28 March 2005
Chron editorialists reject the Constitutional Option
The Chronicle editorialists try to pull a fast one in today's ranting against what the Powerline crew has dubbed The Constitutional Option:
Frustrated that Democratic senators have used extended debate to reject seven of Bush's judicial nominees, some Republican senators want to implement what has come to be known as the nuclear option: allowing 51 senators (or 50 senators and the vice president) to end debate on judicial nominees. They wish to forget that Republicans held up or rejected confirmation of an even greater number of President Clinton's judicial nominees.
Note that the last sentence implies that Republicans used the filibuster to hold up or reject confirmation of that "even greater number" of Clinton nominees. But they did not use the filibuster.
Rather, the filibuster has become a mechanism by which the Democratic minority in the Senate has frustrated judicial nominations in an unprecedented manner, because they realize those nominees would command a simple majority if allowed to proceed to an up/down vote on the floor. However, the maneuver is only possible because of Senate rules, and is not required by the relevant portion of the Constitution, which states:
[The President] shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur; and he shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, Judges of the supreme Court, and all other Officers of the United States, whose Appointments are not herein otherwise provided for, and which shall be established by Law: but the Congress may by Law vest the Appointment of such inferior Officers, as they think proper, in the President alone, in the Courts of Law, or in the Heads of Departments.
Nope, nothing there that requires a filibuster-proof majority to confirm judges.
One can understand that the Chron editorial idealists aren't too happy with the ideological inclinations of an electorate that has chosen Republican control of the Presidency, House, and Senate, but sometimes democratic republicanism results in outcomes that don't please everyone.
Republicans may well decide not to exercise the Constitutional Option. Still, the best way for the minority party to ensure that Republicans don't exercise the Constitutional Option is not editorial whining or relying on the whims of Susan Collins, but beating the Republicans in elections.
UPDATE: The New York Times weighs in against the Constitutional Option, while admitting they supported nearly full obliteration of the filibuster when it was used to delay the Clinton Administration's agenda. They also admit -- honestly -- that "the filibuster has not traditionally been used to stop judicial confirmations...."
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/28/05 09:46 PM |
A perplexing correction from the Chron
The Chronicle ran a confusing correction today:
An article on page A12 of Sunday's Chronicle inaccurately described President Bush's explanation of Mexican Independence Day. In a television interview, the president said the day is celebrated on "Dieciseis de Septiembre" and added in English that the date is Sept. 15. The holiday is celebrated on Sept. 16.
In the original article, Julie Mason of the Chronicle's Washington bureau wrote:
A bit of a Spanish flourish is typical of Bush, even if it sometimes goes awry.
He once famously informed Chris Matthews on Hardball that Mexican Independence Day is "el Dieciseis de Septiembre," or Sept. 16. In truth, the date is Sept. 15, but he gave it a shot.
Here's a bit of information that is readily available from Wikipedia on Mexican Independence Day:
Dieciséis de septiembre commemorates Father Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla's Grito de Dolores — "cry of Dolores"; "Dolores" also means "sorrow", and it comes from the Virgin of Dolores, the village's patron — on September 16, 1810, in the village of Dolores, near Guanajuato. Hidalgo called for the end of Spanish rule in Mexico. On September 16, 1825, the Republic of Mexico officially declared Dieciséis de septiembre its national Independence Day.
[snip]
Contrary to popular wisdom (particularly as manifested in the United States), Cinco de mayo is not the most important national holiday in Mexico. That distinction is reserved for Dieciséis de septiembre, which is celebrated from the eve of September 15 with a re-creation of the Grito de Dolores by all executive office-holders (from the President of the Republic down to municipal mayors) and lasts through the night. In contrast, Cinco de mayo is observed as a notable date, but it is not considered more or less important than the other holidays excepting Dieciséis de septiembre
So, President Bush was actually right to suggest that the celebration of Mexican Independence Day begins on September 15, even though the anniversary itself is September 16.
And the Chronicle correction taken with Mason's original prose doesn't especially enlighten the reader.
But why let facts get in the way of spreading the "President Bush is dumb but well meaning" meme, right?
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/28/05 09:14 PM |
MetroRail's service disruption inconvenienced Lucas Wall
Poor Lucas Wall was inconvenienced by Metro. It's really not wise to do that to the Chronicle's transportation guy, because then he doesn't write a happy column:
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/28/05 10:40 AM |
27 March 2005
When will the Chron version be posted?
The LA Times runs a piece today on House Majority Leader Tom DeLay (R), and his family's decision in 1988 to refrain from extraordinary measures to keep his terminal father artificially alive.
The point of the story is so obvious that it will be shocking if the Chronicle doesn't run some version of it (likely a chopped version).
Orrin Judd dismisses some of the nastier insinuations of the story with his usual precision:
Even by its own abysmal standards the press has done a terrible job covering the issues surrounding the Schiavo case--there's a great difference between the question of whether it's morally necessary to initiate heroic measures to prolong life and whether it's morally permissible to withdraw simple sustenance from someone who isn't otherwise terminal.
One local editorialist is likely to express more concern for her leftovers.
So, any thoughts from readers on which day of the week the Chronicle posts a chopped version of this story?
UPDATE: The Chron posted the AP version this afternoon (the timestamp on their posting is 1:23 pm as of this update). That renders our little contest among commenters moot, but just to keep reader interest -- how long before the Chron editorial board follows up on the AP story by blasting their favorite bad guy?
UPDATE (03-29-2005): The Chron posted a slightly edited version of the original LA Times story, one day later.
Also, Just One Minute weighs in with It Doesn't Always Matter What The Facts Are.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/27/05 12:13 PM |
Chief Hurtt: New Chron "good guy"
Today, the Chronicle runs a puff piece by Joe Stinebaker on police chief Harold Hurtt, a local "exorcist with a badge" (but until recently, no uniform).
The article celebrates council's decision to spend $5 million on tasers on the chief's recommendation (the graphical blurb says $4 million has been spent) and to install revenue-generating red-light cameras.
While the crime lab is mentioned in the article, no mention is made of the harsh criticism the chief has received for moving so slowly on the crime lab. Nor is there any mention of the criticism the chief has received for implementing a "productivity policy" that looks suspiciously like a ticket quota system. And the article does not mention one of the biggest problems facing HPD -- a worsening manpower shortage -- or give any indication of how the chief bureaucrat plans to deal with it.
As a puff piece, it fails in one major regard. We expected a big celebration of the chief finally being able to don the HPD uniform, roughly a year after taking the job! But no such celebration is offered by Stinebaker. We'll celebrate it again for him -- and call attention to his new grooming standards as well! These are exciting times at HPD.
Interestingly, the article refers to tasers as tools by which local law enforcement can overcome the chief's perception that HPD has an "excessive force" problem. That's an interesting concern in light of KTRK-13's current story of an off-duty officer (not identified as HPD, but not identified otherwise) using a taser to subdue two women in a dispute at a local bar. One supposes that's preferable to shooting the lady dead, but it seems that Hurtt's "excessive force" concerns might still need a little work.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/27/05 11:40 AM |
Chron: Resurrection should comfort those upset by forced starvation
Just when I thought the Chronicle editorial board could no longer shock me with their offensiveness, here comes today's Easter editorial:
Schiavo's case is a tragedy that has sparked roiling debate and dueling accusations of indifference to life, severely impaired, and political cynicism. Some believe the contention of Schiavo's husband, Michael, that his wife did not wish to be kept alive by artificial means and that her wishes should be honored. Others argue whether withholding water and nutrition is tantamount to killing Schiavo or simply removing the impediment to the dying process that already is under way.
The horror of Schiavo's situation has prompted many people to discuss with family their wishes about end-of-life care and to make living wills.
The participants and observers in this conflict might find some solace, if not resolution, in the story of Jesus Christ's resurrection, which believers say took place more than 2,000 years ago. Easter, celebrated today at churches throughout the world, provides a comforting alternative perspective on when life ends.
It is stunning that on the most important Christian holy day, the editorial board would lecture us to find comfort in Schiavo's impending (forced starvation) death by reflecting on the Resurrection. The editors, of all people! These are the same people who told us last Christmas that Christianity is ruining peace and good will on Earth!
Contrast this idea that Michael Schiavo was "simply removing the impediment to the dying process that already is under way," with the editorial board's horror earlier this week over terrorists being tortured:
Earlier this month, the Pentagon reported that abuse by American troops had caused the deaths of at least four prisoners in U.S. custody in Iraq and Afghanistan. More recently, Army and Navy officials acknowledged that homicide is suspected or had been confirmed in at least 26 prisoner deaths.
Goss did say during the congressional hearing that techniques employed "at this time" to squeeze information out of suspected terrorists are legally permissible. But that is cold comfort in light of reports that American troops and intelligence officers routinely, in the name of homeland security, cross the line that separates humane from inhumane treatment.
I have to wonder if starvation would now be a permissible technique for squeezing information out of suspected terrorists? If it's humane for Terri Schiavo, certainly it should be humane for terrorists, right?
The barbaric treatment of prisoners, whether in Iraq's notorious AbuGhraib prison or at the detention center for terror suspects at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, undermines the United States' stature in the world.
[snip]
The United States must do more than just politely demur on the subject of torture. If the president abhors torture, he should end the policy of kidnapping suspects and placing them in the custody of barbarous, tyrannical regimes. If the Republican leadership in Congress feels moral outrage at the abuses that have taken place at U.S. military outposts, Congress should investigate and then outlaw the practice.
Unbelievable.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/27/05 07:58 AM |
26 March 2005
Ask President Bush and God to fix MetroRail's crash problem
Here's quite a column from the Springfield (MO) News-Leader:
And then there's Houston. A year and a half ago, Houston put in the first segment of a projected light rail system, 7.5 miles of it. In the first eight months, they had 40 collisions between trains and cars. Forty.
Sacramento, on a similarly situated line, suffered only four car-train collisions during a like period.
But are people in Houston taking a hard look at their driving habits? No. They're blaming the trains.
"Are you from America?" yelled a Houston driver at a reporter. "I'm from America, 49 years. Here, you're taught as a kid that flashing lights, arms come down --trains coming."
The truth is, Houstonians are terrible drivers. They have an accident rate nearly twice the national average.
"It's the general perception," said the chief executive of Houston's Metro. "People in the street, elected officials. They say, 'What's wrong with Metro? Why is it blaming these motorists?' As if it's a God-given right in Houston to run red lights."
We should ask President Bush. He's been to Houston and he has chats with God often.
The author, Donald Kaul, is the former Washington columnist for the Des Moines Register, according to the byline.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/26/05 10:18 AM |
Another poll story to dismiss -- if we can even figure it out
The Chronicle has a poorly edited Knight Ridder Tribune News service story about President Bush's latest poll numbers. It's poorly edited because there are two polls mentioned -- Gallup and CBS News -- but no clue as to which results belong to what poll. It's a very strange piece.
Perhaps we should attribute it to Friday night on a holiday weekend. Who knows, but it appears to be a chopped-up piece, and someone at the Chronicle made the decision to run it.
We can go to USA Today and see first hand that the Gallup poll has suspect numbers:
The poll also found an increased number of Democrats. In this survey, 37% said they were Democrats and 32% said they were Republicans. Last week, 32% said they were Democrats and 35% said they were Republicans.
So, last week's poll surveyed 32% Democrats to 35% Republicans and this week the numbers are 37% Democrats to 32% Republicans. You don't think that could have contributed to the president's "drop" in numbers? What does this say about the previous week's numbers? This is why polling has shown time and again to be suspect.
I love this paragraph from the USA Today story:
The new poll found the largest drop for Bush came among men, self-described conservatives and churchgoers.
Well, duh! If one week Gallup is polling more Republicans than the next week and the number of Democrats polled shoots up, it stands to reason the new poll would show a drop in conservative supporters for President Bush.
Here is a Seattle Times story that appears to be a longer version of the Knight Ridder Tribune News service story the Chronicle used, although this story never mentions the CBS News poll. Did someone at the Chronicle just throw that reference in?
RELATED: CBS News poll
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/26/05 09:15 AM |
Ratcliffe mischaracterizes House republicans on term limits
The Chronicle's R.G. Ratcliffe includes this line in the latest speculation about whether Kay Bailey Hutchison will run for governor of Texas:
Term limits were a popular Republican campaign issue in 1994, serving as a centerpiece of Newt Gingrich's Contract with America. Term limits also were one of the first agenda items dropped by Republicans once they gained control of the U.S. House.
Does anybody check facts at the Chronicle?
Here is the relevant excerpt from the Contract with America:
Thereafter, within the first 100 days of the 104th Congress, we shall bring to the House Floor the following bills, each to be given full and open debate, each to be given a clear and fair vote and each to be immediately available this day for public inspection and scrutiny.
[snip]
10. THE CITIZEN LEGISLATURE ACT: A first-ever vote on term limits to replace career politicians with citizen legislators....
Here is the roll call vote on House Joint Resolution 73, a proposed constitutional amendment to limits terms of Senators and Representatives. The joint resolution actually received a plurality in favor (227 to 204), but failed because a proposed constitutional amendment requires a 2/3 vote in favor to pass.
The resolution did NOT fail because, as Ratcliffe erroneously asserts, Republicans dropped it as an agenda item. Rather, it failed because Republicans were not able to bring enough Democrats on board to secure a 2/3 majority. However, as with other key elements of the Contract with America, Republicans did bring the matter to a roll call vote on the floor of the House, as promised.
Whatever Ratcliffe's intent, the effect of this erroneous characterization in a "news" article is to paint Republicans as hypocrites -- a view certainly consonant with recent Chronicle editorializing, but not consistent with facts.
UPDATE: I should add that this is not information that is hard to find. Google is very useful, but most everything a person would need is in the Wikipedia entry on the Contract with America.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/26/05 09:08 AM |
25 March 2005
Food and drink roundup (03-25-2005 edition)
Houston's food and drink reviewers get us ready for this Easter weekend.
Robb Walsh turns in a classic Walsh review, visiting Segari's on Shepherd (really!) this week.
Alison Cook visits Sugar Land's Cupcake Cafe, which she thinks would be right at home in Montrose.
Dai Huynh reviews Polonia, "Houston's hub of Polish cuisine."
Finally, Joey Guerra checks out Club Ice & Mantra Lounge.
Happy eating and drinking!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/25/05 11:27 PM |
Houston's lobbying team isn't wowing Austin
Kristen Mack has a story today about the efforts of Houston's lobbying team:
With the session half over and the bill-filing deadline long passed, White and his new in-house lobby team are struggling to get the city's priorities passed, legislators say.
"Under this new administration, so far the city has limped a little bit at the beginning of the session, in understanding how Austin works and traversing that system," said Rep. Garnet Coleman, D-Houston.
Rep. Gary Elkins, R-Houston, said he was optimistic early on that the city would keep the delegation informed, but that has not materialized.
"I don't know what their priorities are," Elkins said. "Their lobbying team has not informed us of what the issues are."
It's interesting to contrast this with a column Mack wrote back in January, where she reported that the city had retained the services of a 13-member lobbying team for $520,000 +:
Mayor Bill White's administration says it saved money, since lobbying teams in the past have had as many as 18 members and cost $1 million. The 2003 contract was for $840,000.
Whether it's a bargain, though, will depend upon the team's effectiveness in pushing the mayor's agenda, and that could be trying.
Time will soon tell us how that bargain worked out:
Rep. Sylvester Turner, D-Houston, said most city issues have not resonated beyond the committee level yet. "April and May will be bigger months for the city," he said.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/25/05 03:04 PM |
Houston gets nearly $3 million to ease traffic congestion
Mayor Bill White and House Majority Leader Tom DeLay have secured almost $3 million for "traffic management projects" in Houston:
Nearly $3 million is headed this way for traffic management projects on US 59 and the Katy Freeway. Mayor Bill White and Congressman Tom Delay worked to secure these funds to help ease congestion and ensure increased safety on Houston's busiest highways.
One part of the Freeway Incident Management Program will include cameras on roving helicopters that will quickly respond to traffic scenes. That will help ensure the proper emergency vehicles respond to scenes in as quickly as possible.
[snip]
The US Department of Transportation has announced it will release $1.9 million of the nearly $3 million that will fund the first phase of the project, which targets the I-10 West Katy Freeway from downtown to the Grand Parkway and US 59 from downtown out to Highway 6. The program will also focus on major thoroughfares and access points along these corridors. These targeted areas experience approximately 5,500 freeway incidents annually.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/25/05 01:38 PM |
Guess what? Metro's proposed rail lines have been approved
Remember the Chronicle's outrage that Rep. Culberson and Rep. DeLay messed up Metro's funding:
The voters have spoken. Houston needs mobility improvements that include an expanded rail transit component as well as one of the nation's better bus systems. The next time Metro and the majority of voters in its service area say "Jump," their representatives in Congress should ask, "How high?"
A funny little thing popped up in Houston's Daily Information Source today:
A U.S. agency notified Congress on Thursday that it will approve the next two segments of Houston's MetroRail system and recommend their eligibility for federal funding.
Just as Rep. Culberson tried to explain to the Chronicle, Metro's funding would be approved as soon as its faulty application was fixed, resubmitted and reviewed. He inserted language in the appropriation bill specifically assuring that would happen.
Here's Lucas Wall's context paragraph, in today's story:
Metro submitted its two projects for federal review in August, hoping to obtain a recommendation by February, when the FTA makes its annual report to Congress. The MetroRail lines were not rated in that report last month, however, and the federal agency said at the time it was still reviewing the application.
He writes very nonchalantly and dispassionately this time, as opposed to his fit of pique a few weeks back:
Language that would have sped up Metro 's light rail expansion got stripped out of a massive appropriations bill in the last Congress, prompting a debate about whether two Houston congressmen are still blocking the city's rail plan.
[snip]
"It's an affront to the citizens of Houston," said Ed Wulfe, chairman of the Main Street Coalition, who has promoted development along the 7 1/2-mile light rail line that opened last year. "Somebody is putting their personal agenda ahead of what the people want."
What's an affront to the citizens of Houston is that we have a newspaper and a transit agency that are so woefully inept and out-of-touch. Metro is supposed to serve the citizens of Houston, but appears much more interested in sacrificing all at the altar of light rail. And the Chronicle -- please. It has done more to cover up Metro's shortcomings than any other media outlet in town. It's disgraceful.
There is some funding information in this story that is interesting. Metro needs $60 million for preliminary engineering costs, and it wants the feds to cover the whole amount. Here we go again!
Congress typically offers only minimal funding assistance for preliminary engineering. Metro estimates that work will cost $60 million and is asking Congress this year to fund all of that.
Houston will be competing with at least 25 other cities that also have projects in preliminary engineering this year. The FTA has recommended Congress appropriate $122 million for all of these projects in the next fiscal year. If Metro only gets an average allocation, it can expect $5 million from Uncle Sam next year.
Wilson said Metro will make its case for the $60 million request, but could sell some bonds to pay for preliminary engineering if needed.
And here are the quotes of the day:
"This puts us on the map," said Metro President & CEO Frank Wilson. "This is an extremely important leap forward for us but it's not the end of the process by any means."
[snip]
Metro Chairman David Wolff said he's pleased the proposed rail segments have passed a rigorous review, showing they meet federal standards.
"It's a great positive step in the direction we want to go," he said. "It's an affirmation of our program and it's good to get that from an impartial federal source."
That's some serious chutzpah. So, let's review: Metro screwed up its original application; Rep. Culberson came to Metro's aid, in at least two very big ways; Metro responded by stabbing Rep. Culberson in the back, with the Chronicle's help; and now that the work Rep. Culberson did to help Metro has paid off, Metro takes credit for getting federal approval.
I think that pretty much sums it up.
RELATED: Laurence Simon is waiting for the Chronicle to apologize to Rep. Culberson. Hahahahaha! That's a good one. I would only add that Metro officials should also apologize to Rep. Culberson, but that's not going to happen either.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/25/05 11:30 AM |
Old, outdated equipment to blame for 911 call center failures
The audit of Houston's troubled 911 call center has been completed and recommendations have been made. It appears the technical problems stem from old equipment:
The $53 million Houston Emergency Center, which has experienced 17 computer shutdowns since it started taking calls in September 2003, is more than 99.7 percent reliable, according to independent auditors.
MITRE Corp., hired by the city for $192,000, blamed most of the shutdowns on outdated equipment outside the HEC facility, located at 5320 N. Shepherd. Most of the problems have been fixed and are not are expected to occur again, while several are still being addressed.
[snip]
Dennis Storemski, director of the Mayor's Office of Public Safety and Homeland Security, said that Northrop Grumman, the Los Angeles-based contractor that provided the dispatching software wasn't at fault.
[snip]
The auditors made several recommendations that the city has already implemented, or plans to implement soon. They include:
•Establishing staff positions to manage some technical aspects of the dispatching system;
•Increasing maintenance and testing;
•Replacing old equipment and software;
•And developing better ways to ensure data is not lost.
On a KTRH news break yesterday, I heard a recommendation that the city should also consolidate and upgrade the emergency radio system used by Houston police and fire personnel. KHOU-11 covered the story of Houston's inadequate emergency radio system in February, and at that time Mayor White said this:
"It's not a problem that's going to be solved in one day. It will be over a period of years," said Mayor Bill White.
Maybe now Houston's emergency system infrastructure will become a priority for city officials.
RELATED: Fixing HEC (blogHOUSTON), Can the Houston Emergency Center be fixed? (blogHOUSTON), Public safety priorities (blogHOUSTON)
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/25/05 08:45 AM |
Smoking ban fever is spreading
Kemah is considering a smoking ban similar to the one Houston recently passed:
Mayor William King will present the ordinance to ban smoking in certain public places to the City Council Thursday.
The proposed ban is very similar to the ordinance recently adopted by the city of Houston.
"I personally would like to see a stronger restriction, but I think the other cities in the area follow Houston's lead on this issue. It is important that the restaurant owners do not have different rules in different jurisdictions and that no one can claim a competitive advantage from differing restrictions," King said in a news release.
That strikes me as a strange bit of reasoning.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/25/05 08:15 AM |
Buying groceries online in Houston
While some notable dotcoms weren't able to make a go of online grocery shopping, there are still some internet options available to Houston grocery shoppers.
KTRK-13's Michael McGuff posts an interesting report on online grocery shopping here in town.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/25/05 12:01 AM |
24 March 2005
Houston utilities in the news
KHOU-11 ran a couple of interesting stories involving Houston utilities this week.
Wendell Edwards reported yesterday that Reliant Energy would be turning off approximately 100 streetlights in the Mission Bend area over a billing dispute. That area has suffered through numerous home invasions and driveway robberies over the last year.
Also, Jeff McShan reported on a citizen's complaint about water billing practices by the city of Houston:
Public Works spokesperson Wes Johnson confirmed the rollover billing process. Pat Trahan, with the mayor's office, says the Public Works Department will be looking into the billing process, and there's a chance there will be some changes.
Changes or not, the billing process should be better explained.
If you buy water from the city of Houston, it might be worth checking your water meter against your bills from the city.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/24/05 11:55 PM |
What's a few billion here and there?
Today, the Chronicle posted the following lengthy correction to an editorial that appeared in yesterday's newspaper:
An editorial on Page B10 of Wednesday's City & State section said the state budget approved by the Texas Senate Finance Committee would allocate only $1.8 billion in additional dollars to public education. Lt. Gov. David Dewhurst said the Senate also intends to approve an additional $300 million to subsidize teachers health insurance and $400 million for textbooks. Also, $3.2 billion in fees and current taxes would be shifted from other agencies to education, and local taxpayers could elect to contribute as much as $1.1 billion to enrich local districts.
The editorial's main contention was that the plan allocated "too little money" to education and healthcare needs.
Perhaps the editorialists should have spent a little more time researching their numbers, and a little less time researching movies starring Walter Matthau.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/24/05 11:39 PM |
Better late than never?
On March 21, the Chronicle's Mike Glenn reported that HPD is considering the use of reserve officers.
That same day, we commented that the move was, at best, an inadequate solution to HPD's manpower shortage.
Today, the Chronicle editorial board finally weighed in on this local issue, criticizing the potential use of reserve officers because of concerns over training. The editorial offers no suggestions for Mayor White and Council regarding their priorities (or lack thereof) for funding new HPD hiring.
One supposes incomplete and a little slow on local issues is better than never on the Chronicle editorial page. Perhaps the idealists were distracted by the death of Bobby Short.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 03/24/05 11:23 PM |
Trying to figure out what White and Hurtt are really upset about
Mayor White and Chief Hurtt are upset that a federal drug enforcement program might see some cuts in funding:
Houston Mayor Bill White and Police Chief Harold Hurtt have vowed to fight President Bush's proposal to slash 60 percent of funding for a federal drug-enforcement program that has been more successful in Houston than in many other parts of the country.
The Houston Police Department receives about $3 million a year from the High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area program, and the 16-county Houston region from Beaumont to Corpus Christi receives an additional $7 million a year.
HPD has been receiving $3 million from the HIDTA program. That's a big chunk of change!
I actually had to read the story a couple of times to grasp what is going on here, but the other side of the story (and the reporter, Ron Nissimov, did include both sides of the story) is that Houston will most likely NOT lose HIDTA funding, and there is a possibility that Houston will see an INCREASE in funding, with the proposed changes:
Federal officials have said the Houston area might receive more than $3 million in HIDTA funds because Bush wants to refocus the program on high-trafficking areas.
[snip]
Steve Katsurinis, a native Houstonian who is Walters' chief of staff, said Houston could end up getting more than $3 million even if the cuts are approved because of the proposed change in focus. He said unlike many other HIDTA programs, the Houston program has shown positive results.
That's right -- Houston could get MORE money. So what are Hurtt and White complaining about?
Oversight of the program would be taken away from local groups and given to the U.S. Department of Justice.
There you go: losing local control of HIDTA money is probably what this is all about.
Hurtt claimed that HPD would lose 14 "positions" from the proposed cuts, the sheriff's department would lose 15 positions, and Sam Houston State University would lose 12.
Stan Furce, director of the Houston HIDTA, said the 41 employees Hurtt cited are civilian analysts.
Furce, who is opposed to Bush's proposal, said funds allocated to the Houston HIDTA are typically used to pay overtime for task forces composed of federal and local law enforcement agents, and their vehicles.
Would the Department of Justice say that HIDTA money has to be used differently from how Houston is currently using it? That could be, and it would explain why Hurtt is so vehement in denouncing cuts that probably won't even happen, as far as Houston is concerned.
All we have to do is look at what has happened with Homeland Security funding to see why it can be a good idea to put some controls on federal money. We have seen plenty of stories of Homeland Security money being used by local governments in unique, and some might even say questionable, ways. The federal government has a right to say how federal funding is spent.
There is one more quote in the story that I found interesting:
"Most people are not as concerned about planes running into our buildings as somebody breaking into our houses," said White, citing Bush's emphasis on homeland security and claiming that many home burglaries are drug-related.
Instead of wasting energy fighting a proposal that may give Houston MORE federal money, maybe White could work on some full-time, permanent Houston police officers.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 03/24/05 04:20 PM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]