05 February 2006
Privacy is determined by the media
It's no secret that the Chronicle's editorial leadership is opposed to the NSA eavesdropping on terrorist phone calls (to the point of rewriting the Constitution), and not enthusiastic about the Patriot Act, but when it comes to writing a story, the Chronicle can decide to throw an individual's privacy out the window, apparently, to further the story.
James Campbell's column today touches on this subject in relation to a recent Chronicle story on the death of a Bellaire student. The story included details of the family's personal life:
Readers also learned that Finkelman occasionally hung with the wrong crowd, flirted with drugs and faced disciplinary problems at school, according to classmates. His parents are divorced and both of his older brothers have had brushes with the law and drugs.
To backstop our description of Finkelman's comfortable upbringing, we reported that days before his death he had returned from a cruise to Belize and Cozumel with his father and brothers. We reported that his father, Alan Finkelman, heads a wholesale men's apparel company and lives in a 4,300-square-foot home in Bellaire worth about $500,000. The home also has a spa and swimming pool.
Campbell says he has since received emails expressing concern that those kinds of details invaded the family's privacy. He agrees in part, then adds the reasoning of day city editor Ronnie Crocker:
"I think that when you have a homicide in a part of town and involving students at one of our premier high schools that's unusual," Crocker explained. "And unusual is one of the definitions of news. As far [sic] the appraisal district information, his home life and background convey a fact that an adjective couldn't. We always want to use facts in lieu of adjectives. We felt that his home life was a significant part of the story. But it's never our intention to add to the suffering of grieving families, and we are conscientious about not sensationalizing crime or other tragedies. At the same time, we're obligated to report on events and issues of interest to the community. We work hard to strike a balance there."
Basically we are left to conclude that the media believes it is the final arbiter of what should or should not be private. When the media feels the need to invade someone's privacy, then it's a-okay! (Except for those instances where something backfires.)
Perhaps Editor Crocker should read the Society of Professional Journalists' Code of Ethics:
# Recognize that private people have a greater right to control information about themselves than do public officials and others who seek power, influence or attention. Only an overriding public need can justify intrusion into anyone’s privacy.
# Show good taste. Avoid pandering to lurid curiosity.
And after reading that, Crocker should rethink whether including some of those details was really necessary. Were they essential to the story?
Or we could put it this way: what if it was, God forbid, a Chronicle editor's or staffer's son who had died. Would those same details have been included? We can guess the answer is no.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/05/06 07:44 PM |
When TV reporters tackle social-science modelling...
KHOU-11 ran a story on Friday that purported to determine the effect of Katrina refugees on Houston crime:
So we calculated New Orleans' murder rate before Katrina. We then used that to estimate how many more murders there would be among 150,000 new residents, the estimated number of evacuees now living here.
We then compared that to how many murders there'd be using Houston's lower murder rate.
The result: if evacuees were involved in murders at the same rate in Houston as they were back in New Orleans, Houston would register about 80 more murders a year, or about seven more a month.
Using Houston's lower rate, there'd be only about 2 more murders a month.
The reality is that since September, HPD says there have been 26 Katrina-related murders, or about five a month.
In other words, Katrina evacuees seem to be involved in murder at a rate not quite as high as back in New Orleans, but higher than Houston's.
If the murders continue, Houston's overall murder rate would rise.
But will that really happen?
Consider what has happened at Fred Bhandara's complex.
Since the murder there in December, HPD has flooded this area with task force officers.
The complex added its own security patrols and Crime Watch program.
They've had no more murders at the complex.
About all this exercise tells us is that we have seen an increase in violent crime following the influx of Katrina evacuees. It's not unreasonable to ask if a criminal element among the Katrina evacuees is disproportionately responsible for the increase. But it's also important to keep in mind that HPD's manpower shortage was a problem before the influx of Katrina refugees. It may well be that the spike in violent crime is also reflective of that manpower shortage (though perhaps the Katrina influx has exacerbated the problem). A properly specified model would take that into consideration.
Now that the local press is finally reporting on HPD's manpower shortage with some regularity, MayorWhiteChiefHurtt are cognizant of the need to get someone else to pay for them to boost HPD's manpower after several years of indifference:
HPD will be asking Uncle Sam for $40 million to fund 400 new officers.
And crime stats will be used to make it's case: Houston needs help.
More power to MayorWhiteChiefHurtt if they can convince the feds to help us out, but the manpower problem is mostly one of our own politicians' making.
RELATED: New Orleans failures led crime here (Kim Cobb, Houston Chronicle).
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/05/06 11:27 AM |
Chron corrections: The vignette that didn't pass muster
The Chronicle continued a recent pattern of unusual corrections yesterday:
Cliff Stricklin grew up in Dallas and was immediately accepted to Washington and Lee University School of Law after a stint working for the Drug Enforcement Administration. A story on Page A25 Sunday incorrectly described his admission to the university.
Here's the original story:
When Cliff Stricklin decided to study law, he was eager to attend an elite school, so he applied at Washington & Lee in Virginia, among the oldest and most respected in the nation.
His undergraduate grades at Baylor were good but not great, and Stricklin was rejected.
Stricklin, who lived in Washington, D.C., at the time and was working for the Drug Enforcement Administration, persuaded the dean to meet with him. The dean agreed but limited the meeting to 15 minutes.
"He ended up meeting with the dean for an hour and a half," said Gil Stricklin, his father.
When it was over, after discussing a shared passion for American history, the dean stood up, extended her hand and said: "Congratulations, counselor. You've won your first case."
That odd vignette has now been excised completely from the version of the story currently posted online, which notes that an earlier version contained errors.
It's good that the errors have been corrected, but one wonders how they made it through the vaunted fact-checking process in the first place. Alas, since the reader rep has fallen down on his promise to blog about these matters daily, we're probably not going to find out.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/05/06 10:48 AM |
04 February 2006
Maybe they could name it the Houston American-Statesman?
Today, the University of Houston men's basketball team won a tough road game in overtime.
The Rice men's basketball team narrowly lost to #3 Memphis at Autry Court.
And here is Chron.com's scoreboard:

Nice coverage of the local guys.
A reader could at least turn to the posted AP coverage of the UH game:
Lanny Smith scored 20 points and Brian Latham tallied 17 points and 18 rebounds to lead Houston to a 64-60 overtime win against East Carolina on Saturday.
Houston (14-6, 5-3 Conference USA) shot only 28.6 percent from the field in the first half, and East Carolina (7-14, 1-7) went to the locker room at the break with a 35-28 lead having shot 44 percent.
Whoops. That was Ramon Dyer who tallied 17 points and 18 rebounds, not Brian Latham. Guard, forward, what professional sports journalist can tell the difference?
The newspaper will surely post Michael Murphy's coverage tomorrow (probably replacing the AP story with it), and Murphy does a good job covering UH athletics. But that really doesn't address the dysfunctional online scoreboard (which strangely can show UT and Texas A&M scores, but never the local guys) or the fact that a (temporary) online story about a local team contained errors.
As Dwight Silverman might say, Chron.com's coverage of local sports really needs to evolve.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/04/06 09:59 PM |
Is "unsafe and careless action" a fireable offense?
In METRO news related to Anne Linehan's earlier post, the Chronicle's Rad Sallee reports that the driver involved in the accident that killed a pedestrian was fired on Friday:
A Metropolitan Transit Authority bus driver was fired Friday for "unsafe and careless action and disregard for established safety procedures" in a fatal accident with a pedestrian, Metro spokeswoman Raequel Roberts said.
Metro also revealed Friday, with the permission of the driver, Romain Alexandre, 56, that drug and alcohol tests he took after the Jan. 20 accident that killed Domitila Leon, 43, were negative.
[snip]
Alexandre, who had only minor infractions on his record since being hired in 1993, was cited for failure to yield right-of-way to a pedestrian and had been suspended with pay during the investigation.
Witnesses said his bus, westbound on Hogan, turned south on Main and struck Leon in the crosswalk, dragging her about 20 feet and running over her.
Have we finally seen a fireable offense at a local public entity? Or will a civil service commission insist on the reinstatement of the driver at some point?
Stay tuned.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/04/06 07:08 PM |
More banking industry lessons on the Chron letters page
Does anyone see the irony in this:
METRO Responds to Chronicle Editorial
Feb. 2, 1006This morning, the Houston Chronicle ran a letter from METRO President and CEO Frank Wilson responding to a Jan. 29th editorial critical of METRO's response to pedestrian fatalities. Some of Mr. Wilson's comments were edited out of the letter. We would like you to see the letter in its entirety.
That's rich!
Remember when Rep. John Culberson's letter to the editor about Metro funding was (interestingly) edited? Since we ran Rep. Culberson's full letter (no space constraints on blogHOUSTON, unlike Chron.com apparently), we'll helpfully run Wilson's complete letter in the extended entry.
For some reason I am reminded of banking industry loan failure rates.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/04/06 05:37 PM |
03 February 2006
Because multiple blogs, cams, a carnival, and podcasting weren't enough
Laurence Simon has taken on catblogging duties at Chron.com. His blog is called Catcall, although I, too, liked the Houston Scratching Post.
Can Laurence be tamed for the (mostly) family-friendly environment at Chron.com? Keep checking Catcall to find out.
Post lots of kitty pictures, Laurence!
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/03/06 08:02 PM |
Phew, Chron Editor Emeritus is still among the living
Via today's Chronicle:
Houston Chronicle Editor Emeritus Jack Loftis was honored Thursday by Crime Stoppers of Houston for his ongoing commitment to the anti-crime program.
[snip]
"When we all got involved in Crime Stoppers, we didn't realize how effective it would be," said Loftis, who retired from the Chronicle in 2002 after 15 years as editor and nearly four decades with the paper. "After we found out we were onto something, the Chronicle was very strongly behind it."
The Chronicle recently honored Mr. Loftis by removing his name from its masthead. The Chronicle also removed the name of Chairman Emeritus Richard J.V. Johnson, presumably because he passed away. It's unclear why Editor Emeritus Loftis was erased from the top of the editorial page.
(Thanks to Vernon Guy for pointing out the Chronicle masthead's new look.)
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/03/06 07:20 PM |
Cactus Music is closing at the end of March
H-Town Grooves and Jeff Balke both have posted that Cactus Music and Video is closing up shop.
A phone call to the venerable record store confirmed the bad news: Cactus is indeed closing at the end of March.
That's quite a blow, as Cactus was a merchant for many Houston and Texas independent acts that megamerchants like Best Buy would never stock. Cactus also hosted many in-store performances for local, regional, and even national acts.
UPDATE: The Chronicle has the story posted.
MORE BLOGVERSATION: Hand Stamp, Mike McGuff.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/03/06 01:38 PM |
Oz Bar films patrons in restroom
It's about time for the local television news outlets to start their titillating "undercover" investigations for ratings purposes.
KHOU-11's Mark Greenblatt jumped right in last night with a report on cameras in the restrooms at the Oz Bar in north Houston.
The owner of the bar, Randy Ozburn, came off looking pretty bad in the KHOU report.
He compounded the problem just a while ago with a phone call to the Michael Berry show on KPRC-950. Ozburn repeatedly stuck foot in mouth. He also managed to sneak a "bullshit" bomb past the KPRC censors, at least on the streaming audio version.
Let's hope Councilmember Addie Wiseman wasn't listening, or Councilmember Berry and Ken Charles are likely to get all kinds of grief!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/03/06 09:54 AM |
How they see Judge Sim Lake
Judge Sim Lake, who is overseeing the Enron fraud trial, has been profiled by two prominent newspapers today.
The Financial Times profile gets off to a predictable start:
Judge Sim Lake has spent most of his life in the Lone Star State. Yet he could hardly be further removed from the stereotypical strutting Texan.
Belated warning to any international media in Houston -- beware of the stereotypical strutting Texans! But be even more wary of the Danger Train. It kills.
The Washington Post profile dives right into substance:
As the trial of Enron Corp.'s former leaders ends its first week, U.S. District Judge Simeon T. Lake III is turning into its most active player. Thursday, he beat back repeated defense objections, urged the government to file color-coded document lists and stepped in on occasion to pose his own questions of the prosecution's first witness.
It was quintessential Lake. He is a man in control -- of his emotions, of his fitness regimen, and, most especially, of his courtroom.
So there you have it. Hat tip to the Wall Street Journal Law Blog for the links.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/03/06 08:57 AM |
02 February 2006
Houston airports are world class!
The Houston Business Journal reports that the Houston Airport system has launched a revamped, more interactive website.
We clicked over, and were pleased to learn from the banner that our airports are world class.
Yeah!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/02/06 10:33 PM |
Is Rick Casey "borrowing" without attribution again? (upated)
Sedosi Alhambra noticed something interesting about the latest offering from Chronicle metro/state editorialist and gossip columnist Rick Casey.
In the column, Casey effectively uses a decision by an Austin bankruptcy judge to criticize the recent Congressional reworking of bankruptcy law.
It's not a bad read. A couple of excerpts are of interest, though:
FRANK Monroe used to be a bankruptcy lawyer at a prominent Houston firm.
Now he's a bankruptcy judge in Austin.
An angry bankruptcy judge in Austin.
[snip]
"This Court views this requirement as inane," Monroe wrote in his memorandum of opinion. "However, it is a clear and unambiguous provision obviously designed by Congress to protect consumers."
Quoting that last sentence out of context does not begin to convey the sarcasm with which it was clearly written.
Earlier in the memorandum, Judge Monroe began warming up: "Those responsible for the passing of the Act did all in their power to avoid the proffered input from sitting United States Bankruptcy Judges, various professors of bankruptcy law at distinguished universities, and many professional associations filled with the best of the bankruptcy lawyers in the country as to the perceived flaws in the Act.
"This because the parties pushing the passage of the Act had their own agenda. It was apparently an agenda to make more money off the backs of the consumers in this country."
Monroe wrote that "to call the Act a 'consumer protection' Act is the grossest of misnomers."
Here's Tom Kirkendall's post on this topic from a week ago. Kirkendall cites the same text as Casey, then concludes:
Moreover, he's just getting warmed up in the foregoing passage. Read the whole thing. Steve Jakubowski comments and provides more context here.
Jakubowski's blog provides the following background:
To put this opinion in its context, you need to know something about Judge Monroe, former member of the great Houston-based bankruptcy firm of Sheinfeld, Maley & Kay, which dissolved in 2001 (ironically, according to one partner, "because of the resurgence of bankruptcy as a very hot practice area"). Judge Monroe practiced at SM&K continuously starting fresh out of the University of Texas law school in 1969, even serving as its managing partner for several years. His investiture as bankruptcy judge occurred on March 31, 2002.
As Sedosi notes, it's interesting that Casey uses much the same information as two legal bloggers who wrote on this topic a week ago, and even a key term that Kirkendall used to characterize the very same excerpt.
Perhaps it's a coincidence. Indeed, it surely must be a coincidence, because after Casey got caught brazenly ripping off whole phrases from the work of others and presenting it as his own nearly two years ago, one would think he'd be careful at least to rephrase his "borrowing" more carefully. If he is indeed still borrowing.
UPDATE (02-03-2006): Rick Casey covers another topic (Governor Perry's so-called "65% plan") from a reliably lefty point of view in his Friday column. As Sedosi notes, this same criticism has already been offered by a number of lefty blogs. The Chronicle's metro/state editorialist/gossip columnist may need a vacation if the best he can do is recycle old blog posts. Or he may need to retire.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/02/06 10:14 PM |
Kevin Whited in the Wall Street Journal
Yesterday's Wall Street Journal carried a subscriber-only story that featured a quote from blogHOUSTON's own Kevin Whited.
The story, by Susan Warren, was about the Enron trial -- how local media is covering it, and how Houston in general is reacting to the trial. Since the story is not available online, I will excerpt only two paragraphs from the story, including Kevin's quote:
Houston television and radio stations also are running multiple stories and carving out big blocks of space on their Web sites for parsing the Enron trial with news features, analysis, editorials and blogs by reporters and commentators.
"The circus is officially under way," said Kevin Whited, a Houston energy analyst who writes about local politics and media on bloghouston.net.
Oh wait, I might have to excerpt one more sentence:
At the time of Enron's collapse in 2001, the Houston Chronicle and other media were viewed as slow in picking up the story.
Yup.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/02/06 07:23 PM |
KHOU: Federal judge rules in favor of reassigned police officer
KHOU-11 is reporting that a federal judge has ruled in favor of officer Tom Nixon, who brought suit after being assigned to desk duty for speaking out against the department's pursuit policy:
A Houston police officer is once again criticizing his department’s chase policy Thursday morning.
A federal judge ruled Thursday morning that he, in fact, could do that.
HPD commanders gave officer Thomas Nixon desk duty after he complained the department is unnecessarily putting the public in danger.
His comments came after a chase last month in which a suspect hit a family head-on.
Nixon said it could have been avoided if officers had permission to ram the suspect’s car.
But HPD commanders punished him for his comments.
A federal judge overruled that Thursday morning.
Nixon remains under suspension while HPD investigates articles he wrote for Houston's 002 magazine.
UPDATE: Chris Baker says that Nixon will be on his program on KTRH-740 today.
RELATED COVERAGE: Houston Chronicle, KTRK-13.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/02/06 01:31 PM |
Free tickets to Rice baseball or basketball
Are you interested in Rice basketball or baseball?
If so, you have a couple of days left to score free tickets:
Make it a day with the Owls on Sat., Feb. 4, as Rice's baseball and basketball teams are in action. See the fourth-ranked Rice Baseball team open the season against Central Missouri State at 2 pm at Reckling Park and then support the Rice Owls Basketball team as it hosts number-three ranked Memphis at 6:05 pm at Autry Court.
Free tickets for both events will be given away during lunch-time at the Whataburger restaurants on 59/Shepherd and the Southwest Freeway/Edloe (across from Lakewood Church) locations starting Jan. 30 through Feb. 3.
Rice's baseball team is, of course, a national power. Rice's basketball team is not, but their opponent (Memphis) is.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/02/06 11:50 AM |
Queen Sheila heads for the Enron cameras
Fresh off her usual appearance at the State of the Union proceedings, Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee (D) has made a beeline for the media horde covering Enron. The Chronicle's Mary Flood blogs about it:
The ubiquitous Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee appeared in the courtroom this morning. Though she would not speak on the record, she did kiss both Ken Lay and his wife Linda.She said she will visit the trial often and plans to make a comment at another time.
She will visit the trial often so long as the national media remains engaged. If national media outlets begin to reduce their coverage, then we probably will not see as much of Queen Sheila.
BLOGVERSATION: Brazosport News, Slampo's Place.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/02/06 11:14 AM |
Stealing or accounting oversight?
Last week, reports surfaced that officials at Texas Southern University here in town are investigating the use of funds by the institution's president on her private residence (some people might call that use of funds "stealing").
The Chronicle's Matthew Tresaugue follows up on the story today:
Texas Southern University President Priscilla Slade has reimbursed the university more than $138,000 for the cost of landscaping her new home, according to records released Wednesday.
Slade, who wrote the check Monday, is hoping to get back into the good graces of the university's board of regents before they meet Friday to discuss her future. She is also under scrutiny for charging roughly $87,000 to TSU for household furnishings, according to a source familiar with the inquiry.
So, it's possible that she used over $200,000 of university (really, taxpayers') funds for personal expenditures (again, people more judgmental than this humble scribe might be inclined to call that use of funds "stealing"). The story indicates that an investigation is ongoing. The matter is complicated by the fact that TSU does not provide an official residence for its president, and thus Dr. Slade's private residence is frequently used for university business.
Tom Kirkendall noted the following irony in the story:
Slade, 54, who earned a doctorate in accounting from UT-Austin, has received high marks during her tenure as president of the university.
A doctorate in accounting? You would think Dr. Slade of all people would be diligent about not using public funds for private purposes (again, some people might call that "stealing").
BLOGVERSATION: TBIFOC.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/02/06 10:32 AM |
01 February 2006
Why Harris County might want to sell HCTRA
In a post over at the Houston Architecture Info Forum about Harris County studying whether or not it should keep HCTRA (Harris County Toll Road Authority), there are a couple of intriguing responses:
Because they (may) want a short term gain, the future be damned since they won't be around to deal with it. Obviously, the future cash flow can belong to Harris County or a private firm, and the since the private firm needs to earn a profit and pay all the Wall Street fees, and net present value to Harris County has to be less than if it remained in County control.
Don't underestimate politicians desire to mortgage the future. Bush can do it by explosively increasing the national debt. State and local governments need to use indirect methods to mortgage the future (such as unfunded pension obligations), and now with mechanisms like selling off transportation assets they have a new way to realize a near-term gain.
And:
My sources say Harris County TR has so much debt, it's hurting their bond rating.
That's [why] they are looking to sell.
BLOGVERSATION: Houblog.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/01/06 08:27 PM |
Icing down the Azalea Trail
We've had a wonderful winter this year, temperature-wise, which is bad when one is trying to time azalea blooming:
Thanks to this mild winter, spring is inching ever closer. Too close for Bart Brechter, garden curator at Bayou Bend.
Hundreds of azaleas thrive throughout the wooded 14-acre estate, a perennial stop on the River Oaks Garden Club's annual azalea trail. This year's event is March 10-12, but some of the plants are already beginning to show color — so Brechter has been looking for ways to delay blooms.
His solution? Eight thousand pounds of ice.
Tuesday, crews spread 40-pound bags of ice cubes around 600-700 azaleas. An insulating layer of mulch was then applied on the ice to help keep temperatures down.
Cool! =)
(P.S. Some of us would LOVE to see a Kathy Huber gardening blog on Chron.com.)
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/01/06 08:14 PM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]

