22 August 2005

I-45 tunnel concept is far from a "no-brainer"

Patrick Kurp reports in today's Chronicle that Gonzalo Camacho is continuing to push his I-45 tunnel concept:

Gonzalo Camacho remains convinced that running 14.5 miles of Interstate 45 under the ground would cost less, be built faster, displace fewer people and businesses, and create less air pollution than any conventional, above-ground road design.

"It's a no-brainer. It would be a large error that would be with us for a long time if the elected officials didn't get behind the tunnel idea," said Camacho, a transportation engineer and the most public proponent of making Houston home to the longest tunnel in the United States.

Camacho raised the idea in a public meeting in April and since has met with Texas Department of Transportation officials, the city's planning commission and community groups.

Just a few weeks ago, I attended Camacho's presentation of the tunnel concept to the Houston Property Rights Association, and at that time he said that his proposal was in its early stages, and that a $300,000 study would be required to know if it is truly feasible.

It is odd that in a few weeks' time, Camacho has changed his tune and what can only be described as a raw conceptual proposal has now morphed into a "no-brainer" in his mind.

Camacho's enthusiasm for his proposal is admirable, but clearly the proposal is not fleshed out enough at this point to be described as a "no-brainer."

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/22/05 10:45 PM |


Red light camera revenue stream to be ready by Thanksgiving

The Chronicle's Matt Stiles reports that city officials expect to have the Red Light Camera Revenue Stream supplying city coffers by Thanksgiving.

KHOU-11's Mike Zientek has an amusing quote from HPD:

Police deny charges they'll use the cameras to beef up city coffers.

"We would be happy if we didn't collect a penny in fines once the system goes into place," said HPD Lt. Robert Manzo. "And that's exactly what would happen if everyone would obey the laws."

Right!

It's probably worth repeating our old maxim that when pols and their subordinates say it's not about the money, it's almost always about the money.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/22/05 10:30 PM |


They are killing trees to print these editorials (cont'd)

Nuevo Laredo is literally beyond effective control of government, and the Chronicle editorial board has wasted 500+ words with a poorly written critique of U.S. Ambassador Tony Garza's recent comments?

I suppose we should be thankful they didn't create a new treaty, which sometimes happens when the editorial idealists tackle international affairs.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/22/05 10:21 PM |


Rad Sallee exposes how Metro ill-serves those who depend on it

Wow, wow, wow!

Rad Sallee has given us so much truth in one story about Metro ridership. In clear black and white, all of Metro's obfuscation is on full display:

[Metro President Frank] Wilson passed out a quarterly report that says total bus and rail ridership for the nine months through June was 6.5 percent higher than a year earlier. A footnote, however, explains that the numbers are adjusted.

Unadjusted and more recent counts show total ridership for October through July was actually down 1.5 percent, driven by a 9 percent drop in the local bus component that serves many poorer neighborhoods in the inner city — the core mission of public transit.

YES! For all those who say that light rail critics are just anti-Metro, that's the point right there. Metro's core mission as a public transit agency is to provide transportation to those who have no other transit options. I certainly don't mind Metro's sales tax if it's providing the public service it is supposed to and that it promised. But Metro isn't doing that. Metro has decided to change its mission to one of catering to commuters with light rail trains and now (don't say Bus) Rapid Transit.

Jim Archer, Metro's manager of service evaluation, said the raw fiscal 2004 numbers are misleading because of two unusual events that will not be repeated: The agency cut 37 poorly performing bus routes and changed numerous others to connect better with the new light rail line and avoid duplicating service.

So, because of 7.5 miles of downtown light rail, numerous bus routes had to be changed...to feed into the light rail. Which, of course, usually makes getting around much more inconvenient for bus riders.

But Metro's route changes can't explain why local bus boardings have fallen each year since 1999, dragging overall ridership down with them until fiscal year 2004, when it rose 3 percent.

Archer blames the bus problems largely on construction of MetroRail and transit streets in downtown and Midtown that forced many route changes, which typically cause some riders to fall away. Then came the 9/11 attacks and the Enron debacle, which had sharp impacts on downtown trolley ridership, he said.

Metro blames 9/11 for declining trolley ridership? What hasn't been blamed on 9/11?

And what Archer doesn't let on is that eliminating the trolleys was always a part of Metro's (light rail) plan, and Metro was able to do it by cutting back on trolley service and instituting a fare, when previously the trolleys had been free.

There's a pattern here. Metro decides to build the downtown light rail, come hell or high water (or 2 inches of rain). Downtown gets torn up with light rail construction. Metro expresses puzzlement because bus and trolley ridership is down while downtown is torn up. So Metro modifies and cuts services. And ridership still plummets while light rail construction continues. Metro again scratches its head, and finally gives up and cuts bus and trolley service.

Some of Metro's critics accuse the agency of building rail and catering to commuters while shortchanging those who depend on local buses to get to work, the doctor or the grocery store.

"They promised 50 percent more bus routes, but they don't say that. They just say the people voted for rail," said bus rider Mark Smith.

"Metro could have crisscrossed the county with buses for what it will cost to build the rail system."

Yep.

Then we get into the pesky little issues of service "improvements" and per-rider subsidies:

Then there's Terrence Wilson, who was paralyzed from the waist down in a motorcycle accident 24 years ago. Wilson, 49, depends on Metro buses and his motorized wheelchair to get around.

Because many streets in his Acres Homes neighborhood lack sidewalks, Metro built a concrete slab on the shoulder for his wheelchair, he said. But over the years, his regular bus was replaced with a circulating shuttle, and then Metro shortened that route. It no longer passes his home, and Wilson said he now rides his chair in the street for a risky 1 1/2 miles to reach the bus stop.

Archer said Wilson's former route, the 64 Lincoln City Circulator, has kept 85 percent of its riders, despite being shortened, and now has more midday service and a more reliable schedule. It's also a good example of a dilemma that Metro often faces, he said.

"In Acres Homes," Archer said, "the customers are spread out, and because so many are elderly, they don't ride the bus every day."

That adds up to a taxpayer subsidy of $7.61 each time a rider steps on board, Archer said. As a general rule, Metro cuts or changes routes when the subsidy reaches $5.90, he said.

We want to see the per-rider subsidy for the light rail. Enough of this crap about per-rider subsidies for buses being too high. Providing bus service that can reach the people who need it the most is what Metro is SUPPOSED to be doing!

It is outrageous that Terrence Wilson has to go 1 1/2 miles in his wheelchair to catch a bus so that downtown residents and workers can look at world-class light rail trains.

Sallee's story concludes with an appearance by Tom Bazan and an admission that Metro has no way to count actual MetroRail riders. In fact, look at how Metro can claim "booming" ridership:

Because Metro has no practical way to count actual riders, it instead keeps track of boardings — usually expressed on an average weekday basis and counted by electronic devices on buses and trains. A single trip involving transfers, like Villanueva's journey to work, is counted as several boardings.

Metro's service area will be lucky to have any bus service left after the next round of rail expansion.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/22/05 07:36 AM |


21 August 2005

They are killing trees to print these editorials

The Chronicle's editorial board recently gave the President and Mrs. Bush a little advice on how to show some Texas hospitality to the Cindy Sheehan anti-war protesters who are just down the road in Crawford.

Bizarre.

And not only that, but the editorial writer shows a total lack of class and respect:

Now that the gathering of antiwar protesters will be just a stone's throw from the president's ranch, perhaps he and Laura should engage in another act of traditional Texas hospitality by dropping in unannounced on their new, though temporary, neighbors with a housewarming gift and a desire to make their acquaintance.

Laura? Is that how the First Lady should be addressed? Mrs. Bush or the First Lady would have been more appropriate, but then again, we don't quite understand the Chronicle's ideal state.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/21/05 10:11 PM |


Mayor changes course; Now there's money for HPD probe

The Chronicle's Matt Stiles reports that Mayor White has stepped up with funding plans for the next phase of the Bromwich investigation of the HPD crime lab:

The investigation into problems at the Houston crime lab, stalled because of rising costs, could resume under a plan Mayor Bill White will present to the City Council next week.

The mayor's spokesman said Friday that the city has the $1.6 million a special investigator says he needs.

"The mayor believes that we have the funding sources to back it up," spokesman Frank Michel said.

That comes after even the Chronicle editorial board had to give some credit to favorite "bad guy" Chuck Rosenthal for offering to fund part of the investigation in order to move it along.

The "public safety" mayor had previously been awfully quiet on the delay in the Bromwich investigation. Perhaps Rosenthal's offer to get it moving again embarrassed him into action.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/21/05 10:09 PM |


Steffy hits the "covert hospitality" brigade

On Friday, the Chronicle's L.M. Sixel reported on a gathering by Houston movers, shakers, and spin artists (such as Jordy Tollet, Jeff Moseley, and Frank Michel) to discuss how the city can boost itself to journalists in town to cover the Enron trial in January.

Today, Loren Steffy has a little fun with the entire "covert hospitality" notion.

It might also be useful to recall Ken Hoffman's fine advice after some of these same people failed in luring a future Super Bowl to Houston:

If I were an NFL team owner, and the Houston contingent came to my door, I'd put a piece of candy in their bag and send them away.

What if they came to your door and tried to convince you to write nice things about their shoes?

The national media probably won't cave like some writers.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/21/05 10:02 PM |


UH athletics under fire

Earlier in the week, various media outlets weighed in with reports on alleged improprieties regarding some athletes at the University of Houston. Athletics Director Dave Maggard reacted quickly and tried to downplay the allegations, but merely the suggestion of impropriety and the announcement of an NCAA investigation could set back an athletics program that has seen plenty of setbacks since the demise of the Southwest Conference.

Sedosi Alhambra has been tracking the story, and put up these posts.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/21/05 09:47 PM |


The "ideal state" of Army recruitment

Today's Chronicle editorial on Army recruitment is more puzzling than the usual fare.

The idealists suggest that highlighting various incentives is a misleading form of recruiting by the U.S. armed forces:

The new ads, however, might confuse some parents with their suggestions that the Army is primarily a job training program, a tuition source or, most worrisome, some kind of personal development retreat. Parents can succumb to wishful thinking when it comes to opportunities for their children. At a time when most recruits are destined for combat, this TV campaign may offer a perilously skewed view of what military service entails.

But the editorial concludes as follows:

In addition to its TV ads, the Army has taken proposed substantive steps to boost recruitment: greatly increasing financial incentives, offering down payments on homes and raising the maximum recruitment age to 42. These straightforward measures would do far more to prompt realistic decision-making than ads promoting wartime military service as a path to self-actualization.

So, some inducements to serve (job training, tuition) are worthy of disparagement from the editorial elitists down at 801 Texas Avenue, but others (financial incentives, down payments on homes) are "straightforward measures" that somehow relieve the original concern of the editorialists (that being the ridiculous assertion that recruits somehow don't understand that soldiers sometimes fight wars, and wars can be deadly)?

Seriously, a down payment on a house makes it more clear for the Chronicle editorial elitists that war can be deadly?

Does anybody at the Chronicle even read some of these editorials before they go to print?

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/21/05 09:40 PM |


Chron eye for the death row killer gal

The anti-death-penalty Chronicle starts early with today's Chron Eye on a killer not scheduled to die until September 14.

As protesters take to the streets and attorneys launch late-in-the-day efforts to save her from the executioner's needle, Frances Newton's capital murder case promises to pack an emotional punch rarely felt in Texas, a state that leads the nation in putting killers to death.

Newton, 40, is scheduled to die Sept. 14 for fatally shooting her husband and two young children in April 1987 to claim $100,000 in death benefits. She would be the third woman — and the first black woman — to be executed in the state since the Civil War. Her execution would be the 349th since Texas executions resumed in 1982.

Newton and her supporters consistently have proclaimed her innocence, but state and federal courts have on at least 10 occasions rejected motions filed on the Harris County woman's behalf.

With those facts established, most of the rest of the story clearly is intended to provide a forum for defense attorneys and activists looking to stop the execution.

The Chronicle devoted three reporters to this Chron Eye, weeks before the execution is scheduled.

Expect Mr. Kathryn Kase's newspaper to keep pushing hard on this one.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/21/05 09:17 PM |


Minutemen: Houstonians with permits may carry concealed weapons

The Chronicle's Edward Hegstrom reports that the organization that calls itself the Minutemen will not require Houston-area volunteers who have the legal right to carry a concealed weapon under Texas law to refrain from doing so.

Hegstrom phrases it somewhat differently:

The Minutemen will come to Houston bearing arms.

Leaders of the Minuteman Civil Defense Corps of Texas had earlier said volunteers observing Houston's day laborers in October would carry nothing but video cameras.

But leaders now say those involved in the operations targeting local illegal immigrants will be allowed to carry arms as long as they comply with all federal and state laws.

In fact, those who have a concealed-weapons permit are being offered a discount on joining the Minuteman Civil Defense Corps. An Arizona-based organization, the Minutemen started out by patrolling the Arizona-Mexico border in April to prevent illegal immigrants from crossing, but the group has announced it will conduct a variety of operations here this fall.

Greg at Rhymes with Right calls attention to the conclusion of the story:

Houston police are aware that some of the Minutemen will be armed, and officers will make sure that all laws are obeyed, said Lt. Robert Manzo, an HPD spokesman.

That isn't quite right, since it is official HPD policy not to enforce some aspects of federal immigration law.

Expect a Chronicle editorial by Tuesday or Wednesday condemning Texans who work with the Minutemen for even thinking about exercising their right to carry concealed weapons under Texas law.

RELATED COVERAGE: Associated Press.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/21/05 08:54 PM |


The three stooges of state government?

On Friday, the Chronicle editorial board wrote the following about the close of the latest legislative special session:

Gov. Rick Perry, Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst and House Speaker Tom Craddick come away from this session looking less like statesmen and more like Larry, Curley and Moe.

It is hard to believe a major metropolitan daily would commit such insulting language to print.

[Read More]

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/21/05 08:01 PM |


Inner loop, the 'burbs, and the Chron - Take two

A few days ago, I linked to a post by John Wagner that seemed to suggest that the Houston Chronicle pushes an inner-loop bias on its pages.

I wasn't quite sure that Wagner meant to go that far, and wondered if he was merely referring to the editorial page, which does seem to push the inner loop and downtown.

Wagner clarified on Thursday in this post, and made it clear that he did mean to indict the entire newspaper for an inner loop bias.

I think between us, we probably have a decent mix of readers inside the loop and out in the suburbs, so feel free again to add your thoughts here or at Wagner's place.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/21/05 07:35 PM |


20 August 2005

Not to worry, a Chron editor is looking into it

Byron Calame, the public editor of the New York Times, admits on his web journal that his newspaper was slow to cover the story of Air America's alleged peculiar financial transactions with the Gloria Wise Boys and Girls Club:

Readers of The Times were poorly served by the paper's slowness to cover official investigations into questionable financial transactions involving Air America, the liberal radio network. The Times's first article on the investigations finally appeared last Friday after weeks of articles by other newspapers in New York and elsewhere.

The Times's recent slowness stands in contrast to its flurry of articles about Air America in the spring of 2004, when the network was launched. "Liberal Voices (Some Sharp) Get New Home on Radio Dial," read the headline on The Times's article the morning of March 31 when the network went on the air. The article noted that the network had a staff headlined by comedian Al Franken and hopes of establishing a counterpoint to conservative radio personalities such as Rush Limbaugh.

Two months later, The Times reported that the network had come close to running out of money in April but had received an infusion of an undisclosed amount of cash from sources that weren't identified. The article noted that Evan M. Cohen, a primary early backer and the chairman of the network, had resigned.

[snip]

It has become clearer in the past week or so that Air America hasn't yet fully repaid the "loans" from the club, and its financial condition remains murky even in The Times's article Friday. So the future of the radio network seems to be a key question for The Times to answer.

Locally, Calame's equivalent at the Houston Chronicle had this reaction to the matter in response to a reader:

I'm not aware of the story regarding the accounting practices used by Air America. I will ask an editor to look into it.

That was posted on August 16.

Apparently, the editors are still looking into it, as we've not seen any stories on the matter posted to the Chronicle, and couldn't find any we might have inadvertently missed in our search of the Chron.com archives and Google news.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/20/05 06:53 PM |


19 August 2005

More job cuts at the Chronicle (updated)

Matt Bramanti points out that Chronicle Publisher and President Jack Sweeney announced the paper will "pare its work force" by seven percent:

In a letter to Chronicle employees released late Thursday, Sweeney outlined the changes, which include involuntary layoffs, open positions that will not be filled, and changes in the use of contract labor and use of outside services.

The restructuring will not affect the newsroom and advertising sales staff, Sweeney wrote.

Unemployment is no fun -- I hope all those who are restructured out of their jobs find new employment as soon as possible.

RELATED: Job cuts at the Chronicle

UPDATE: Editor & Publisher reminds us of the Chron's circulation woes:

The Chronicle is Texas' biggest paper and the ninth-largest U.S. daily. In the most recent Audit Bureau of Circulations FAS-FAX, the paper reported a daily circulation of 537,744 for the six months ended March 31, down 3.9% from the same period in 2004, and a Sunday circulation of 720,711, down 2.6% from last year.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/19/05 08:51 PM |


It's just like Monopoly (updated)

On the heels of yesterday's idiocy about the fantabulous Astrodome Hotel, today we learn that the city of Houston may soon take control of a second hotel:

Houston taxpayers have millions of dollars on the line -- money that former Mayor Lee Brown's administration loaned to private hotel developers. Now the current mayor is threatening to foreclose on two hotels that owe the city a small fortune.

As downtown Houston revived, the city government orchestrated a hotel building binge.

Around the same time, the city built its 1200 room convention center hotel. It also helped private developers build two other downtown hotels.

But the 11 News Defenders reported earlier this year that the Magnolia Hotel hasn't paid back a dime of the $9.5 million it owes the city -- missing payment after payment.

[snip]

But the Magnolia is a different story. City officials are already talking about foreclosing on the property and hiring an outside management team to come in and take the place over and keep it running until another buyer can be found.

In effect, the city of Houston would own yet another downtown hotel.

Some downtown hotels managers complain the city government helped flood the market with empty rooms.

"It seems, sometimes, politicians get into the supply and demand business, trying to force supply and demand to balance," said Sergio Ortiz, GM of the Lancaster Hotel. "But there's only one way it is balanced, which is free economics."

Now the city government's playing a different tune, saying it'll never again put taxpayer's money on the line for one of these downtown hotel deals.

It's a little late for that epiphany now.

As Tom Kirkendall has said previously, this is why the City of Houston should not be in the business of financing redevelopment projects.

UPDATE: Tom Kirkendall cautions Mayor White about seeking to foreclose on The Magnolia Hotel:

Note to Mayor White -- before you have the City foreclose its second lien on either of those hotel properties, please check to see whether either of them is generating enough revenue to pay operating expenses, much less debt service on the first lien indebtedness. Hotel properties "eat" money, and if the current owners are at least contributing enough to subsidize negative cash flows to operations, considering an alternative to foreclosure could save the City a ton of money. Sometimes you get more than you wish for when driving a hard bargain.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/19/05 08:05 PM |


Tom Kirkendall's review of Redstone's new course

Recently Tom Kirkendall noted that Redstone's new Tournament Course was open for business and he promised a first-hand review. Being quite the trooper, Tom found time in his schedule to give the course a try and he has posted the promised critique:

Several days ago, three pals and I teed it up at the Tournament Course for the first time. Although we should have had our heads examined, we decided -- in order to get the full flavor of the course -- that we would walk the course with caddies (in 95 degree temperature with 90% humidity!) and play the course from the tournament (i.e., the longest) tees. Inasmuch as the ground was still quite wet from a heavy rain storm the previous afternoon, we received no roll on our drives and felt like we trudged every one of the 7,500 yards of the course.

I told you he was a trooper!

Overall, the Tournament Course is an outstanding addition to the Houston golf scene. It is already a very good golf course, and has a chance to become a truly superior one. At this point, I would give the course a strong B+, but my sense is that the Houston Golf Association -- which did a wonderful job refining The TPC Course in The Woodlands over the years -- will make the improvements and modifications necessary to elevate the Tournament Course to one of the best golf courses in Houston and Texas. A strong golf course will not be enough alone to attract the best professional golfers back to the Shell Houston Open (a more favorable date help even more), but a strong course is a necessary component of a successful event, and the Tournament Course certainly fulfills that need.

There's much more, of course, and he has posted beautiful photographs, too. Go check it out.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/19/05 08:10 AM |


Ohio corruption trial wraps up; Houston investigation continues

The Chronicle's Dan Feldstein reports on the Ohio trial of Cleveland businessman Nate Gray that snared several former Brown Administration officials:

The Cleveland, Ohio, businessman accused of bribing two Houston officials was convicted on 36 felony counts in Akron on Wednesday, including bribery-related crimes in four cities.

Federal investigators spent years pursuing Nate Gray, 47, a well-known consultant who was close to Cleveland's former mayor. In the process, they snagged the Houston officials and vowed the investigation is not over here.

Oliver Spellman, who served as former Mayor Lee Brown's chief of staff, and Monique McGilbra, who was the city's building services director, both pleaded guilty to accepting bribes to help Gray or his consulting clients get business in Houston.

They testified against Gray to reduce their sentences.

[snip]

In Houston, the question is this: What did it mean when a federal prosecutor asked FBI agent R. Michael Massie on the witness stand whether the investigation was finished in Houston and Massie testified, "No"?

It probably means that Feldstein is going to be doing some very interesting reporting in the coming weeks and months.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/19/05 07:46 AM |


Metro board meeting topics: "smart cards" and Tasers

Rad Sallee went to yesterday's Metro board meeting and reports that Metro's "smart card" system will soon be back in development again:

The Metropolitan Transit Authority board voted Thursday to hire another firm because the original contractor, Cubic Transportation Systems of San Diego, Calif., was fired in March. The agency is seeking in court to recover the $4.5 million already paid to Cubic for the high-tech system that never met expectations.

Metro consultant Richard Lobron said Ascom Transport Systems products have performed well in New Jersey, Boston, Lyon, France, and elsewhere, and won't have to be redesigned for Metro's needs.

Lobron said sensors can respond to the cards' computer chip in a fraction of a second compared with several seconds to read cards with magnetic strips. This automatically deducts the fare from a prepaid amount, like EZ Tags on the county's tollways, he said.

[snip]

Although the Cubic contract was for $8.5 million and the board voted to spend up to $20 million with Ascom, Lobron said the two deals are very different. He said Ascom is charging $9.8 million for equipment and services that go beyond Cubic's offer, such as helping Metro market the cards and operating a help desk to answer users' questions for a year.

The $20 million is a "not to exceed" sum that Metro spokesman George Smalley said would allow for future expansions of the system not covered in the Cubic contract.

And Metro Police Chief Lambert wants more Tasers:

The board also heard a proposal from Metro Police Chief Tom Lambert to buy 140 Tasers, which shoot electric darts that administer a shock. Metro has had 30 of the devices, which cost about $1,000 each, since 2003 and has used them 20 times without serious injury, he said.

[snip]

Lambert said Tasers are intended for use when the alternative is bullets, but board Chairman David Wolff noted that the nonlethal nature of the devices can lead to overuse.

Posted by Anne Linehan @ 08/19/05 06:06 AM |


18 August 2005

Fleck knocks down Chron "firewall" between news/editorial

Back on August 4, we noted the delay in the Bromwich investigation of the HPD crime lab, and wrote,

The Chronicle editorial board is really going to have to stretch to blame this on Harris Country District Attorney Chuck Rosenthal.

A full two weeks later, the Chronicle editorial board finally got around to commenting on the matter, with a clumsy rhetorical effort that goes pretty easy on Chron "good guy" Bill White while taking shots at Chron "bad guy" Chuck Rosenthal:

Harris County District Attorney Chuck Rosenthal says he is willing to allocate money from one of several discretionary funds at his disposal to pay a portion of the crime lab probe costs. "I'm a resident of the city of Houston and I don't want the money coming out of HPD's budget," Rosenthal said.

He also says he wants to resolve the crime lab issue quickly because he doesn't feel it's as serious as has been reported. The Chronicle believes the scandal, with its faked or botched lab tests, inaccurate testimony and mishandled evidence pertaining to thousands of cases, some of them capital murder convictions obtained by Harris County prosecutors, is deadly serious.

The scandal IS serious, but until the investigation is complete, we will not know definitively if the crime lab's problems significantly affected the delivery of justice in Harris County.

Today's related "news" story by the Chronicle's Steve McVicker contains an assertion from a defense attorney that Chuck Rosenthal's motives in helping to get the crime lab investigation moving are suspect:

Although he would not say how much money he is offering, Rosenthal said Wednesday that he has contacted city officials about the possibility of using discretionary funds — such as drug-seizure money — to help underwrite the HPD probe.

Rosenthal acknowledged that he has a "selfish" motive for wanting to get the crime-lab investigation back on track: "I'd like to see it done just to get a resolution to this because I don't feel like there's been the immediacy or the problem that's been painted by y'all and the other media as to how bad things are."

To Houston defense lawyer Troy McKinney, Rosenthal's remarks are indicative of the overall crime-lab problem.

"They continue to take the attitude that any problems are isolated, and only anecdotal, even though there is a tremendous quantity of evidence that the problems are pervasive and continue," McKinney said.

If the crime lab's problems "are pervasive and continue," then how in the world has the crime lab under the current leadership managed to gain accreditation in all areas but DNA testing?

In reality, the excerpt we've cited seems intended as a shot at Chuck Rosenthal -- and it doesn't seem fair or accurate in light of the crime lab's recent accreditation. The defense attorney's assertions NEVER should have made it into a credible "news" story without the reporter at least pointing out the crime lab's accreditation (which would go a long way toward refuting the quote, which leads us back to the notion that the quote NEVER should have appeared in a credible "news" story).

But therein lies the problem. Sedosi Alhambra noticed this curious credit at the bottom of the "news" story:

Chronicle staffer Tim Fleck contributed to this report.

Tim Fleck is not just any "Chronicle staffer." Tim Fleck is a member of the Chronicle editorial board!

So, not only did the Chronicle run an editorial today that took a cheap shot at Chuck Rosenthal, it also ran a "news" story in which it used a suspect quote from a defense attorney to take a cheap shot at Chuck Rosenthal, a "news" story to which an editorial board member contributed!

So much for that "division between the opinion pages and the news pages" that one Chronicle editor/blogger once pointed out to us.

Posted by Kevin Whited @ 08/18/05 11:03 PM |


[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]

 SITE MENU

+Home
+About
+Archives
+BH Commentary (RSS)
+Bloggers
+Blogroll
+Contact Us
+Forum
+Local News Headlines
+Syndication
+Twitter