17 June 2005
Elected officials question mayor's new Metro plan
Rad Sallee (with Kristen Mack) has another interesting story on Mayor White's new $2 billion expansion plan, with some elected officials expressing concern:
Two Metro supporters in Congress said Thursday that the agency's decision to put a guided bus system in three corridors where voters had approved light rail could damage public trust in the agency.
"This is not helping Metro's credibility problem," said U.S. Rep. Gene Green, whose district includes the Metropolitan Transit Authority's North, Southeast and Harrisburg corridors.
[snip]
A second Democratic congressman from Houston, Al Green, said he will reserve comment on the plan until he understands it more fully, but he added, "People are concerned that there may be some plan that is going to develop that would not be consistent with what they perceived it to be when they were casting their votes."
[snip]
State Rep. Garnet Coleman, D-Houston, said it appears that "the west side of town won out over the right side of town.
"It's disappointing, but it's clear this is not the end of the discussion," he said.
Coleman is scheduled to talk to White, Wilson and Councilwoman Ada Edwards this afternoon, but said he wished that discussion had taken place before the plan was made public.
"I'm disappointed that people don't understand that you have to work a deal with everybody, regardless of the sticks people carry," Coleman said. "I hope that we can get some clarity on what the plan is."
Several area legislators, including U.S. Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, state Sen. Rodney Ellis, both Houston Democrats, and Commissioner El Franco Lee are all on the same page, according to Coleman.
Woopsie! As we suspected, Mayor White didn't share his plan with those communities before he made his announcement. But with the exception of SAFEclear, the mayor generally gets his way and probably didn't anticipate any problems with the new plan.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/17/05 11:50 AM |
Rep. Culberson on Edd Hendee's show
Rep. John Culberson (R) was just on with Edd Hendee (KSEV-700) and while most of the conversation dealt with this, Hendee did bring up Mayor White's new Metro plan at the end of the interview.
Rep. Culberson mentioned that he was concerned about Metro's decision to take on debt and issue short-term notes, instead of its previous pay-as-you-go policy. He said he was prepared to question Metro's financial position. He also reiterated that he did not help design or plan Mayor White's new $2 billion expansion plan, and that he doesn't endorse the plan. He said he would continue to seek funding for many transit plans in the Houston area, including Metro's plan, but that he's not exclusively working on Metro's new plan.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/17/05 09:17 AM |
More Bob Stein -- this time on SAFEclear
Bloomberg.com is running a fawning SAFEclear story:
Tow trucks are doing what politicians can only hope to achieve with billions of dollars in transportation spending: easing traffic congestion in Houston, the fourth-largest U.S. city.
A program to clear disabled vehicles from freeways during peak travel times eliminated 1.8 million hours of delays since starting in January, according to a report last week by the Texas Transportation Institute and Rice University. Accidents dropped by almost 10 percent. Commuters saved $70 million in lost time and collision-related costs, the report said.
``People were 2-to-1 against the program,'' said Bob Stein, a Rice professor who has studied Houston traffic for more than 20 years. ``They are now 2-to-1 for it. They have seen results.''
Bob Stein is EVERYWHERE! Now, Stein doesn't just study Houston traffic (and of course, his wife works for Mayor White); he helped design SAFEClear. And not only did Stein help design the original SAFEclear, but in January he let slip the true purpose behind the plan:
Stein said the biggest factor in determining how much towing companies bid for their segments was not the expected number of tows or miles of freeway, but the average age of vehicles there.
Vehicles on the city's largely industrial east side average about 4 years older than those in the affluent western suburbs, he said.
Stein's conclusion: "Tows were not the driving force in the bidding."
On the west side, he said, "it was the opportunity to make referrals for repairs." On the east side, the tow operator's profits are likely to come from storage lots and reselling impounded vehicles whose owners cannot afford to pay the fees, he said.
None of that is in the Bloomberg story. But this is:
Stein, the Rice professor, said results have won over many of the people who opposed Safe Clear. Traffic congestion is a perennial sore point for people in Houston, which ranks fifth in the U.S. for time wasted in traffic.
No source is given for Stein's repeated pronouncements that "people" have been won over by SAFEclear.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/17/05 08:47 AM |
How to identify Bob Stein
Chronicle politics columnist Kristen Mack reports today on the companies vying for the city's red-light-camera contract, and the city-hall ties of some of their lobbyists.
The column concludes with a proper identification of Rice University political science professor Bob Stein:

"It's going to be ugly. There's a lot of money involved," said Rice University political scientist Bob Stein, whose wife works as the mayor's agenda director."The mayor will be watching carefully to ensure that the contracts are handled properly and that there are no shenanigans."
On that bolded part -- how does Professor Stein, sometime advisor to Mayor White himself, know? Is it because he's an omniscient objective political analyst, or because of his personal ties to the White Administration?
There's no way for readers to know, which is why it is important for journalists to note his association with the White Administration in their reporting. Otherwise, readers simply think he's an outsider doing objective political analysis, which is misleading.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 06/17/05 07:08 AM |
16 June 2005
Beware of a Dwight Silverman media appearance near you
Chronicle tech guru and "Houston Driver" Dwight Silverman is everywhere!
He's blogging. He's writing columns. He's broadcasting. He's random podcasting. He's burning up the Chron servers with new blogs.
And now, he's helping out KHOU-11 with road engineering:

It might be a good idea to hire out-of-towners to put up Houston's signs. That way you wouldn't have somebody who already knows how to get where he's going.Dwight Silverman has another idea. "Let the highway engineers ride around with people who new to the city and see what they get confused about. Essentially beta test the roads," he suggested.
This would make everyone's list: Beltway 8, which, yes, is also Sam Houston Tollway, has special lanes for those with exact change. But the exact amount seems to be a secret. Is it $1? More? Less?
You television guys leave Mr. Silverman alone! The man is busy enough.
NOTE: The posted screen cap isn't very clear, but below the name, Silverman is identified as "Houston Driver."
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 06/16/05 10:29 PM |
How not to report on an audit
Yesterday, we gave the Chronicle's evolving coverage of the SAFEclear audit a bit of a break, suspecting that the story that appeared in the morning editions of the print version would be significantly different.
Instead, it was mostly the same.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 06/16/05 09:56 PM |
A potpourri of blather from the Chronicle DC bureau
Sedosi Alhambra points out something interesting about a Bennett Roth/Samantha Levine story from the Chronicle's underwhelming Washington bureau.
The story comments on House financial disclosures, covering Majority Leader Tom DeLay's disclosures in some detail, while noting the disclosures of several other Texas Republicans and one Democrat (Gene Green).
Conspicuously absent from the list was Sheila Jackson Lee (D), as Alhambra notes.
Other oddities from the story are: 1) The subtle implication that Ron Paul (R) somehow hopes to profit from legislation to return to the gold standard because he has invested in gold and silver; Paul's criticism of fiat currency is well known, so it's hardly surprising he would invest in hard currency, and 2) the two reporters and probably several editors apparently feel that it is news that Michael McCaul (R) has several thousand dollars of debt on a department store credit card.
If the Chronicle's Washington bureau can't produce more balanced, notable journalism than this, Hearst really ought to shutter the place, go with wire coverage, and reallocate the assets to the city desk.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 06/16/05 09:24 PM |
HISD students help restore Evergreen Cemetery
Some HISD students have been busy cleaning up a historic Fifth Ward cemetery:
Almost three dozen students from HISD’s Wheatley High School (4900 Market Street) have been honoring their neighborhood’s rich heritage over the past few months by rolling up their sleeves and applying some elbow grease.
The students—many of whom graduated this May—joined forces with representatives from the Houston Geological Society, the Fifth Ward Enrichment Center, Keep Houston Beautiful, and Project Respect to give the old Evergreen Negro Cemetery in Houston’s historic Fifth Ward (located just east of downtown) a facelift.
Over the course of several Saturday-morning sessions, the students have partially erected a wooden fence to prevent drive-by trash dumping, trimmed and manicured overgrown trees and shrubs, and mowed the grass that periodically covers and obscures many of the gravestones—one dating back to the early 1800’s.
“This area has a long history,” explained Fifth Ward Enrichment Project Manager Charles Williams, “and we wanted students to be a part of the clean-up effort and take pride in that. Many of the headstones have chain links carved into them to show which people were slaves when they died, and some students even have relatives buried here.”
[snip]
The Evergreen Negro Cemetery, which is the final resting place of slaves, freedmen, buffalo soldiers, and African-American veterans from virtually every American war, is located on the site of an old cotton plantation. It is bordered by Calles Street to the west, Sakowitz Street to the east, Market Street to the south, and the businesses on the south side of Interstate 10-East to the north. The cemetery is also bisected by Lockwood Street, which runs north-south and divides the graveyard into eastern and western sections near its center. Preliminary research indicates the original 20-acre site may have once extended north of I-10.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/16/05 08:45 PM |
Another disappearing Metro press release? (updated)
For some unknown reason, Metro's press release announcing Mayor White's new expansion plan is no longer listed in the News Releases section. (Update: the press release is listed again in the News Releases section. Hmmmmm.)
You can still access the release by clicking on the above link, but in case that changes, I'll reprint the whole thing:
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/16/05 06:26 PM |
Transcript of mayor's speech won't be posted
On Monday night Mayor White gave a speech before the Progressive Forum. I emailed Frank Michel and Pat Trahan in the mayor's office asking when a transcript of the mayor's speech would be posted. Today Frank Michel responded, saying that since the speech was "mostly impromptu," there is no "written copy of it."
Oh. Well, how impromptu could it have been if the Chronicle highlighted it at least three days before the speech?
I also emailed the Chronicle's news desk asking if there would be a follow-up story on the mayor's speech. I was told that something was planned for next Tuesday.
I would really like to see a transcript of that speech, since Monday was when the big Metro deal was announced, and according to one person who was at the Hobby Center, Mayor White did talk about Metro's new plan in his speech.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/16/05 04:08 PM |
Does Mayor White trust the voters?
We nearly passed out this morning when we saw Rad Sallee's story in today's Chronicle:
Two days after Metro's revised transit plan was announced, criticism was bubbling up in the minority communities whose votes for light rail tipped the scales in a close election.
"It's clearly a slap in the face," the Rev. William Lawson said of the Metropolitan Transit Authority's decision to begin with a guided busway system in his southeast Houston neighborhood and three others. Metro says these will be upgraded to light rail when ridership increases.
[snip]
"The largest percentage of Metro riders are people from the southeast quadrant," Lawson said, "and they needed the votes of those people to get the issue passed."
State Sen. Mario Gallegos, D-Houston, and Councilman Adrian Garcia, whose district includes the largely Hispanic Near Northside, said the Uptown-Galleria connection was a surprise.
"I've never seen any language in what I sold to my constituents that had the Galleria in it," Gallegos said.
"When you go to the fine print, they're telling me it's perfectly legal and when we wait a few years we'll get light rail, but that's saying 'trust me.' "
Minister Robert Muhammad, head of Nation of Islam's southwest region, who endorsed the 2003 Metro plan, said the change of plans "may be the straw that broke the camel's back politically. We can't trust anything that they say."
The referendum passed with 52 percent of the vote.
About 74 percent of low-income blacks and 80 percent of middle-income blacks voted for the Metro light rail plan.
So did 57 percent of Hispanics, compared with 45 percent of middle-income whites and 42 percent of upper-income whites.
We have wondered how the minority community feels about Metro's endless cutting of bus routes so it can concentrate on 7.5 miles of downtown light rail. Mayor White no doubt thinks he has salvaged Metro's expansion plans, but my guess is he never consulted anyone from the communities that REALLY rely on Metro for transportation. Heck, since we haven't heard a peep out of Judge Eckels, we wonder if Mayor White consulted with anyone from Harris County about the new plan.
Since the new plan IS dramatically different from the 2003 voter-approved plan, Mayor White should tell Metro to put it to a vote. $1 billion of local tax money is a big commitment and we know from past experience that Metro will require more and more funding. Light rail has an insatiable appetite, just like the Metro Bigs pushing for it. Plus, Houston-area residents are getting smarter -- we don't want to keep hearing the "trust us" refrain. We are tired of trusting and getting squat in return.
If Mayor White and Metro think it is such a good plan, they should have enough confidence to put it to a vote, just like the mayor did with SAFEclear and the smoking ban. Oh that's right...we didn't get to vote on those -- Mayor White made an executive decision, and convinced City Council to agree with him.
Maybe Mayor White doesn't trust the voters.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/16/05 10:17 AM |
Metro's holding board meetings today
I check Metro's "Meetings and Notices" page frequently (just like the Sports Authority) and it has been empty. Well, today a whole slew of board meetings are listed, with some interesting topics. For example, during the 1 p.m. regular board meeting, look at this eye-opener scheduled to be discussed:
6. Rescind current METRO Policy of "pay as you go" and adopt new Board "Debt Policy"
Wow! That one items tells us so much about Metro's current (and future) condition. But there's more:
8. Authority to negotiate a line of credit with JP Morgan Chase for $59 Million with a one-year duration (to provide liquidity to meet current obligation pending receipt of FY2005 Section 5307 Formula grant already appropriated by Congress).
[snip]
10. Authority to establish a Commercial Paper Program
Now, I'm just a mom trying to raise her kids, but I can Google, and when I Google "commerical paper program" I see references to short-term notes, used to raise funds.
And do you think that line of credit with JP Morgan Chase is to cover for money Metro expects to receive in the future? It sounds like it.
Also, a public hearing on a state performance audit of Metro will be held on June 30, 2005 at 12 noon. That sounds intriguing.
UPDATE: A friend of blogHOUSTON emails the Wikipedia entry for "commercial paper":
Commercial paper is a short-term unsecured debt trading as a security issued by large banks and corporations. It is generally used not to finance major projects but rather is used for purchases of inventory or to manage short term cash flow. It is commonly bought by Money market funds (the issuing amounts are often too high for individual investors), and is generally regarded as a very safe investment. As a relatively low risk option returns are not large.
Because commercial paper maturities don't exceed nine months and proceeds typically are used only for current transactions, the notes are exempt from registration as securities with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission.
UPDATE 2: I am wondering if this is the Section 5307 funding Metro is waiting on (referred to in the agenda above).
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/16/05 08:55 AM |
New Chron education reporter quotes Anne Linehan
Anne Linehan is quoted in an education article by new Chronicle columnist reporter Jennifer Radcliffe today:
Anne Linehan, a mother of three in Spring, said she tries hard to make sure they read and study history during the summer. She was surprised to learn about the "summer slide" statistics for math skills.
"I work with my kids a lot," she said. "I didn't think about the math."
Here's hoping Radcliffe will boost the Chronicle's education coverage, which has seen its share of journalistic mishaps courtesy of reporter Jason Spencer. We wish her well.
UPDATE: I got the job right in the title (reporter!) and wrong in the body (not columnist). That's proof I should not be allowed to touch a keyboard until the Starbucks Red Eye has kicked in fully!
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 06/16/05 07:41 AM |
15 June 2005
McShan reports on HPD manpower shortage
Jeff McShan did some excellent reporting on HPD's manpower woes for KHOU-11 this evening.
The entire report should be read, but here are some excerpts:
For months, Houston police officers have been telling 11 News about what they're calling a severe shortage. They believe the shortage of police officers and detectives hinders their ability to fight crime, and often puts them in dangerous situations.
Union president Hans Marticiuc says he's hearing the cries for help, too.
"We're getting calls all the time," says Marticiuc, "We've got officers working a district by themselves, sometimes roll calls are two or three people for an entire roll call. The numbers just don't add up for the amount of calls that we have to cover."
If you live in Houston, you might be surprised to know that the number of officers working at HPD is actually 258 less than it was 11 years ago.
Since 1994: 893 officers have retired, 596 resigned, 412 were part of phase-downs, 156 were terminated and 60 officers died.
If you live in Houston and read this blog or listen to Chris Baker, you won't be surprised.
When asked how serious the situation is, "I think we're at a critical point. I think we're at a critical point and our council people need to prioritize here," Marticiuc says.
Mayor Bill White says he's working on a solution that includes adding five academy classes this year. There were none a year ago.
He blames the current situation on past administrations and an HPD retirement plan that wasn't fiscally responsible.
"The police contract was designed when I came in. It was designed to provide an incentive for people to see if they made the pay raise and then resign, because you paid on your retirement based on your last two weeks," says Mayor White.
The city has not been adding enough cadet classes. It's been a massive failure of leadership on the part of Mayor White and his council, as they've spent time and money on other priorities. Certainly, the Brown Administration did not leave matters in great shape, but he's gone. Mayor White has been in office long enough to tackle this problem -- or to focus on other issues, like Tasers and new badges for cops and downtown parks and finding overtime pay for some cops to harass downtown pedestrians. This is Mayor White's problem now, not Lee Brown's, and he has dropped the ball thus far.
"We're already at a point where we don't have enough officers on the streets to back each other up," says Marticiuc.
He says additional money for overtime to place officers where they are needed the most could help.
Council member Ada Edwards disagrees. "Over 80 percent of our budget goes to public safety, so for me it's not the dollars, it's the management and I don't know who's to blame, but I think we really need to talk about it."
That may be the first time in her political life Ada Edwards has ever suggested that it's not the dollars. Unfortunately, it IS partly the dollars. Cadet classes take money. Hiring police officers from other cities takes money. Keeping officers from retiring or seeking police jobs elsewhere takes money. It IS about the dollars, dollars that Mayor White and his council have diverted to other priorities.
Chief Hurtt says he knows his men and women in blue are short-handed.
"I think the citizens of Houston should really continue to support them because we all realize several years, we went without having any academy and several people have retired in the last year or so, but the Houston Police Department is up to meeting the challenge," says Hurtt.
We DO support the HPD rank and file. We just wish Mayor White, his council, and his police chief could help them out with some more bodies.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 06/15/05 10:50 PM |
SAFEclear costs go up up up! (cont'd)
City Controller Annise Parker's limited audit of the SAFEclear program was released today.
The audit estimates costs for SAFEclear from January 2005 to June 2005, and then for the next fiscal year. The full report is available here in PDF format.
Last week, HPD presented to council an estimate of $1,586,767 for the cost of SAFEclear from January 2005 to June 2005. The controller's estimate of costs over that period is $1,643,917.
For the coming fiscal year, the report notes:
The HPD and the Administration represented to City Council on June 8, 2005 that FY 2006 estimated expenses would total $3,000,000 and the expenses not covered by Metro and freeway segment fees would be $600,000.
We believe the estimated expense not covered by Metro and the freeway segment fees to be $878,000 or $278,000 greater than HPD's estimate, if the Safe Clear Program remains unchanged.
Parker estimates the total cost of SAFEclear for next year will be $3,288,000 -- or nearly ten percent more than HPD/White Administration estimates that were presented to council roughly one week ago.
Interestingly, this ominous paragraph is included in the first page of Parker's report:
HPD estimated $578,300 for towing costs for the five-month period, but only has $567,000 available to pay for free tows for the period. This $567,000 is derived from a contractual monthly cap of $25,000 ($125,000 for the five-month period for free tows; February through June 2005), plus Metro's $442,000 contribution received in May 2005. To date, HPD has forwarded to the Controller's Office $1,143,000 in Supplemental Allocation Letters, which is $576,000 in excess of City Council's authorization of $567,000. Until HPD resolves this matter, the Controller's Office has suspended payments to the Operators. [Emphasis supplied]

News that this critical report was ready for release may have prompted action with the tow companies by the city. Parker's report notes the following:
[I]n the afternoon of June 14, 2005, we were supplied with a new draft contract between the City and its Tow Truck Operators. The effects of these contracts, if any, on this report have not been determined."
We would email Mayor White's staff for that information, but neither Frank Michel nor Pat Trahan have bothered to answer any number of emails that we have sent to them previously requesting various information. Apparently, that's how customer-oriented government works! So, we'll encourage any of the local reporters who read this blog to follow up on that with the White Administration.
RELATED COVERAGE: Doug Miller (KHOU-11), Matt Stiles (Houston Chronicle).
PREVIOUSLY: SAFEclear costs go up up up! (bH).
ANNE LINEHAN ADDS: The genesis of SAFEclear was a trial program on the Katy Freeway. Since that program seemed to go without a hitch, the mayor decided to implement it on ALL of Houston's freeways, all at once. When a hue and cry went up about the highly punitive nature of the original plan, the mayor was forced to scramble up a Plan B. Now we learn that the mayor's Plan B completely overwhelmed HPD:
"We think the program was poorly vetted in the beginning, that it was placed with a police administrative division that was unprepared to handle it. They were overwhelmed," said Annise Parker, Houston City Controller.
Houston police had problems handling an avalanche of paperwork verifying that wrecker drivers had really towed the cars they claimed to have towed.
If there is anything we have learned about Mayor White, it is that when he wants something done, he expects everyone involved to jump. We can imagine that HPD was told to jump, and we can see what the result of that was.
UPDATE (06-16-2005): I didn't comment on the Chronicle story last night, because I assumed it was a work in progress, but that's pretty much the version of the story that ran today. It's really some weak reporting. A separate critique will follow with specifics later.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 06/15/05 06:41 PM |
MS-13 has met its match: HPD's Operation Jaywalking
Yesterday the Chronicle had a story on the first day of HPD's jaywalking crackdown:
Bicycle messenger Ken Fairbanks sat down in the shade outside Chase Tower shortly after 3 p.m. Monday, unfolded the ticket he'd been issued minutes earlier on Main Street, and said it came as a surprise.
"I hardly ever get tickets," he said. "There was a person kind of lollygagging along and so I passed him."
Fairbanks said he and other bicycle messengers who work downtown were aware of the Houston Police Department crackdown on all traffic violations � pedestrians, bicycle riders, drivers � but he said he hadn't realized he was breaking any law by passing a car in the same lane.
He was ticketed on the first day of the latest phase of HPD's Downtown Mobility Initiative, a plan city leaders say is intended to deal with the dangers of congested streets and bad walking, biking or driving habits. The first phase focused on educating the public to obey traffic laws.
HPD spokesman John Cannon said the eight police officers assigned to intersections during morning rush hour on Monday stopped 190 people and issued 23 citations, 14 to pedestrians and nine to drivers.
Three people got citations for crossing the street in the middle of the block and 11 for crossing against the light, Cannon said. Four drivers were ticketed for running red lights and five for "other" violations.
That's weird -- I thought HPD required cameras to handle the problem of red light running.
For the proper perspective on Operation Jaywalking you had to listen to Chris Baker (KTRH-740) yesterday. Ken Charles was on air with him and this was their take: MS-13 has finally met its match, as gang members will be so blinded by shiny new police badges and distracted by new police shirts that they will walk right into HPD's jaywalking trap.
It's brilliant.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/15/05 05:42 PM |
Rad Sallee's Metro story, con't.
As I mentioned previously, Rad Sallee's Chronicle story presents both sides of Metro's new expansion plan, and is filled with interesting bites including this:
[...]the agency plans to build rail corridors served by specially outfitted buses, a system called bus rapid transit.
"Right now, we're projecting about 8,000 on the busiest one when they open," he said, referring to the North line from near downtown to Northline Mall.
[snip]
Wilson said opening-day ridership on the next planned light rail line, a crosstown route linking the University of Houston's central campus, Greenway Plaza and the Uptown-Galleria area, is likely to be 15,000.
But that will climb quickly, he predicted.
It's no secret how Metro builds rail ridership -- it cancels bus routes.
Sallee also talks about Rep. Culberson's appearance on Edd Hendee's show (KSEV-700) yesterday when Hendee expressed his displeasure with the expansion plan.
And the funniest part is where former Metro head Shirley DeLibero offers her thoughts on the new plan:
Former Metro President and CEO Shirley DeLibero said she is pleased to see a rail line was going near the Galleria.
As for the rest of the revised plan, she said, "As long as this (bus rapid transit) is a stopgap to the ultimate rail system, I'm OK."
What a relief! Shirley's okay with the plan. We can rest easy.
RELATED: White changes mobility plan (Owen Courreges, Lone Star Times), Sucking up all the oxygen... (Sedosi Alhambra)
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/15/05 12:47 PM |
MeMo's tip of the day
MeMo directs us to something that, uh, could come in handy? Not that we're advocating its use, of course...
No, no, no. Absolutely not.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/15/05 09:47 AM |
Why do Mayor White and Metro fear a new vote?
Now that Mayor White's new Metro plan is being widely discussed, some interesting things are coming to light.
Tom Bazan emailed the original ballot language from the 2003 referendum, printed in the Chronicle and translated by Lucas Wall. What immediately becomes apparent is how different the new plan is from the voter-approved plan. Here's an example:
3. While 73 miles of rail are included in the Metro Solutions plan, the financing package on the referendum provides only $640 million of bonds to implement the plan's first decade, including construction of 22 light rail miles. The remaining 51 rail miles could be built by 2025 if voters authorize additional bonds in or after 2009. Voters would also have to end Metro road spending after 2014.
That is from the 2003 referendum. Here is what Metro says about the new plan:
The implementation plan also includes more miles of commuter rail than were in the Referendum plan, as well as 40 miles of Signature Express/Suburban BRT instead of 14.
The net result is 97 miles of rapid transit instead of the 36 envisioned in METRO Solutions.
Today's Chronicle story by Rad Sallee (thank goodness he's handling this right now -- his stories are presenting both sides; and we'll go through the whole story in a later post) includes this:
Metro spokesman George Smalley said the revised plan would provide "equivalent service" to light rail until the changeover. "Everything is the same except for the wheels," he said.
But [Barry Klein, president of the Houston Property Rights Association] said the ballot made no mention of the UH-Galleria route, commuter rail on U.S. 290 or an intermodal facility on the Northside near his home. All are envisioned in the new proposal.
And how does Smalley get around that? Oh, you know, it was in the fine print:
Smalley said the changes are covered by a footnote to the ballot resolution that says: "Final scope, length of rail segments or lines, and other details, together with implementation schedule, will be based upon demand and completion of the project development process including community input."
Yeah, I'll bet that fine print was heavily advertised while Metro was trying to sell its Solutions plan.
And we previously heard about an intermodal center, which is a developer's dream.
The icing on the cake, so to speak, is this letter to the Houston Business Journal from 10-3-2003 by Metro Chairman Arthur Schechter; specifically:
Voters will be able to hold Metro accountable throughout the process because they will have the opportunity to vote to continue funding based on their experience with Metro Solutions up to that point.
Okay then! Give us the opportunity to vote on what is a substantially different plan. We've seen quite a bit of Metro Solutions enacted (or not, as in the case of reduced bus service), so let the voters tell Metro what they think of Metro's stewardship of our tax dollars so far. As Barry Klein said in today's Chronicle story:
"They [Metro officials] make all these quick switches, and they don't think they have to bring it back to a vote," he said. "If they think they have public support, they shouldn't hesitate to put it on the ballot."
One wonders if Metro officials and Mayor White already know it would be tough to get this plan approved.
Posted by Anne Linehan @ 06/15/05 07:28 AM |
14 June 2005
Kinsley: Are editorial boards relevant?
Today, Mr. Kathryn Kase's editorial board put its anti-death penalty spin on a Monday Supreme Court decision. The editorial is typically lackluster, and concludes as follows:
Texas' full-throated resort to the death penalty demands that all procedures pertaining to this maximum punishment be applied with the utmost, unquestioned prosecutorial integrity and that those operations are reviewed by courts that can acknowledge what may be going on.
Courts that can acknowledge what may be going on? What does that even mean? The writing seems less than ideal.
Fortunately, local attorney and blogger William Dyer has dissected the case in a more thoughtful and analytical fashion on his blog. His conclusion is particularly strong. Perhaps even ideal!
This latest instance of a blogger upstaging the high and mighty Chronicle editorial board brings to mind a story in the New York Times about Michael Kinsley's efforts to shake up the LA Times editorial pages in his role as opinion page editor:
"Michael does like to ask questions, such as, 'In today's world, what is the continuing relevance of a newspaper editorial board?' "
Mr. Kinsley, who earned a reputation as an iconoclastic editor at Harpers, The New Republic and Slate, seems determined to answer that question by upending the established notion of the newspaper editorial.
The entire New York Times story is worth reading. Kinsley does seem determined to bring his opinion pages into the internet age.
And one rather suspects that he doesn't inflict stories about riding his bicycle on his readership.
Posted by Kevin Whited @ 06/14/05 10:44 PM |
[Previous 20 Entries] [Next 20 Entries]