28 February 2005
MAP in Montgomery County
South Montgomery County has its own Motorist Assistance Program:
The function of the taxpayer-funded program, which costs about $130,000 per year in salaries and fuel, is to reduce auto accidents caused by rubbernecking drivers distracted by motorists stranded along roadways in South Montgomery County.
The program also is an alternative to compulsory towing programs, like the hotly-debated Safe Clear program started in January along Houston freeways.
"We try to do whatever we can to get you down the road. And if we can't accomplish that, we've got a cell phone so you can call someone," Gilchrist said.
[snip]
The motorist assistance program came about as a partnership between the Precinct 3 Constable's Office, Montgomery County Precinct 3 Commissioner's Office and Buckalew Chevrolet in Conroe, which provides the vehicles at no cost to the county.
"(An auto) dealer agreed to help with a program to keep our roadways and our highways open and free of obstructions and stranded motorists," Holifield said.
Two constable's deputies — one who works the day shift from 6 a.m. to 2 p.m. and one who patrols from 2 p.m. to 10 p.m. — monitor Interstate 45, Texas 242 and local roadways.
[snip]
"I'd like to see it expanded countywide. They work Interstate 45 from Spring Creek north to the San Jacinto River, although they'll go further if they get an emergency call, and (Texas) 242, Rayford/Sawdust Road, and some on the more major streets that carry 40,000 cars, like Woodlands Parkway," [Montgomery County Precinct 3 Commissioner Ed] Chance said.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/28/05 11:57 AM |
Spur 527 and Houston signage
Outbound Spur 527 will be closed this weekend, and when it reopens, drivers will notice some changes:
This weekend, the Texas Department of Transportation enters the last step of the final phase of rebuilding the spur and the Southwest Freeway section it connects to south of downtown Houston. Crews will close the outbound spur at 9 p.m. Friday. It will stay shuttered all day Saturday and reopen early Sunday.
When the weekend's traffic shift is complete, commuters will notice several changes to the outbound spur. Vehicles will travel on the new inbound lanes. Two entry ramps will be closed for this last step of work, estimated to be complete in summer 2006.
The biggest potential headache will be the reduction of spur traffic from two lanes to one approaching the merge onto southbound Southwest Freeway. That potential chokepoint — the spur had three outbound lanes before work began in February 2004 — has downtown leaders and transportation officials advising commuters to think about other routes.
Also, Laurence Simon has come up with some alternative Houston highway signs.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/28/05 10:29 AM |
Heavy trash zero-tolerance
Mayor White's heavy trash policy, where people who put it out too early get cited, has some residents complaining:
"I've lived here 39 years and in that time, I've set my heavy trash out twice, and I get a ticket," he said.
He wasn't alone. Several of the mostly senior residents at the recent Kashmere Gardens Super Neighborhood meeting expressed uncertainty about Houston's new heavy trash schedule.
But confusion about their trash day — and how early they can place it in front of their residences — won't keep them from being ticketed under Mayor Bill White's zero-tolerance policy under which citations are liberally handed out to people who set tree limbs, tires, furniture and other big items early.
[snip]
Ignorance of the schedule or absentmindedness will not prevent tickets ranging from $50 to $2,000 for schedule violators, he [Houston Police Officer Tony Emanuel] said.
I wonder how much money the city has collected so far?
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/28/05 08:41 AM |
Metro needs help figuring out why ridership is down
In today's Chronicle is a short bit with highlights from the latest Metro Board meeting. In addition to authorizing extra money for MAP and agreeing to sell surplus trolley cars to Austin, the board discussed the smart card system, which still isn't doing what it's supposed to be doing, and then there's this:
The board authorized spending $250,000 for a survey firm to research why transit ridership has gone down in recent years and what Metro can do to attract more passengers.
Shoot. For a lot less than $250,000, blogHOUSTON's writers and readers could give Metro a list of reasons why ridership has gone down. If you'd like to give the Metro Board some hints, fire away in the forum.
UPDATE: Owen Courreges has his own (smart) thoughts on why Metro is having a problem attracting riders:
Metro has shown that it doesn’t care about its actual ridership base, and instead is fishing for yuppies.
Yep.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/28/05 07:55 AM |
27 February 2005
Chron editorialists want new privileges for "journalists"
Today's Chron editorial advocating new privileges for journalists based on a mischaracterization of the Plame affair seems once again to take the editorialists far from the ideal state the opinion page's interim editor has previously glorified.
The editorial begins with an overblown assertion:
Two news reporters, Judith Miller of The New York Times and Matthew Cooper of Time magazine, face going to jail for 18 months. Their crime? They agreed to listen to what a senior administration official had to say on the condition that they would not publicly connect the information with the official's name.
No, that's not their crime. Local blogger and attorney William Dyer has knocked down similar contentions effectively (most recently here), as has Orrin Judd. The First Amendment does not, and should not (they contend) bestow any privilege on a journalist or anyone else to withhold information related to a crime.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/27/05 06:55 PM |
City should focus on loan-default "revenue stream"
On February 23, Anne Linehan called attention to a KHOU-11 report by Mark Greenblatt on the city's seeming indifference to multimillion-dollar defaults on city loans made to various downtown developers.
Readers of the Chronicle found out about this news in February 26 print editions of the newspaper.
Apparently, city officials were able to get their talking points in better order for the Chronicle story. Recall the statements of John Walsh, the city's point man on this matter, to KHOU's reporter:
The Defenders couldn't find a single payment that the Magnolia Hotel has ever made to the city of Houston. When asked if that surprised him, Walsh said, "No. I can't vouch for the reason why it has taken so long for us to pursue the collection of these loans."
But Walsh says the city might not be able to collect.
"Then if we can't collect it, we'll just take our lumps and do the best we can."
After a few days, though, the mayor's spin machine has Mr. Walsh sounding much better for the Chronicle:
The city intends to "aggressively pursue" repayment by the owners of the Magnolia Hotel and the Crowne Plaza Hotel, said John Walsh, Mayor Bill White's deputy chief of staff for neighborhoods and housing.
Tom Kirkendall calls these defaults -- along with the city's partnership in the Hilton Americas hotel -- "two more examples of why the City of Houston should not be in the business of financing redevelopment projects."
It is worth noting that Mayor White effectively used the Hilton America's hotel to collaterize part of the city's underfunded obligations to the municipal employees pension fund, and that even with optimistic assumptions regarding that hotel's performance (which may not pan out), that pension fund remains underfunded to the tune of some $850 million dollars.
Clearing up matters with such short- and long-term revenue implications for the city deserves much higher priority than revenue-enhancement efforts such as red-light cameras, expansion of downtown parking meters hours and coverage, or parking authorities.
RELATED: Hyatt Regency in Foreclosure.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/27/05 05:54 PM |
Political consultant's accountant accused of embezzling
On February 18, KTRK-13's Miya Shay reported that an employee of Allen Blakemore's political consulting firm had been accused of embezzling at least $100,000. Chris Elam noted the news on his blog.
The "olds" appeared in print editions of the Houston Chronicle a week after the KTRK story.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/27/05 04:32 PM |
KHOU introduces new executive news director
KHOU-11 has a new executive news director:
KHOU-TV Channel 11 has named Keith Connors Executive News Director. Connors comes to KHOU from Belo owned WCNC-TV in Charlotte, North Carolina where he has been Executive News Director since March of 1998.
[snip]
In 2004, under Connors’ direction WCNC-TV won a number of prestigious national journalism awards including the George Foster Peabody award, the DuPont-Columbia award and the Scripps Howard Foundation award. In the three years prior, the WCNC newsroom earned three regional Edward R. Murrow awards for overall excellence.
Prior to serving as Executive News Director of WCNC-TV in Charlotte, Connors was Executive News Director of Belo’s WVEC-TV in Norfolk, VA; News Director for WOKR-TV in Rochester, NY; Executive Producer at WTOL in Toledo, OH and held several news management positions with WKRN in Nashville, TN.
Connors replaces KHOU Vice President News, Mike Devlin. Devlin will become station manager of Belo owned WFAA-TV in Dallas on February 28.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/27/05 04:23 PM |
Chron editorializes on Woodfill
The Chronicle ran a predictable editorial on Friday blasting recent comments by Jared Woodfill, Harris County Republican Chair.
What was predictable about the Chron's editorial was not that it blasted Woodfill. Rather, it's that the Chronicle editorialists denied that political perspective has any role to play in policy formation:
Houston's nonpartisan municipal elections were designed from the start to keep partisan ideology and antagonism at bay. Mobility, garbage collection, parks and libraries defy pigeonholing by party. There is no Republican sewer line, no Democratic pothole. Opposing a solution just to score points against the official proposing it hurts everyone who lives in the city.
We agree with that last sentence. However, that's not the same as saying political ideology can't inform and lead to very different policy choices.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/27/05 03:49 PM |
What happened to the downtown trolleys?
Just under a year ago, Kevin Whited posted, on his personal blog, this news story about Metro's plan for its transit services to better serve the light rail:
Laid out in the presentation are pages with maps of transit services that will be eliminated, or modified so that the routes feed into the METRO rail.
"The plan is designed to integrate the rail system with the overall transit system, to make the maximum use of both buses and rail," said METRO spokesperson Ken Connaughton.
Part of the plan is to eliminate all of the routes of the downtown trolleys.
Then yesterday Lucas Wall told us this:
Metro has sold six surplus trolley buses to Capital Metro in Austin, illustrating the waning of downtown circulator routes served by the special vehicles designed to resemble old-fashion streetcars.
Well, what happened to the trolleys?
The passenger count has waned in recent years, however, despite the continued churn of street and light rail construction. Last June, with boardings down to about 3,200 per weekday and trains running on Main Street, the authority decided to consolidate the trolley routes from six to three and remove night and Saturday service.
Even fewer riders used the new routes. On Nov. 1, Metro cut them down to two and reduced the hours even further. For the first time, a fare was established — 50 cents, exact change only.
Those curtailments have produced lower ridership figures, and all downtown trolleys are now on the chopping block as the long-awaited end to transit-street construction nears.
Gosh, that's strange: cut routes, cut service, add a fare and the people aren't flocking to it. Go figure.
And does Wall ask Metro about the plan from a year ago to eliminate the trolley? It doesn't look like it:
"The downtown trolley program was designed to compensate people downtown for the disruptions caused by reconstruction of the transit streets," said Metro Chairman David Wolff. "The trolleys might not be a permanent fixture."
Wolff described the recent passenger counts as "really anemic." Under Metro's business philosophy, routes low in demand will be slashed.
"If the demand were there," Wolff said, "people would be on them."
Metro's chairman just says that ridership is anemic and demand isn't there.
You know, if the average Houston reader hasn't been paying attention to the MetroRail story in great detail, he or she might assume that trolley ridership has just mysteriously dried up. Because Wall sure doesn't let on that eliminating the trolleys was actually a part of Metro's plan.
CALLIE MARKANTONIS ADDS: Why does it seem as if the Chron unquestioningly accepts Metro's account--unquestioningly accepting ridership figures, unquestioningly accepting statements about the lack of usage of the new, Metro-Rail-inspired trolley routes--to the point where it will even erroneously attack local elected officials on its behalf (Culberson and Delay) when the agency is clearly culpable, etc., but does take HISD and CPS and the District Attorney's office to task on matters large or small, imaginary or real?
No other governmental entity garners such cushy coverage. Why?
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/27/05 09:54 AM |
26 February 2005
There's more to the story of Texas defying NCLB
Both the Chronicle and the Dallas Morning News have the story about the Texas Education Agency not following a federal rule, regarding special education testing, in the No Child Left Behind act. That allowed many Texas school districts to achieve an "adequate yearly progress" grade, instead of being placed in the "needs improvement" category.
I think it's worth exploring a bit more what is behind the TEA's decision and why it does not mean that Texas schools are poorly educating their students. Between the two stories, the DMN's has better background and details to understand what happened and why.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/26/05 03:56 PM |
Press tackles "evil Republican" developer
This week, the Houston Press passed up an opportunity to do some balanced, interesting journalism on the massive redevelopment going on inside the loop.
Instead, Josh Harkinson took the easy, predictable, boring approach:
Few businessmen provoke sharper differences of opinion among Houstonians than Bob Perry. The founder of Perry Homes is the largest private political donor to Republican causes in the nation. Writing checks from his modest home in Nassau Bay, he gives voice to conservative suburbia and inspires nightmares among the left-of-center politicos in the city's urban core.
And he's no less controversial within the camps of his own industry. University of Houston architecture professor Tom Diehl speaks for many in his profession when he describes the 72-year-old former schoolteacher as, simply, "the enemy."
Standing with Diehl in the lounge of the Gerald D. Hines School of Architecture, Celeste Williams giggles. A native of Manhattan who teaches courses on the history of design, she grapples for her own words to describe Perry's town houses. "I can't even call them plain vanilla," she says, "because I love vanilla so much."
Williams climbs into her blue Audi and drives through the Third Ward. The architect has agreed to tour several Perry developments and apply an informal "good neighbor test" -- a measure of how the town houses interact with their surroundings. She comes to a stop at Baldwin Park, where old oaks are hemmed in by a young wall of identical brick facades.
Walking out of the park and into the street, Williams catches simultaneous views of two sides of a new Perry town house. "It looks like two different buildings," she says. The bricks on the front of the house peter out halfway along the side, in favor of siding. Windows are scarce, and their sills don't line up with those fronting the park. It's a classic example of squandering a valuable corner lot: "If you're facing the corner, you have an incredible opportunity to gather both streets to you," she says as a car whizzes by, "and as you can see, that's pretty much lost."
The explanation for the disjointed corner house is simple: Perry has surrounded the park with tract homes. "They're just stamping and then they're just building," Williams says. "It has no site-sensitivity."
Part of what we like to do with this blog is offer some balance to the formulaic approach of this town's tired legacy media (yes, the days when the Press should be considered substantively alternative journalistically have long passed).
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/26/05 03:39 PM |
25 February 2005
Food and drink roundup (02-25-2005 edition)
The output from Houston's food and drink reviewers was hit and miss this week.
Alison Cook visits Miguelito's, a small Venezuelan restaurant that seems to be quite a little find.
Robb Walsh plays political commentator and food critic, and his review of Bistro Moderne suffers as a result. Unfortunately, too many of Walsh's columns lately seem to reflect the general decline at the Press.
Ken Hoffman says Quaker Rice Cakes aren't as bad as they once were.
The best bet might be to use the things as coasters at Bluto's Sports Bar, reviewed by Gracie Ochoa.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/25/05 11:57 PM |
Chron Corrections
Yesterday we commented on the Chronicle's editorial expressing concern about Tasers. The editorial also said there are no guidelines in place on how Tasers are to be used.
Today, a little something appeared in Corrections:
A memo by Houston Police Department Chief Harold Hurtt, circulated Jan. 19, warned officers to use Tasers only on combative suspects who posed a danger to officers and citizens. Nonviolent suspects fleeing or passively resisting arrest are not to be Tasered. HPD Lt. Robert Manzo said academy training materials discourage officers from using a Taser on children, the elderly, the disabled or the mentally ill, except in the most extraordinary circumstances. An editorial on Page B10 of Thursday's City & State section urging HPD to develop detailed, written guidelines didn't mention the existence of the memos.
Also, I noted a couple of days ago that a Chronicle editorial contained a couple of misspelled names. Those have been corrected; and in that stealth way we love so well, no hint of the fixes appeared in Corrections. There is a precedent for a misspelled name being mentioned in Corrections, because Drayton McLane merited it once.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/25/05 06:05 PM |
Is there a new residential toll road on the horizon?
I have posted on the Grand Parkway project that is a hot topic up where I live. Now Charles Kuffner receives word that there is another toll road being proposed, and it too would run through a residential area:
Boy, that Houston-Galveston Area Council 2025 Regional Transportation Plan sure is a gift that keeps on giving, isn't it? I've got a note from Andrea Warren, the Public Relations Committee Chair for the Oak Forest Homeowner's Association, informing me that the latest proposal is a toll road from Tomball to 610 at TC Jester, cutting through the Oak Forest neighborhood along the BNSF rail line.
Please follow the link to read all the details.
I am particularly concerned about the Harris County Toll Road Authority, which has phenomenal power to build at will, regardless of community concerns. Something needs to be done to change the way the HCTRA works.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/25/05 01:38 PM |
Mayor White really, really wants red light cameras
According to this Chronicle story, Mayor White says he will not give up the fight for red light cameras even if the state Senate passes the bill closing a loophole that would allow the city to use the cameras:
White said he believes the city may have the authority to use red-light cameras despite Thursday's House vote.
[snip]
Houston City Attorney Arturo Michel said state law does not preclude municipalities from using cameras to issue criminal citations.
White said that may be an option, but acknowledged it would be difficult.
Under Texas law, running a red light is a Class C misdemeanor that can be regulated only by the state, even though local governments are in charge of enforcement.
Drivers who run red lights would have to be identified to issue criminal citations, but intersection cameras typically photograph license plates and don't clearly show the driver.
I don't know. The Legislature seems firmly against cameras. If the city can come up with another way to do it, my guess is the Legislature would tackle the issue again.
Then the mayor gives us a little pro-camera spin:
"I think the public overwhelmingly wants us to use the technology," White said after a lopsided vote in the House to ban camera enforcement.
I didn't know the city had done some polling on the issue. I would love to see the poll particulars, and not the mayor's interpretation of the results.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/25/05 12:42 PM |
HISD received good news, but the Chronicle buried it (updated)
The Chronicle's headline at the top of today's City & State section is: Half of high schools miss U.S. goals, and the first paragraph of the story is:
Half of HISD's high schools failed to meet federal goals showing academic progress last year, though more schools than the year before met expectations in the U.S. Department of Education's second annual grading.
That sounds fairly alarming, but if you check HISD's press release, you'll come away with a different take: the feds released No Child Left Behind results for 2004 and HISD did very well -- 91% of HISD schools are meeting federal education standards.
To that end, HISD spokesman Terry Abbott forwarded a letter he wrote to the Chronicle editors protesting the paper's coverage of what should be a good news story:
We're so disappointed this morning by the Chronicle's incredibly biased coverage of HISD on the important story today about progress under the Federal No Child Left Behind law.
Yesterday, HISD announced that 91 percent of its schools -- 9 out of 10 -- made adequate yearly progress in 2004 under NCLB, and that HISD as district made AYP as well. Yesterday also, the Dallas Independent School
District announced that 88 percent of its schools made AYP.Here is the headline and lead of the Houston Chronicle this morning:
Feb. 25, 2005, 12:16AM
Half of HISD's high schools fail to meet U.S. goals
By MELANIE MARKLEY
Copyright 2005 Houston ChronicleHalf of HISD's high schools failed to meet federal goals showing academic progress last year, though more schools than the year before met expectations in the U.S. Department of Education's second annual
grading.Not only does the Chronicle story focus on the 9 percent of schools that failed to make AYP and not the 91 percent that made AYP, the story doesn't mention a single name of an HISD school that made AYP. The story doesn't even report that HISD as a district made AYP. The story also failed to compare HISD with other school districts around the country, when just yesterday, the Associated Press reported an average of one third of schools nationwide failed to make adequate yearly progress.
Now, keeping in mind that Dallas ISD did not do as well as HISD, here is the headline and lead in the Dallas Morning News this morning:
Most DISD schools making grade
Almost 9 of 10 have adequate progress under No Child law10:01 PM CST on Thursday, February 24, 2005
By TAWNELL D. HOBBS / The Dallas Morning NewsNearly nine out of ten Dallas schools made adequate progress under the federal No Child Left Behind Act, DISD officials said Thursday.
Why can't the Chronicle simply play the story straight like other media? 9 out of 10 schools making AYP -- and the district making it -- is a significant accomplishment for HISD -- for any urban school district.
Is there anything we can do to appeal for fair coverage from the Chronicle?
Sincerely,
Terry Abbott
I'll be the first to admit that I am often critical of HISD, but I try to base it on facts and reasoning. When there is good news, it should be reported -- fairly. HISD parents, students and employees deserve to know that their school district is meeting the tougher NCLB standards. And I can guarantee you that there are many school districts across this country that would love to have HISD's results.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 02/25/05 11:22 AM |
24 February 2005
Hoffman: Faxas and Boudreaux on the move
Ken Hoffman, who always seems to have the scoop on local media personalities, reports that Eileen Faxas will be leaving KHOU-11:
Channel 11 reporter Eileen Faxas is leaving TV news to concentrate on her singing career.
"You only live once, and you can't go through life without jumping off a few bridges," she said. "This is my destiny."
Quitting your day job is a pretty big gamble. She may be singing a different tune later.
Also, he reports that Bob Boudreaux is hitting Ireland this spring:
"I've acquired the rights to the musical Always ... Patsy Cline, and we're presenting it in Dublin, Ireland, for six weeks starting March 26," said Bourdreaux, who is producing the play. Boudreaux said he drew the Patsy Cline and Dublin connection a few years ago while on his honeymoon in Ireland.
"The Irish are very musical and lyrical people," he said. "They like good storytelling. Country music is very big there, and Patsy Cline is hugely popular. I remembered the play Always ... Patsy Cline from when it debuted at Stages in Houston and figured the Irish would love it."
Boudreaux and business partner Charles Simmons bought the rights to the play by Ted Swindley from the estate of Cline, the country legend who died in a 1963 plane crash.
Boudreaux is producing every nut and bolt of the play, from hiring the director (Scott Fults) to casting to securing work permits to buying commercials on an Irish country music station. He's even putting together a travel package with Absolute Adventure Travel for Houstonians who want to attend.
Although they currently have the rights only for the Irish production, Boudreaux said, "Our ultimate goal, if we're successful in Dublin, is to move the play to London's West End."
Even if they don't make London, the post-production nights at Dublin pubs should be interesting.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/24/05 11:43 PM |
Woodfill comes out swinging.... but at what exactly?
The Chronicle's Ron Nissimov devotes a surprising amount of space today to Harris County Republican Party Chair Jared Woodfill, who is highly critical of cooperation by city council Republicans with Mayor Bill White:
The executive committee of the Harris County Republican Party has voted overwhlemingly to support Proposition 2 and to repeal Safe Clear. The local party's Web site has links to council voting records maintained by the city.Woodfill said the Harris County Republican Party has a good relationship with Republican council members and is not planning immediate action against them.
But he said the party is keeping a closer eye on them and may take more aggressive stances if they continue to vote for what he called liberal positions.
There are conservative alternatives to Mayor White's approach to municipal government, which may fairly be characterized as a technocratic-progressive approach that relies heavily on the mayor's considerable interpersonal skills, but Woodfill and the Harris County Republican Party haven't been been presenting them effectively (if at all). Woodfill has admitted he supported the SAFEclear program initially, and seemed only to get worked up over it about the time Mayor White gave in to public pressure and decided part of the $1 million windfall could pay for tows so that poor people wouldn't have their cars impounded and sold; Doctor-Councilwoman Gibbs deemed this "socialized towing," but after a motorist died while seemingly trying to beat a SAFEclear wrecker, Council finally stopped playing games and passed the changes. As for Proposition 1, there are probably many Republicans who wish that Woodfill had been more proactive when councilman Ellis actually helped write the legislation with the mayor.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/24/05 11:25 PM |
Smoking ban advocacy journalism, Chron style
The Chronicle's Dina Cappiello reported the following in yesterday's Chronicle:
Testing for 31 different chemicals at nine city watering holes, a University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center doctor — who is also an anti-smoking advocate — found that customers are likely getting a breath of carcinogenic benzene along with their beer, and nearly a dozen other chemicals from cigarette smoke.
Most of the levels detected were higher than those found in 10 smoke-free restaurants, 10 eating establishments with smoking sections, and outdoors during the eight-hour test on a Saturday evening in January.
"There is a measurable line that goes from smoke-free restaurants to smoking restaurants to the bar," said Dr. Joel Dunnington, an associate professor at M.D. Anderson. "The bar is really out there."
The results, requested by the Houston Chronicle, have not been reviewed by other scientists. But they come as the city is weighing a nonsmoking ordinance that would ban smoking in indoor dining areas but allow it in bars and restaurants with bars.
[snip]
Dunnington's research, one of the first local studies on the chemicals released from smoking indoors, lends some scientific support to an all-out ban.
The concentration of benzene, a carcinogen, was twice as high in bars as outside and in smoke-free restaurants. Bars had nearly five times more methyl ethyl ketone, which can irritate the eyes, nose and throat, than outside, and twice as much methyl ethyl ketone than smoke-free restaurants. Some of the other compounds, such as limonene and pinene, which could come from scented cleaners, were not higher in bars and are not harmful.
From the information presented in this article, one cannot reach the bolded conclusion of the reporter (who should stick to reporting, not analyzing). That's because the Chronicle reporter did not give any detailed concentration data, or any benchmark data. To wit, a concentration of methyl ethyl ketone that is five times greater than a trivial amount might be significantly harmful -- or it might just be a trivial amount. Likewise, a concentration of methyl ethyl ketone or benzene two times greater than a trivial amount might be significantly harmful -- or it might not. We can't decide without raw numbers and benchmark data, which aren't provided.
The reporter probably doesn't understand environmental science well enough for the point I've made to register. The reporter's editors should have, though. The result is that the reporter presented information that probably seems ominous to the average reader, but isn't robust enough to draw any health-related conclusions. It's not the first time the newspaper has sensationalized data in advocating for a smoking ban, although at least it did so on the editorial page last time.
UPDATE: Relative to the first sentence of the last paragraph, a reader points me to this biographical information on the reporter, which I had not seen. One would think a reporter with those credentials would understand environmental science well enough not to make an elementary mistake. Still, the mistake was made. I was mistaken and perhaps overly generous in speculating it was made out of ignorance. There was no intent to disparage or discredit the reporter's credentials in the previous paragraph.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 02/24/05 10:07 PM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]
