18 August 2005
The Astrodome Hotel boondoggle
So, some group has obtained funding to turn the Astrodome into a hotel/village. What a ridiculous idea.
Sedosi, Tom Kirkendall and Owen Courreges covered the main problems of this impending fiasco very nicely. Here's Sedosi:
Why does this strike me as a monumentally bad idea?
Could it be due to the fact that the Hilton Americas Hotel is having trouble maintaining capacity at operating levels?
Could it be due to the fact that there is barely enough convention traffic in Houston to satisfy the current available space?
Could it be due to the fact that the Dome is a County-owned property, and this basically would be another high dollar subsidy for private investment?
It could be!
A project of this magnitude would entail working out huge problems, such as how an additional 1,200 rooms can be justified to lenders and equity investors in light of Houston's current glut of hotel rooms, parking woes during football games and the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo, and the dubious nature of the pitiful Astroworld Six Flags Amusement Park across the freeway from the Dome as a draw for the hotel. As a result, my sense is that this deal will never come together, but crazier financial decision have been made -- just look at the Metro Light Rail line!
Houston has waaaaay more hotel capacity than we currently need, or will need for the foreseeable future. We aren’t a tourist destination, and everything beyond tourism – i.e. business travel and conventions – aren’t enough to sustain our current capicity.
Yes, yes, yes. The Houston hotel market is saturated. The LAST thing the city needs is another hotel, let alone another BIG hotel. And let's not forget that Mayor White "fixed" Houston's pension mess by burying it in the Hilton Americas. He certainly can't be rooting for the Astrodome Hotel. Plus, the Hilton Americas is already in iffy shape as evidenced by something the Chronicle's Shannon Buggs wrote in June:
Heywood Sanders recently placed a $50 per night bid for a four-star hotel room in downtown Houston on PriceLine.com. His offer was accepted by the Hilton Americas .
"As the Hilton seeks to fill up rooms by offering low rates through alternative booking channels, it's cannibalizing business from the other hotels," said Sanders, a professor of public administration at University of Texas at San Antonio who studies publicly financed convention hotels.
Fifty bucks. That's embarrassing.
And last April the Orlando Sentinel shared this depressing news:
the Hilton Americas on average had almost as many empty rooms as filled ones -- just like the rest of the hotels downtown.
So, the plan is to build another big hotel. Great! That's a terrific idea! How many tax breaks will be promised to the developers by Harris County officials? Will there be any no-interest or low-interest loans of taxpayer dollars to make the dreamy new hotel/village a reality? Owen's absolutely right that people are not going to decide to come to Houston because of an Astrodome Hotel. It just ain't gonna happen. And few (if any) companies are going to decide to have their conventions in Houston because the Astrodome was remade into a hotel.
The whole idea is a novelty -- a very expensive novelty -- and it will wear off very, very fast.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/18/05 08:01 PM |
17 August 2005
Chron swings, misses on 9-11 march/concert
The Chronicle editorial board almost had it.
They were so close today.
They managed to put out a topic sentence with some potential:
The decision by Bush administration officials to sponsor a march from the site of the 9/11 airliner attack on the Pentagon to a free country music concert in the nation's capital at best exhibits poor taste.
And then, inexplicably, the rest of the editorial goes on to hyperventilate about the war in Iraq and suggest conspiracies.
They just can't help themselves.
A more thoughtful editorial board might have proceeded after that first sentence to question what genius in the White House decided that a march and a Clint Black concert were an appropriate way to commemorate 9-11, a point made by KTRH-740 talker Chris Baker today.
But that wouldn't be our Chronicle.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/17/05 11:34 PM |
Big man: Chron gossip columnist takes on low-level bureaucrat
Chronicle metro/state editorialist and gossip columnist Rick Casey apparently didn't have anything to write about today.
But, he didn't let that stop him. Here's a snippet from today's column of gossip:
May I be so presumptuous as to suggest a topic for discussion at Thursday's weekly "Current Events" group at the Tracy Gee Community Center out at Beltway 8 near Richmond Avenue?The 30 or so participants in the group at the county-funded center had planned to discuss the newly-proposed Iraqi constitution, but it hasn't quite been proposed yet.
So maybe they should discuss the U.S. Constitution instead. In particular, the First Amendment.
[snip]
Last week, the community center's director, Margaret Patterson, greeted the members before they started their meeting. She had received a complaint about the previous session and needed to lay down some rules.
Bazemore recalls Patterson as saying participants are restricted to two to three minutes each and are not supposed to try to persuade anyone else of their positions.
Bazemore said she asked Patterson if there was a written set of rules. The answer was no.
Later, Bazemore called Sue McDougald, director of all six community centers in Precinct 3.
"She appeared to be aware of the situation and gave me basically the same responses," Bazemore said. "She also informed me that we could discuss current events only if we did not have a 'political point of view' or were not attempting to 'persuade someone toward our position.' "
* yawn *
Was there any kind of point to all that gossip?
Apparently, Casey thought so, as he had to write up his intimidation of a community center director:
I called Patterson at the center to hear her side of the story.
"I'm going to refer you to my supervisor," she said pleasantly. "She may refer you back to me for details, since she wasn't at the meeting."
That's not what McDougald did. She referred me to her boss, Commissioner Steve Radack.
"We don't really respond to the press," she said. "We're not supposed to write anything in the paper without clearing it downtown, so I don't think he wants us to give interviews."
Hmmmmm. The people paid by taxpayers to run our civic institutions are not supposed to talk about what goes on in them?
She's a low-level bureaucrat. She referred a newspaper reporter to a policymaking elected official. Is that so hard to understand?
Let's hope the bigshot metro/state gossip columnist feels better about himself after taking that cheap shot at a low-level bureaucrat.
The Chronicle's metro news coverage has been improving, in my view. It's a shame that some of the good reporting on the metro/state pages has to share space with Casey's columns.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/17/05 10:25 PM |
Press readers respond to Taste of Texas review
Last week, Houston Press food critic Robb Walsh posted a review of Taste of Texas that took an unusual turn into personal and political territory.
blogHOUSTONians pointed out the problems with the review.
The latest issue of the Press runs several letters in response, including one from co-owner Nina Hendee.
So, will Robb Walsh take up Mrs. Hendee's offer to sit down with Edd Hendee and have a cup of coffee?
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/17/05 10:04 PM |
Does the Chronicle have an "inside-the-loop" bias?
John Wagner makes an interesting point about the Chronicle:
Just about every weekend, you can find an obvious representation of the Houston Chronicle's "inside-the-loop" bias.
It works like this: Anything downtown-related is cool; anything outside the Loop (except for the people who buy newspapers) is lame.
His entire post is here.
I'm an inside-the-loopster myself, and that may color my own perspective, but I expect the city's only major daily to focus on the city's core rather than suburbs (although as Wagner correctly points out in his comments, the This Week sections do provide good neighborhood coverage), so I'm not sure that I would call the newspaper anti-suburban simply on the basis of focus alone. But I think Wagner's suggesting something more along the lines of anti-suburban values, a case that could probably be made about the editorial page at the least.
What do you think? Feel free to join the blogversation at Wagner's place or in our forum.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/17/05 09:37 PM |
The heat in Crawford's getting to the journalists also
A Crawford dispatch from the Chronicle D.C. bureau's Julie Mason, like much of that bureau's reporting, suffers from some problems.
There's this:
Sheehan's 10-day vigil took its new turn when Fred Mattlage, from nearby Hewitt, walked into the tumbledown Crawford Peace House on Monday night and offered his 300-acre Crawford parcel for use by the protesters.
[snip]
Mattlage, who could not be reached for comment, is reportedly a distant cousin to Larry Mattlage, a homeowner near the protest site who last weekend fired a gun in the air near the encampment after expressing annoyance at the roadside activity.
Reportedly?
Julie Mason is a reporter. So is she reporting fact or hearsay? And if it's hearsay (because it could not be confirmed), then wouldn't it have been better to leave it out? Because, as we lowly bloggers frequently hear, professional journalism has editors and research staff and safeguards to make sure unsubstantiated allegations and hearsay never make it into print, unlike blogs.
There's more:
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/17/05 09:11 PM |
Metro's July revenue plummets more than 50%
Tom Bazan emails Metro's July's farebox revenue numbers:
The METRO fare box revenue for July 2005 DECLINED 56.6% ($1,654,991.17) from July 2004 ($3,817,130.00).
Further, for the pro-METRORail folks, the TVM (Ticket Vending Machine) revenue for July 2005 DECLINED 16.9% ($140,064.50) from July 2004 ($168,507.80).
The combined revenue (excluding the sales tax "windfall") for July 2005 DECLINED nearly 55% ($1,795,055.67) from July 2004 ($3,985,637.80).
Lord have mercy. A 50+% DECLINE in revenue from last July.
If this were a private business...well, we all know what would happen. But this is Metro -- an unaccountable, quasi-governmental agency that has been rewarded for its incredible performance with hundreds of millions more in taxpayer dollars. Instead of planning more rail lines that will only exacerbate the current financial crisis, Metro should focus on increasing its PAYING ridership!
KEVIN WHITED ADDS: Commenter Bobby Warren left the following note on Lone Star Times, which posted Bazan's figures today also:
Hmmm… half the fares collected from July 2004 to July 2005. How could this have happened?
MLB All-Star Game in July 2004.
No such event in July 2005.Then again, I suppose you’ll blame Metro for the lack of a major event to keep up the extraordinary July 2004 numbers.
As Matt Bramanti pointed out to the commenter, a single event doesn't explain an overall decline in system fare box revenue of over two million dollars. And to drive home that point, Bazan's figures comparing June 2005 with June 2004 show a comparable 48% decline in fare box revenue ($3,742,140.00 in 2004 to $1,936,783.06 in 2005).
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/17/05 07:26 PM |
Rep. Noriega is back from Afghanistan -- and the Chron got it right this time
Yep, the Chronicle finally figured out that state Rep. Rick Noriega was in Afghanistan, as opposed to Iraq:
Houston state Rep. Rick Noriega spent a year 8,000 miles away and got a new perspective on his life back home.
Noriega returned this month from a stint in Afghanistan with the Texas Army National Guard's 136th Regimental Training Institute. He and several fellow Texans shared a tent, as well as the frustration of being unable to help much with problems facing their families.
Back in April, the editorial board thought Rep. Noriega was in Iraq:
Temporary Acting Rep. Melissa Noriega, wife of Rep. Rick Noriega, who is serving in Iraq[...]
Ah well, today's story by Kristen Mack and Judith Torrea on Rep. Noriega's return is interesting reading and we're glad he's home safely.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/17/05 06:13 AM |
16 August 2005
HPD announces more property room discoveries
KHOU-11's Jeremy Desel reports that evidence from a number of capital murder cases has recently been discovered in HPD's property room:
Dozens of boxes of evidence were found in the HPD property room last year during the investigation into problems at the HPD crime lab.
Investigators have been combing over each piece of evidence -- 700,000 so far -- and they recently found evidence linked to the capital murder cases.
The findings may have come too late for one person already executed.
Ponchai Wilkerson was sent to death row for a 1990 murder during a jewelry store robbery. The evidence was a car baby seat. It's relation to the case isn't clear. Wilkerson's attorneys didn't request the evidence during the trial.
District Attorney Chuck Rosenthal said that at least in the Wilkerson case, the evidence may not have made any impact.
"It appears that it is very tangential. In fact, nonessential to any given matter in Mr. Wilkerson's case, which is good from our standpoint," he said.
[snip]
Evidence also turned up in the 1987 case of Warren Rivers. He lured an 11-year-old boy to his home, sexually assaulted him, mutilated him with a broomstick and stabbed him to death. The evidence found in that case is clothing, a towel and a knife.
The third case of evidence involves Robert Campbell. He kidnapped Alexandra Rendon from a gas station in 1991, raped her, then shot her to death. The evidence is a cigarette butt which defense attorneys had asked for during the appeals process.
The city needs to stop dragging its feet on the next phase of the Bromwich investigation of the HPD crime lab and get it moving forward.
UPDATE (08-17-2005): Steve McVicker and Roma Khanna cover the story for the Chronicle.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/16/05 11:38 PM |
Chron slow to criticize abortion-rights group
Sedosi Alhambra was not overly impressed with the Chronicle editorial board's criticism of NARAL today:
You have to feel sorry for Mrs. White. There are eleven minds that share her affections, five of which probably contribute daily to the editorial pages, yet it takes them over a week to drum up a condemnation of NARAL.
Yes, it was a pretty decent rebuke of the organization, which shamed itself by running false ads, but it is also terribly late in appearing, as most Americans have moved on from this issue.
For readers who are not aware (although most should be by now), Mrs. White is Sedosi's nickname for the Chronicle editorial page, because of its frequent Bill White boosterism.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/16/05 11:25 PM |
Metro police arrest tailgate thief
Metro police may have solved the problem of disappearing tailgates:
For months, tailgates were disappearing from Houston area pickups at an alarming rate.
More than 130 were stolen from parked pickups all over Houston. Fourteen were taken in June from Metro's Eastex Park and Ride.
Now police hope they've put a dent in the crime wave by arresting two suspects.
After weeks of investigating, Metro police arrested 48-year-old Larry Joe Faulkner.
Detectives say he confessed to stealing at least 50 tailgates -- a number they figure is pretty conservative -- to support his drug habit.
"He had probably $115 to $120 a day methamphetamine habit. In order to support that habit he was required to steal at least two tailgates a day which he said he was doing everyday for months," said Metro Police Capt. Michael Raney.
Investigators tell us Faulkner would sell the $1,500 tailgates for $50 to $75 a piece to car lots in East Houston.
The story doesn't mention if Metro's elite counterterrorism unit was brought in to help crack the numerous cases of disappearing tailgates. And I wonder if Metro Police Chief Lambert ever found the technology he was looking for to help deter crime at Park and Pillages?
RELATED: Beware tailgate thievery at Park and Pillages
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/16/05 06:03 AM |
Thank you Mayor White
Matt Bramanti points to a KPRC-2 story about how the city's forced towing program has another black eye:
Two women from different parts of Houston became victims of identity theft and the only common link between the cases was a towing company with the city's Safe Clear program, the Local 2 Troubleshooters reported Monday.
[snip]
Andrea Anderson broke down along Highway 59 near Collingsworth. A Safe Clear wrecker was dispatched.
"I was hot and sweaty and waiting for a long time," she said. "I was forced to use the Safe Clear program, where I could have used my warranty tow."
A wrecker from Unified Auto Works towed Anderson's car to Humble. She paid the bill with her check card. Several days later, Anderson checked her bank account and found more than $600 worth of unauthorized charges, along with a list of overdraft fees.
Around the time Anderson was trying to figure out who was draining her bank account, a different woman's car broke down along Interstate 10 near Lockwood. Again, a wrecker from Unified Auto Works was dispatched as part of the Safe Clear program.
The woman talked with the Troubleshooters but asked to remain anonymous. She told them she also paid Unified with her credit card. And soon after, she also got hit with hundreds of dollars in unauthorized charges.
Detectives traced some of those charges to an east Houston apartment and a woman by the name of Cheryl Jackson, a three time convicted thief.
[snip]
There's a wrinkle though -- Jackson doesn't work for Unified. But her husband, Huey Hamilton, did work for Unified. He was a dispatcher for the wrecker service and he also has a long criminal record for theft and burglary.
There's more...go read how the city is responding to this. And then, let's all thank Mayor White for SAFEClear.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/16/05 05:32 AM |
15 August 2005
Council considers banning children-beggars
Council may soon crack down on some forms of begging on city streets:
Houston might soon crack down on children soliciting money for charity on city streets.
A proposed city ordinance would forbid charities from using youngsters under the age of 16 to collect contributions. And even 16- and 17-year-olds would have to be supervised by adults.
The ordinance would also require people walking around intersections collecting money for charity to wear high visibility traffic vests.
Council probably has more pressing problems to be solving (say, funding for the HPD Crime Lab investigation that is stalled once again), but here in midtown, I have noticed young children in football jerseys out begging on the streets. Sometimes they've had one adult in the vicinity. Other times they haven't. Every time I've seen them, they've had signs that say "Third Ward Football Fundraiser."
Begging in the streets isn't a fundraiser. It's dangerous, and children ought not to be doing it. It's unfortunate that we have to substitute municipal ordinances for parental common sense.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/15/05 09:17 PM |
HPD warns it may cut services to fund crime lab investigation
KTRH-740's Brent Fuller is reporting that HPD officials are saying HPD may have to cut spending on public safety in order to fund the next phase of Michael Bromwich's investigation into the HPD crime lab.
Mayor White, who likes to wrap himself in "public safety" when it comes to promoting his agenda, needs to head this off by assuring citizens that the City of Houston will find the resources to sort out the crime lab without cutting public-safety services.
Mayor White was not quoted in Fuller's story.
UPDATE: KTRK-13 and KHOU-11 cover the story.
UPDATE (08-16-2005): The Chronicle covers the story. Mayor White is not quoted. Where is the leadership of our "public safety" mayor on this important issue?
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/15/05 02:13 PM |
Food and drink roundup (08-15-2005 edition)
It's high time a food and drink roundup made an appearance. And there are quite a few links this week.
Alison Cook loved her visits to Mary'z Mediterranean Cuisine, a restaurant that seems to take love of garlic to yummy extremes. She also does a smaller checking in at Gravitas on Taft.
Dai Huynh checked in with Houston Community College's Pastry Chef Eddy Van Damme, whose cookbook On Baking: A Textbook of Baking and Pastry Fundamentals beat out 4,000 entries from 60 countries to win the prestigious Gourmand World Cookbook Awards' best cookbook for professionals.
Peggy Grodinsky goes Hoffmanesque with her short review of Starbucks' new 500-calorie Green Tea Frappuccino.
Ken Hoffman gorged on Long John Silver's new Popcorn Shrimp that...actually seems to contain...shrimp.
Gracie Ochoa checked out Bond Lounge and found it to be "like New York's boutique-style nightspots." Again, that’s not necessarily a selling point to this sometime bH contributor.
Eliza Barclay examined the booming local market for premium tequilas.
And finally, Robb Walsh had a steak at Taste of Texas and ends his review with these few paragraphs:
Taste of Texas long ago slipped into the second tier. And I say this regardless of my political opinions. Edd Hendee, the restaurant's owner, vents his hatred for Muslims, liberals and immigrants five days a week on his talk-radio show. "They must have failed Bomb Making 101 down at the mosque," he recently quipped about the London terrorists whose bomb didn't go off.
Hendee took over the show when the previous self-righteous far-rightist, Jon Matthews, was arrested for exposing his genitals to an 11-year-old child. Hendee reportedly encouraged listeners to bring letters of sympathy to Taste of Texas so he could deliver them to his fellow conservative. Houston Press columnist Richard Connelly called the restaurant "Dittohead Central, the gathering place for Rush Limbaugh fans and light rail foes" (Hair Balls, May 13, 2004). Hendee is a close friend of Tom DeLay, who is also a student in Hendee's Bible study class at Second Baptist.
Hey, I'm not a big fan of Tilman Fertitta's worldview either. But I give him credit for running some great steak houses. Regardless of his politics, Fertitta is keeping an eye on national restaurant trends and knows what's selling at the butcher shop. Hendee, on the other hand, is running a restaurant that's ludicrously out of date.
I'm often chided by readers to leave the politics out of my reviews. But I don't see how you can leave politics out of a discussion of Taste of Texas -- it's become the restaurant's main attraction. Showing support for Tom DeLay, Edd Hendee and the conservative agenda seems to be the real reason that so many people stand in line to get into this mediocre steak house.
Sadly, up until these last few paragraphs, the review wasn’t that far off the mark. I hope this isn't a new trend for Mr. Walsh: panning a restaurant, panning the owner’s personal political views, assuming and panning the customers' political views, and then tying the restaurant's failures to said views and stands. Let's see, how would this work? It might be difficult to find out the political views of, say, for example, the owners of certain family chain restaurants in town, which also serve mediocre food at exorbitant prices and pack the crowds in like sardines every day of the week, but maybe with a little research...oh. Wait. Mr. Hendee is a bit more outspoken than that. Oh. Now I understand. But does that REALLY have ANYTHING to do with the quality of the restaurant, the food, the service, or the customers?
Regardless, it’s still all World Class!! Even when we include far-rightists, er, conservatives, in the steakhouse business. Enjoy!!
Posted by Callie Markantonis @ 08/15/05 08:41 AM |
Metro asked why new rail line won't go down Westheimer
Rad Sallee's Move It! column covers last week's Metro Mobility Series breakfast meeting:
Afton Oaks residents worried about access to their homes and the fate of live oaks on the Richmond Avenue median aren't alone in asking an intriguing question about Metro's planned rail line to the Galleria area:
If Metropolitan Transit Authority officials really want the train to go where the riders are — the reason given for laying track in the middle of public streets — why wouldn't they want it on Westheimer?
The question was put to Metro board member George DeMontrond several times last week at a breakfast meeting of the Houston Intown Chamber of Commerce at the Briar Club near River Oaks.
Westheimer, which is broad and passes through the heart of the business and shopping hub called Uptown (actually Houston's second downtown), seems an obvious choice. But as one audience member told DeMontrond with emphasis, "It's not on the map."
Indeed it isn't. Metro's map shows two possible routes — Richmond, which Metro prefers, and Westpark. Metro is also considering a combination of the two, with trains coming out Richmond to any of several cross streets, where they would cross the Southwest Freeway to Westpark.
Follow the link to Sallee's story to read the details of what is and isn't being considered for the new rail line.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/15/05 06:18 AM |
CenterPoint getting more heat for its anti-tree stance
Local tree activists (Anne likes those!) are hot about CenterPoint's "zero-tolerance policy" for trees. CenterPoint's aggressive anti-tree policy stems from the massive Ohio blackout in 2003 and CenterPoint says it is following federal regulations that were drawn up as a result of that mess.
Recently Mayor White stepped into the tree fray and his office said CenterPoint had agreed to stop chopping down trees willy nilly, but CenterPoint says no moratorium is in place. So, now CenterPoint is supposed to meet with representatives from some local tree groups:
Company officials are scheduled to meet this week with organizations that have been promoting the "reforestation" of Houston, through citywide tree-plantings, as a way to clean Houston's air and beautify the city.
The groups include Trees for Houston Inc., Scenic Houston and The Park People.
Kathy Lord, executive director of Trees for Houston, said CenterPoint had agreed this spring to postpone any major tree cutting until after a regulatory conference in the fall.
"I think we were moving forward, and somebody screwed up," said Lord. "They just did not honor their agreement not to do anything until the fall."
CenterPoint officials have not offered an explanation about the destruction of the crepe myrtles, which were trimmed down to the ground, or about two live oak trees that were cut down near the intersection of the Southwest Freeway and Shepherd.
Kelly, who is trying to protect the mature live oak trees near his alma mater, Rice University, said that on the same day CenterPoint's contractors cut down the crepe myrtles, other crews chopped down the two live oak trees.
Deborah January-Beavers, of Scenic Houston, said CenterPoint officials repeatedly have cited the 2003 blackout as justification for their policy.
"They need to realize that there is an avalanche of interest in urban forestry in Houston right now," she said. "And they need to realize what bad public relations tree-cutting is for them."
And just a bit up north is an example of how trees and power lines can live in harmony together:
As evidence closer to home that trees and power lines can coexist, Kelly and Lord point to Texas Utilities' recent agreement to plant trees and vegetation under a high-voltage power line in the Dallas suburb of Addison.
In the Dallas area, TXU has cooperated with a citywide plan to develop more hike-and-bike trails near or under power lines. The city has agreements with the utility, as well as the Dallas Area Rapid Transit Authority, for narrow trails, with lower vegetation such as shrubs, and other amenities such as drinking fountains and benches.
Well, maybe not:
CenterPoint officials have declined overtures from officials of the cities of Bellaire and West University Place to use its transmission right of way along the Union Pacific railroad tracks as a park area. Those cities have repeatedly tried to use the area under the transmission towers in different ways, including a dog park.
Mercado and other representatives have said that those transmission towers need to be maintained, and that access to the towers must be clear so that heavy trucks can reach the towers.
Way to go CenterPoint!
Houston-area residents love their trees; CenterPoint would be wise to get on the right side of this issue.
(Thanks to the Chronicle's Anne Marie Kilday for a terrific story.)
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/15/05 06:06 AM |
14 August 2005
Robison: Lege should get out the money catapult
Sedosi Alhambra has previously noted Clay Robison's preferred approach to Texas education reform (get out the money catapult and fling tax dollars).
Today, the Chronicle's six-days-per-week Austin bureau chief and Sunday partisan lefty editorialist tries a sneakier version of the money catapult argument:
There is the real world, where there would be no judges without lots of teachers, helping future jurists navigate everything from nap time and the three Rs to contracts and torts.And there is the Texas statehouse, where lawmakers, meeting in a so-called "education" session, recently sent Gov. Rick Perry a bill giving judges a pay raise while continuing to reward teachers with compliments and promises.
[snip]
Most judges nevertheless deserve the higher pay, which will be financed with higher court fees. Stemming the turnover of experienced judges taking higher-paying jobs elsewhere in the legal profession frequently was cited by the governor and others as the main reason a raise was needed.
Judicial turnover, however, may be no greater a problem than the turnover of classroom teachers. According to a cursory statewide check, members of both professions are leaving their jobs at comparable rates, but time is rapidly running out for higher teacher pay.
[snip]
Meanwhile, 11 percent of the teachers in classrooms at the beginning of the 2004-05 school year didn't return last fall, said Ed Fuller, an adjunct professor in educational administration at the University of Texas at Austin and former director of research for the State Board of Educator Certification.
Some retired after long careers, but many younger teachers quit for other reasons, unhappiness with their pay being a significant factor. Fuller said a 1999 study, the most recent done on the issue, determined that low pay was the No. 1 reason for teacher turnover.
Even if one accepts Robison's turnover statistics, it's arguably far easier to replace teachers than judges, simply because the talent pool from which to draw is MUCH larger and the required education is much less difficult to obtain. Robison tries to present his turnover statistics as a self-evident reason that the money catapult should be brought to bear on teacher salaries. However, as a matter of public policy, that view is not self-evident at all.
Furthermore, Robison's citation of a 1999 study tells us hardly anything about current conditions and attitudes, and Robison doesn't provide enough information about that study for interested parties to doublecheck his presentation of the facts.
Because the Chronicle inexplicably has its Austin bureau chief double as a partisan lefty editorialist on weekends, such sloppy editorial work of course calls into question the credibility of the news reporting from Austin the other six days of the week.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/14/05 09:07 PM |
A little balance on the Sheehan affair
The Chronicle editorial page, which claims to be neither conservative nor liberal, illustrates its notion of balance today on the Cindy Sheehan affair.
There's an op-ed from Cindy Sheehan herself.
There's an op-ed from the usually conservative columnist Kathleen Parker, who points out that President Bush has not behaved as Tony Blair might have.
And there's an op-ed originally published on September 9, 2004 by E.L. Doctorow entitled "Our unfeeling President: Bush cannot grieve because he doesn't know what death is."
In the interest of providing some of the balance that is notably missing on the Chronicle editorial page, here are other perspectives from the area blogosphere: Owen Courreges at Lone Star Times (Days One, Two, and Three), A Certain Slant of Light, Isolated Desolation, and This Blog is Full of Crap.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/14/05 08:43 PM |
Why the sudden fixation on Rosa Parks?
The Chronicle, which earlier in the week ran a staff editorial comparing Cindy Sheehan to Rosa Parks, today runs an op-ed by D.C.-area resident Diane Twinam that makes another unfortunate comparison to Rosa Parks:
The trouble is that the law is out of sync with economic and social realities in the United States — especially with the job market. Many of those who decry illegal immigration willfully ignore the economic benefits it provides to much of the society. For most of the 11 million undocumented people in this country, this is the first law they have ever broken — a law that makes no more sense to them than the laws requiring segregated seating on buses made to Rosa Parks.
Her attempt to draw upon Rosa Parks is as silly as the editorial board's earlier attempt. The fact is, Twinam's husband is an illegal alien. That they have a child complicates the matter. But it has nothing to do with the issues or legacy of Rosa Parks.
Incidentally, the op-ed is "olds" that first ran in the Washington Post on Wednesday, so perhaps it inspired the editorial board's own silly reference to Rosa Parks on Friday.
Elsewhere on the editorial page, Councilmember Mark Ellis, who has proposed that HPD's sanctuary policy be terminated, pens an op-ed on the issue of immigration:
Short of throwing out every congressman and state legislator who doesn't seem to get it, we can and should implement policies that at the very least discourage illegal immigrants from calling Texas home. We can do so with effective leadership at the state and local level that accomplishes the following:
• Repeal the sanctuary status granted by cities, including Houston.
• Provide clear legal authority to law enforcement to detain, arrest and prosecute illegals for both state and federal crimes.
• Establish systematic data collection for illegal alien use of public services, including our schools, hospitals and state welfare services.
• Prohibit and/or repeal at the local level the use of matricula consular ID cards.These policies would benefit all including the communities my liberal friends presume to represent. Our hospital district could provide the care for which it was intended — for the poorest of our communities — and do so without constant fear of bankruptcy. Rather than being overwhelmed by a population that consumes dollars in a disproportionate ratio, our schools could concentrate instead on lifting those children who are at greatest risk — those from our inner cities who struggle in less-than-adequate schools. Our communities would be safer, our law enforcement more effective and our jails less crowded. Last but not least, property taxes would stop growing at exponential rates.
We have a federal system that costs billions and fails, and a state and local system that basically says: If you clear our border, welcome home.
The full op-ed is here.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/14/05 03:40 PM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]

