ill adults have not even tried to get flu shots because they figured they would not be able to get one, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said today.
How was that furor generated, anyway?
After three years of GAO warnings, HHS only this summer issued a draft plan for a national response to an influenza pandemic, such as the world saw three of [sic] in the 20th century. The GAO last month criticized the draft as too unspecific.
[snip]
The Bush administration has blamed the current vaccine shortage on virtually everyone but itself.
Aha. It's all coming into focus.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/16/04 05:14 PM |
Talk radio is thriving in Houston
Clear Channel has generated a steady buzz about its new sports talk station, which fully launches its new format on KBME-790 on Monday, December 20.
Meanwhile, Salem Communications quietly launched a new conservative/Christian-oriented talk station overnight:
Salem Communications Corporation (Nasdaq:SALM - News), the leading radio broadcaster focused on Christian and family themes programming, announced two major Houston radio station initiatives. Today it launched a new station in the Houston metro area, News/Talk 1070 KNTH-AM. Salem's long-time Christian Talk and Teaching station, KKHT-FM, moved from the AM band to a new dial position at 100.7-FM.
Chuck Jewell, general manager of KNTH-AM and KKHT-FM, commented on the new station and the addition of the new FM signal. "We're delighted to offer Houston our successful News/Talk programming bringing some of the most intelligent talk on air today. For our dedicated Christian Talk and Teaching listeners, we now are able to provide the same inspiring programming over a strong FM signal. It's returning KKHT-FM back to its original roots as an FM station serving the Houston metro area."
News/Talk 1070 KNTH-AM offers a strong line-up of syndicated talk show hosts including Bill Bennett (5-8 AM), Mike Gallagher (8-11AM), Dennis Prager (11AM-1PM), Dave Ramsey (1-3PM), Michael Medved (3-5PM), and Hugh Hewitt (5-8PM).
That's an extremely strong syndicated lineup that should readily appeal to the target audience (and beyond).
Political talk radio afficionados in Houston now have a wealth of choices after this latest addition, with KPRC-950's revised lineup now including Sean Hannity, KTRH-740 getting a boost from the Chris Baker show, and KSEV-700's lineup being headlined by local talkers Edd Hendee and Dan Patrick. Of course, KPFT-90.1 also offers a mix of talk programs from a more liberal perspective.
MORE: Salem makes room for another station in Houston
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 12/16/04 11:42 AM |
Organizational restructuring at HISD
I was critical of HISD as the superintendent "search" was conducted, but not because Abe Saavedra wasn't qualified -- he certainly seems to have what it takes to run a large urban district. Rather, I didn't think the search process was tough enough, for the job that needed filling, and the local media glossed over his reason for leaving Corpus Christi.
Now, though, it's over and done. Time to move on, and Saavedra's first move, to shakeup district leadership, is an excellent start:
Saavedra said big changes are likely in an administrative system that divides responsibility for overseeing HISD's 300-plus schools among 12 geographic districts, plus a 13th district for alternative schools. Some jobs will likely be consolidated or eliminated outright when a new organizational structure is in place next fall, he said.
"It's possible it may not even resemble what we have today," said Saavedra, who signed a three-year contract to lead the state's largest school district last week.
While the changes are likely to cut the district's payroll — nearly 60 HISD employees earn six-figure salaries — Saavedra said the main force driving the reorganization is improved efficiency. The Dallas school district, which has about 50,000 fewer students than Houston's 209,000, has more than 70 employees making more than $100,000.
[snip]
School board trustees say they'll give Saavedra leeway to make the changes he sees fit and grade his performance based on the outcome. In addition to his $270,000 base salary, Saavedra has up to $60,000 in bonus money riding on the district's performance.
"You need to give him the freedom that he needs to implement the changes that he thinks will bring about more efficient and better results," Trustee Dianne Johnson said.
One of the biggest problems large urban school districts have is the unending number of administrators needed to maintain a large district. The layers of bureaucracy -- oh dear! Pretty soon, the mission of teachers teaching kids is completely lost when the focus on bureacracy takes center stage.
This is a good move on Saavedra's part and a hopeful start to his time as superintendent.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/16/04 11:23 AM |
Blind squirrel finds nut (Chronicle covers HEC story)
Even the Chronicle can sense the Houston Emergency Center is becoming a problem, which explains why the paper has a story on it. And not just another op-ed. Oh no, it's a two-reporter story. This must be serious.
The piece doesn't have a whole lot of new information, but it does have some quotes from HPD chief Harold Hurtt that are not inspiring:
Hurtt said the departments are "working very diligently," and he hopes the analysis by MITRE will help get the center running smoothly.
"We've hired a third party to come in and review the system and process, and give us some insight on what our next step should be," Hurtt said. "We have to fix this problem. Next year at this time we should not be having these discussions."
It's unclear what departments Chief Hurtt thinks are working so diligently, but I don't think that has ever been a complaint. The complaints are technology that doesn't work, inadequate training and staffing for employees, and leadership that isn't. Chief Hurtt's comment that by this time next year everything should be swell is not very reassuring. Let's hope nothing bad happens between now and then!
Chief Hurtt continues with some thoughts on the study that is now being conducted:
Hurtt said he is not convinced the analysis will solve the problem.
"The investment has been made," he said. "I don't think we are at a point where we can say, 'OK, let's close the building and build a new system and move.' ... That may be the final answer."
Goodness gracious. He's not sure the analysis will solve the problem? He doesn't think the building should be closed and a new system built, but that's what may have to be done? If it comes to that, who's going to foot the bill?
And last, one bit of nitpicking with the story:
In November, the dispatch center's telephone system broke down for more than an hour, causing delays for people calling for help.
I don't understand why the reporters didn't mention the December system breakdown that lasted 13 hours. $53 million and the dispatchers had to resort to using pen and paper to handle emergency calls. Unbelievable.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 12/16/04 07:15 AM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]